This is a RUMMAGE SALE not a THRIFT STORE!

United States
June 17, 2011 11:18pm CST
I know I have to be as cheap as possible with things so I spend a few weekends when I have some cash to spare at rummage sales. So this week we were surprised with a few dollars we had not counted on and being the weather was simply perfect! Now we went to several subdivisions that we had seen advertised. And I noticed a trend that many were charging thrift store prices! And I don't mean on nice things but everything... they'd have lists up that would say $2 kids shirts, $3 pants for example. I've ran across this before but not 9 out of 10 being that way. I know the economy is bad but do they realize what their stuff is worth rummage sale wise? Unless its something I truly like I won't pay more than a dollar. I prefer under a doller if possible. As last weekend there was this house that always sells their stuff cheap depends on what their mood is or whatever... but they've gone as low as 5 things for a dollar!!! And wouldn't you know it I was slim pickings for spare money when I saw them set up. Also an ad online said how this rummage had the sizes I was looking for and even brand names and then went on to say how they organized everything and even bins for a quarter so fine.... get out that way and guess what they had 5 things in one box and the one I really liked was $5! OUCH! Yeah... liars. Another rummage I saw yesterday the lady wouldn't come down on her stuff.... she said she wouldn't knock anything down on the first day. And she had a couple things in the under $1 range but they were for things that were several years out of style. So I dunno if I'll waste the gas bothering going back tomorrow or just realize there will be something else before the summer is over.
4 people like this
14 responses
@coffeebreak (17798)
• United States
19 Jun 11
I am a "vet" yard saler! I have them and go to them! But I do know what you mean about them being higher prices. I know they need to make money to, but at the same time...it is used stuff and if you want a higher price you put in in the local paper freebie or something like that, not at a yard sale as everyone that goes to a YS is looking for cheap. That is what they are all about! I just look, if I find anything I want and the price is to high, I make them an offer and if they don't take it, I put the item back. I had noticed last few summers tho...lot of things still there and lot of people walking away with nothing in their hands! Either they had next to nothing or their prices were to high. The point of a YS is to get rid of stuff and make a few extra bucks. I don't know why they think they can do either if their prices are high! When I had them...(in an apt now!) I'd have things priced properly. Low or not very high. I wanted to get rid of the stuff and make a few bucks. Always did well. My daughter got in on it and she'd sell kids stuff like crazy..especially clothes. But what really got to me... I am a nice person and always there to help someone out. I'd have something for a dollar...totally fair and cheap and well worth it for the item. Some one would ask me if I'd take 50 cents for it. I'd look at them, they looked sincere and maybe low on money, so I'd say okay....being nice and helpful....then they'd take out a $20 bill to pay me for it! At first, I thought, okay, they need to stretch their $10. But the last several sales I had before I moved here...the first one...they'd offer me a quarter on a dollar item or a dollar on a $5 item. At first, I'd take it just to get rid of the item, then when they'd give me a large bill to pay for it and it'd take all my change I started to think about this and realize...they are playing me for a fool and all I am doing is trying to be nice! So, I decided to make things firm. Some things I'd accept offer on, (the higher priced items) and others (lower priced especially a dollar or less) I wouldn't come down. I'd just say no to their offer. SOmetimes they'd take it anyway, other times they wouldn't...but someone else did. I also saw the "system" and noticed that the first 2-3 hours in the morning were when the horders would arrive...and then lesser the rest of the day...so what I'd do is stay firm on alot of things, and then lower prices after 12:00. THat way I got the best I could for most and as much as I could for the rest. What didn't sell I'd box up for the next one. Worked out really great. But I found that being nice is not something you can when you have a yard sale as they will just take advantage of you. I mean, a dollar is a fair price on most anything and they offer me half that? And then pay with a large bill? I"d also tell them I cant change a $20 for a total under $5...and they'd always pull out a $5 of exact change. YS is a game on both sides...you just have to know how to play it where you are!
1 person likes this
@coffeebreak (17798)
• United States
21 Jun 11
WOW! Justice for a buck!?!?! Man oh man did you make out!!! That's great. But like you, I don't haggle unless I really like the item and think it is a bit high. I either pay what they ask or not get it. And often, pay what they ask if I think it is fair. And even when I do haggle...I don't rip them apart. A couple bucks lower but not half of what they ask! I priced items at what I would pay for them at a yard sale. Some I would consider lowering if asked, others, I didn't as I figure...if it don't sell I can always use it again. But when they'd offer me pennies for a dollar item, I said no.. I didn't care if it sold or I trashed it but I was not going to be insulted with my own items.
