should it be compulsary for university students to attend the classes?

@tenrajj (911)
Bhutan
March 19, 2011 11:14am CST
Some people say that university students should be required to attend classes while others say that going to classes should be optional for students. What do you think? I believe that students, be it school students or university students, they should be attending the classes. I don't think university students can learn without going to classes. Personal experience can help people learn about themseleves and the world outside the classroom, but when it comes to learning about academic subjects, students need to be in class.
3 people like this
14 responses
@peavey (16936)
• United States
19 Mar 11
What's the point of going to school if you don't go to class? Isn't that what it's all about? Universities are not huge amusement parks, regardless of what some students think. If a student isn't going to class and learning, she or he should be kicked out. There are those who want to learn who would gladly take their place.
1 person likes this
• Mexico
20 Mar 11
It is not binary, you do not have to choose to either go to class or think that the University is a huge amusement park (actually, most of the amusement parks I know are bigger than most of the Universities I know), there are other alternatives. Going to class is not the only way to learn. Actually, when you are an advanced student and you are on a basic class (for example, if you have previous experience on the matter), most of the other student's questions will be uninteresting to you and it can happen that attending a class is actually wasting your time (that you could use to learn something else, for example). I do not understand why some people think that the Academia is never wrong and that the way they think and say things should be done is the way things should be done, even when the justifications they give are often just something they are repeating somehow. Learning doesn't only occur inside of the classroom. Lots of people think it does and that is the reason why you have so many low-quality profesionals in almost every career.
@tenrajj (911)
• Bhutan
20 Mar 11
Going to class teaches students how to work with other member of the class. Many times students will be given group works or assignments. This is different from what they did in secondary school. Here they are with people from different backgrounds and expeciences. In this situation, they learn how to handle working with people different from themselves to achieve a common goal. Going to the class also teaches students responsibility and discipline. Having to be at a particular place at a particular time prepares them for getting a job. Being at a place on time with an assignment completed prepares them for carrer.
• Mexico
20 Mar 11
Yes, if you want a job, that may be the right thing to do. As an entrepreneur, I do not like jobs and I would never hire someone for a "job". I have worked with other people in projects that we have developed but it was nothing like a job: we set out goals and achieved them. We did not need to make a commitment or even "be there in time". None of us needed to "learn responsibility and discipline" because just wanting to do what we were doing was enough to have everybody be responsible and do their part. It is easy to get to where you need to be on time, no need to "learn" to be responsible for 4 years. Now, I have learned a lot more about working in groups while actually working with people than by attending my classes. Less than 20% of the classes I have had had even 1 exercise or homework or anything to be done in a group. Most of the time you only have a teacher that talks about the class' subject and people asking questions, sometimes, the teacher just gives you some copies and reads them with you... Now, about the different "backgrounds", the truth is that, in the University, most people don't really have a "background" they just finished high school and they want to keep partying... but mainly, they just have different personalities but no real experience that you can learn from... most of the time (there are exceptions). Now, I am not saying that you shouldn't attend your classes but I do believe that making attendance compulsary will just make people learn to obey, follow the rules and take orders as well as learn to tolerate a routine... which are all activities that are contrary to creativity and will make people into good low-level employees... So yes, go to every class and if you just do it you will learn a lot of things. Still, I can personally do a better job at teaching myself than most schools can. For example, I have learned programming, 3D modelling and animation, hypnosis, piano, Italian and calculus, among other things by myself without ever taking one single class about those subjects.
@psyches (59)
• United States
19 Mar 11
University students are adults, you cannot force them to do something and should not have to take attendance. If the fail the class due to not attending enough, that is their problem--not the problem of the school not making them go.
• Mexico
20 Mar 11
I agree with you a 100%. Some schools make it more important that you attend all your classes than actually having learned something useful and use it for their students to pass. I do not want people who can be there on time all the time to work for me, I want people who can think for themselves and solve problems. Schools tend to presuppose that you cannot learn outside of the classroom but that is because education is an enormous business all in all.
• Philippines
20 Mar 11
checking of attendance is just for primary and middle school. they are adults and they know what they're doing. they know the consequences of their acts. some absentees are smarter than those who are always present,take it from my experience.
@JoyfulOne (6232)
• United States
19 Mar 11
Just my opinion, but I think if a student is paying to go to a class, then they should attend it in person and not rely on others notes or something. If not attending, then what is the point of going?! For instance, the professor might make a discussion about something, but it isn't in somebody's notes, or listed anywhere else, then they've missed something potentially important to their learning. As a parent, if I found out my kids were skipping classes, and I was paying for their education, I would be upset. Going to the classes shows that you're giving it an honest try. And for those that don't attend, maybe they're not honestly interesting in the classes and aren't taking their advanced education seriously enough.