• United States
22 Jun 11
Yep Justice jeans for $1. The Justice skort was .50 they had, it was a size too big but I don't mind storing it for another year til she fits it. I didn't realize it either but I got another pair of Justice jeans at Salvation Army for .49 when they had their deal last labor day... which I better mark down on my calendar while I'm thinking about it just incase they have that same special I'll stock up on jeans again. Unfortunatly I didn't have the room to keep all the stuff I tried to sell last summer. We're done having kids and I need to room to store all the stuff for them to grow into. I agree no haggling down a huge amount or trying to scam someone. I just know what I want to pay for things and that's $1 or less depending on the item.
• United States
20 Jun 11
Yeah, I've heard of people like that. I don't care to haggle unless I really like the item. Usually I like their prices or I don't. I usually carry say $20 of that only one $5 bill the rest singles or quarters. I just want a deal. Like last summer there was a lady who wanted $1.50 ea pair of jeans. I put them down then she picked them up and looked at the and gave the 2 pairs to me for that because the cuffs were frayed. Now if they were in the hardly worn aka the kid grew faster than the wear on the clothing. The Justice jeans were a steal @ $1 ea, looked new like everything they had and they run around $35-40 a pair full price! And some nike pants & shorts that looked new for .50 ea! I was excited and they only had 2 small card tables and I was going to pass it by but the girls wanted to look.
@cutepenguin (6431)
• Canada
19 Jun 11
Strange - maybe some of these people just hadn't been to garage sales? I went to one the other day where I found some good toys for a good price. $4 for a set of wooden puzzles. Around here, these would have cost $10 at a thrift store or a swapmeet. (or $28 new!) I guess it's getting harder to find good deals though.
1 person likes this
• Canada
25 Jun 11
That makes sense. But people naturally tend to think their stuff is worth whatever they paid for it, so a lot of people will charge too much.
• United States
20 Jun 11
Or they were thinking that if a thrift store can get that price so can I! If you know the price of it and you figure it should sell for 25% or less of original cost.
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
21 Jun 11
some people who are holding yard sales do it to make money. others do it to get rid of stuff so they sell stuff cheap. those are the ones you want to go to. they generally say moving sale, that sort of thing.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Jun 11
We all want to make money when we hold a rummage sale but there is a difference in pricing at a yard sale versus going to a thrift store or shopping a clearance rack.
@carolscash (9492)
• United States
19 Jun 11
I have been to sales like this too and I find that it is just best to leave and go somewhere else. Some of the better neighborhoods here will have nice name brand clothes that have hardly been worn but they will want the price I could pay retail for. I was at one a year ago or so and they had Coach purses that had been used and they were asking $100 for them. I do not know what they cost in the stores, but I would never pay that kind of money at a yard sale for one. I really didn't like them anyway, but still that is too much money for a used purse.
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Jun 11
Exactly, if I can find it on clearance for that price I may as well get it new. Sadly, a used coach purse is worth around $100 at a consignment shop. I think you can find them at goodwill for about $50. Key question is it authentic or fake? There are people out there who change purses with the season, how they can afford this I do not know.
@bmorehouse1 (1028)
• United States
21 Jun 11
I don't go to rummage sales, yard sales, etc much anymore. When my kids were smaller I used to. I did go to one a while back because they had a chair I wanted. Of course it was overpriced! I asked if she would come down any and she looked at me like I was crazy. Of course not! Well I walked away. She can keep her chair! I bet if she got it sold that she had to come down on the price. Evidently people don't want to get rid of their stuff very badly or they wouldn't price things so high! If it were me I would rather get rid of it rather than carry it back into the house.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Jun 11
very true, I'd rather sell it then store it another day. But who knows, the St Vincent DePaul thrift store thinks a beat up couch is worth over $100. Maybe she thought she'd get the same prices?!?! I don't know what people are thinking or not sometimes.
@Shellyann36 (11385)
• United States
20 Jun 11
We hit a few good one's a few weeks ago. We actually got quite a bit of stuff for $25! One lady was having a moving sale and she had lots of decorations/curtains/table clothes and such for sale. We struck a great deal on several items that match my home decor. The new place she was moving to had different carpeting and paint so all of her drapes, decorations did not match. I was so happy! Sorry you did not have any luck.
• United States
20 Jun 11
That was pretty lucky it's hard to find decor that goes with your "look" and at a reasonable price no less. I had luck at 4 rummages of 4 subdivisions and more houses than I can count. We found barbies & bratz dolls for .25 ea w/ CLOTHES! Justice jeans for $1ea, nike clothes for .50 ea, 12 things (she had 12 for $5... so my girls got skirts, skorts, and some shoes), big kid footy pj's for .50 (my eldest said she's wear them despite them being boy themes on them). We did ok, I guess but for the amount of houses we stopped at we didn't do well. But I was glad to find something.