@tenrajj (911)
• Bhutan
20 Mar 11
yea i agree with you.In short, by going to class students learn more than just information from the teacher. They also learn how to learn, how to work with others and how to work responsibly. These are not optional skills in life, so attending classes should not be optional in college.
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
25 Mar 11
The basic theories are best discussed inside the classroom. That is where professors and instructors teach us how to use a T-square, look into a microscope, argue about Marx academically, and Sigmund Freud, too. How else can we glare at a teacher for infuriating our youthful emotions if not for classroom encounters. Stay put, you younglings, the classroom is where you should be. After the fundamentals, you have all the time to learn outside, at your own risk. But fear not, by that time, you are well equipped for the battle of life.
• United States
23 Mar 11
Yeah I agree how in the world can they learn if they do not sit in class and learn the lectures taught. It is quite difficult to develop discipline if you do not have a teacher to guide you with the daily lessons.
• Philippines
20 Mar 11
it should not be a requirement. students should exercise their freewill. it's up to them if they want to attend the class. teachers are just paid by them in the first place.
• Mexico
20 Mar 11
It has happened to me to know the subject better than the teacher and yet be forced to take her class and do her simple and boring exercises and listen to her lousy explanation just because of the attendance requirements.
@sunny5u (2069)
• India
20 Mar 11
Hi tenrajj, irrespective of school students or university students one should attend classes, we learn or join in some course only when we are not much aware of it, so listening to classes help us in grasping more of it, in school we will be told each and every part of the chapter, but in university its just an introduction of the subject or chapter will be given to us, so in my view attending the classes is important....
@galileo2008 (1141)
• Philippines
19 Mar 11
If those students don't attend classes, then what's the purpose of them paying the tuition? Unless they will enroll to an online class or just do homeschooling, then it would be understandable. I couldn't figure out why they need not to attend the class, how can they learn if that's the case?
@Torunn (8609)
• Norway
20 Mar 11
No, not really. I've taken quite a few classes in which I've done well without having been to many lectures, and I've taken exams that haven't been very good at all even though I've been to nearly all the classes. For me, a point with the university is to learn how to study, and not everyone studies best in class. Plus, if you have a bad lecturer, you're just wasting your time. The most annoying thing I know as a teacher are the pupils that except me to just say, word for word, what's in the textbook. If I can't bring different examples and facts, there no use in me standing there, repeating the book, word for word. Usually skipped out on lectureres who did that, and I don't regret it at all.
@pokumon (644)
• United States
21 Mar 11
I don't think that students should be required to attend classes. Some classes are absurdly early in the morning and I wouldn't dream of going to them unless I had an exam. This was the case with organic chemistry. Maybe I didn't learn quite as well as students who always attended class, but it was my choice. I'm fine with certain classes having attendance and being mandatory, but I think it's stupid to make all lectures so because some professors just aren't good lecturers. You could definitely learn from reading a book.
@Liliac26 (557)
• Romania
19 Mar 11
I think in most universities it is compulsory to attend a certain amount of classes. I think to extend it to all of them would be a little harsh. Some students have to work their way through college and can't be there all the time. But I think a certain amount of attendance should be required. If reading a few books would be sufficient, then there wouldn't be any classes at all. A teacher/professor can explain certain concepts to students, answer questions, give additional information, etc.
@aghiuta (525)
• Canada
20 Mar 11
I think that attending classes and paying attention would make it much easier for a student to learn.When I was in university in Romania,I went to university and I did not attend classes because I was in very intensive training(competitional swimming) so I had to study by myself, and go for the exams.It was very hard.It is very different when you learn from books,or you learn in school, with teachers,participation... And if you really listen,you pick up a lot in classand that means that you have to study less.
• Philippines
20 Mar 11
hello! Well it should be a must! How can you be graded by your teacher? Hahaha... Kidding aside, Of course yes. Learning can be easier when you attend classes. Your teachers guide your learning. You get to interact with other people and sometimes reason out with them. You learn a lot of stuffs.
• Australia
20 Mar 11
I personally believe it is impossible to get properly educated without going to university. Once, I missed my uni for a week, i had to struggle the whole semester to get back on the track. It is immensely important to attend the lectures and tutorials.