@GardenGerty (157665)
• United States
3 Sep 15
If I go to the bother of putting stuff in a sale it is to get rid of it, without having to cart it out myself. I hate it when stuff is overpriced. Thrift stores are even beginning to up their prices a lot as well.
@oscar6 (1938)
• United States
18 Jun 11
That doesnt sound like a very fun time. I too do not buy anything that is over a dollar unless I really like it. I dont go garage selling to spend a ton of money. I go to get a good deal. If I wanted to spend a ton of money I would go to a department store in the local mall. I would be upset with this too but I think it is because of the economy.
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Jun 11
My hubby and a friend even call these type of rummages mortgage payment rummage sales because as you said a rummage sale is supposed to be cheap not thrift store, e-bay ect pricing. Atleast it got us out of the house and something to do +they behaved themselves and got some barbies as a reward and being the best deal I found for .25 ea!
@dragon54u (31636)
• United States
18 Jun 11
Things are tough all over, aren't they? I've noticed some of the yard sales near my house have much higher prices than I'm used to. One was selling purses for $10 each! It's pretty bad when a person can't even afford to shop at a yard sale.
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Jun 11
$10?!?! That's there forsure when you can get a decent new one for $30 or less new. The only way that would of been a deal is if it was a high end purse.... and if you can afford a high end purse you'd sell it another way that would generate more money. Yes it is bad when you can't afford to shop at yard sales because they think because a thrift store or e-bay can command those prices they can too!
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
29 Jun 11
I do not go to rummage sales, though I have been considering it. I frequent salvation army and goodwill a lot more. When it comes to stuff though, if I were to go to a yard / rummage sale I'd expect things to be no more then fifty cents to one dollar when it comes to clothes UNLESS the things are still nice / barely worn, but then I'd also expect them to have sold it to a plato's closet or something like that.
• United States
5 Sep 11
It's been a while since I've gone to any yard/garage/rummage sales. I haven't been to any at all since my boyfriend and I moved to Florida, so I don't know if that's the case here or not in terms of pricing. I do know, though, that there are some thrift shops with decent stuff at good prices, so I know where to head if I need anything in particular. However, my closet is overflowing with clothes, so I really haven't any need to go shopping--not even yardsaling or thrifting.
@free_man (7330)
• United States
19 Jun 11
Hi SnuggleBunnies. Sounds like they need to look at what they have and realize it isn't made of Gold. I won't buy anything from a garage sale that is more then fifty cents. I don't usually find anything really more then that anyway here in my home town. Good luck hope you find more bargains next time you go out.
• United States
19 Jun 11
I'll pay a dollar for jeans but not much more. Though the jeans I found were 2 sizes too big BUT they were in excellent shape and retail for up to $40
• United States
19 Jun 11
That is pretty sad that she would not lower the price. My thinking is that if I was holding a rummage sale and someone asked me to lower the price, I certainly would. Though I understand she was trying to make a few bucks but what if she does not sell them all. My thoughts always with any rummage sale is that if we can get anything out of the selling items I would jump at it. What else would we do with the stuff after the sale is over. That would also encourage customers to come back in the event that I had another one. Not everyone is the same but she at least could have taken into consideration that you were interested. No I would not go back because then I would be wasting more gas to return therefore unless there was something I absolutely had to have I would not return.
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Jun 11
That's just it these people wonder why they have so much left to donate. I went yesterday just to see if there were more houses open and I wanted to get out of the house. The lady had the gaul to have a sign up that said buy 2 get 1 equal or lesser value free! My hubby even had this look of WTH? Needless to say I did not look much further than the sign she had. But I did find another one that was new and as I mentioned to another person found Justice jeans for $1, nike stuff for .50 and all in hardly worn shape to boot.
@bostonphil (4459)
• United States
18 Jun 11
I love garage sales and have gone for many years - and I mean for many years. I know what you mean. I have gone to many garage sales where they try to charge thrift store prices. And thrift store prices are high these days. I refuse to pay thrift store prices for garage sales. I also do not like to bargain so I do not offer a lower price. Usually the persons who put on these type of garage sales do not have very successful ones. They often have long faces and are in bad moods. I do not drive and I do not care to take a bus to garage sales so I only stick to ones in my neighborhood. This does limit me. As for church sales and rummage sales, many groups have good ones but often they are unrealistic in pricing. And the pricing is uneven. Some items are priced too low and others are priced too high. Clothes are one item that seem to be priced too high. Remember, there will always be another garage sale. I go to sales with an open mind. I almost never find what I am looking for but often find something I was not expecting. I am open to possibilities.
• United States
19 Jun 11
You are exactly right you never know what you find til you look. I will only ask the price if the rest of their things are reasonably priced so I know it won't be a shock when I hear the reply.