sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

16 year old in custody under the Patriot Act  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics 3 years ago

FBI arrested a 16 year old boy in North Carolina a few months ago for being a "terrorist" and a "enemy combatant" under the patriot act.
According to Annette Lundeby (the boys mother)of Oxford, N.C., armed FBI agents and local police stormed her home around 10 p.m. on March 5, looking for her son, Ashton. The officers presented a federal search warrant and seized the tenth-grader's computer, cell phone and bank statements.

Ashton was then taken to a juvenile facility in South Bend, Ind., charged with making a bomb threat in Indiana from his home computer.
No bomb making materials were found in his home. His mom thinks someone hacked into his computer and made those threats.

Sence then his mother has had little access to him. The FBI is not talking to her or anyone about it. And her son has yet to see a court room or a judge (after two months). WHy? Because when someone is charged under the patriot act ALL their constitutional rights are suspended.

"We have no rights under the Patriot Act to even defend them, because the Patriot Act basically supersedes the Constitution," she told WRAL-TV. "It wasn't intended to drag your barely 16-year-old, 120-pound son out in the middle of the night on a charge that we can't even defend."

http://www.freedomsphoeni...

I am still researching this issue. I have just found about it. Even if the boy made the threats I not think he is an "enemy combatant" and he should still have his constitutional rights. THe legal process should handle this. What do you think?
Is the partriot act being abused in this situation?

 

politics
sponsors
Local Electronic Stores
Find Local Electronics Stores& Get
yellowpages.com

Criminal Check- $19.95
Instant criminal, felony-sexual offender checks-Updated daily!
www.Intelius.com

criminal investigations
View Anyone's Criminal History& Investigate Backgrounds In Seconds.
www.InstantCheckMate.com

gewcew23 (5064) response was accepted on 5/28/2009.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  patriot act, 16 year old, computer, fbi, rights suspended
 
1. myLot reputation of 82/100. spalladino (11857)   ranked 127 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

No, this incident does not appear to qualify and is very disturbing to say the least. Making threats via the internet isn't something new and it's always been dealt with by law enforcement in a routine fashion that did not include your basic constitutional rights being removed under the guise of the Patriot Act. Keep us updated, Lil, if you learn anything else.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I am still trying to figure out how he is an enemy combantant or domestic terrorist. He has not ties to a terrorist group that has been reported. If he even did the threats than it looks like a stupid prank pulled off by an immature 16 year old. HEck a bunch of teen agers played mailbox baseball in our neighborhood this weekend. Lots of distroyed mail boxes. When they find them are they now "enemy combantants"? Yes if he did the threats he should be charged. But not under the partriot act. But in a regualr court.
I hate the fact that the patriot act is "above" our constitution. NOThing should be above our constitution.


myLot reputation of 82/100. spalladino (11857)   ranked 127 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I couldn't agree with you more. This is a serious violation of this boy's rights.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

yep. But it looks like so far no one but his mom is standing up for him.

Local Electronic Stores Find Local Electronics Stores & Get  yellowpages.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 84/100. milkmaid (375)   3 years ago

I think the Patriot Act has been abused all along. We should not have a document that is held higher than our Constitution. We should not have a document that allows U.S. citizens to be held without their rights at all, no matter the fear level in the country. That is exactly what the terrorists want- for us to sacrifice our values because we are scared. The Patriot Act has been used in lots of ways it wasn't intended to.

We don't know what, if anything, the FBI has found on his computer. I don't think that he intended to carry out any threat, but I don't know. For all we know, he made the threat as a joke. 16 year olds come up with some stupid stuff. Then again, maybe his mom is right, and his computer was hacked.
They had a federal search warrant, which means some judge thought that there was enough evidence to check it out. The fact that he has been held for two months makes me think there is something on there- if he is innocent and there was nothing to find, he would have been released. It doesn't take two months to snoop someone's hard drive, and every second that they hold him makes it worse for the FBI if he is released without being charged. That's not to say the FBI hasn't made some colossally stupid moves in the past, but one would hope they have learned from them.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

We will have to wait and see what happens. But I still think this is a HUGE over reaction and show why we should NOT have the patriot act.


myLot reputation of 84/100. milkmaid (375)  3 years ago

No argument here! I have always thought the Patriot Act was just a tool to circumvent our laws. Maybe this will get it repealed.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

only if the mom is willing to sue the federal government over it.

Criminal Check- $19.95 Instant criminal, felony-sexual offender checks-Updated daily!  www.Intelius.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 48/100. sndcain36 (2691)   3 years ago

Hell yeah it's being abused...if there is a more glaring act of abuse I don't know what it is....

Only crap is there no such thing as COMMON SENSE anymore? This is completely outrageous. I wonder if it would help if the mother contacted her Rep in Congress?


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

http://www.wral.com/news/local/story/5049867/
Here is a local story on it out of north carolina.

In it it says "In a bi-partisan effort, Rep. Jerrold Nadler, D-N.Y., and Rep. Jeff Flake, R-Ariz., last month introduced in the U.S. House of Representatives a bill that would narrow subpoena power in a provision of the Patriot Act, called the National Security Letters, to curb what some consider to be abuse of power by federal law enforcement officers."

But it does not mention any north carolina elected officials in it. I hope she has contacted them. And if they are ignoring her than she needs to keep contacting them until they listen.


myLot reputation of 48/100. sndcain36 (2691)  3 years ago

Hannity O'Reilly and Beck should be told about this. They are exactly the loud mouths this situation needs.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I agree. Anyone know how to get a hold of them? I don't think htey read the email box that is listed on the fox site. So I do not know if they get the tip on the story. Any better way to contact them? I hate Rush but he would be another one. He is simple. Someone jsut needs to call in to his show.


myLot reputation of 48/100. sndcain36 (2691)  3 years ago

Hannity has a radio show, but I live on the west coast so I never catch it live.

I think Beck reads his email; he gets story ideas, and I know O'Reilly does because he reads them on the air....

I didn't even think of Limbaugh...


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

Someone reads the emails for them and then picks a few for them to read on air.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I will see who I can contact about it. The word needs to get out. None of the major news organizations are covering this. Which is strange and wrong. This is an abuse of power by homeland security. The whole country should be told about it.


myLot reputation of 67/100. anniepa (11669)   ranked 329 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

As much as I don't like Limbaugh, Hannity or the other conservative pundits you guys have mentioned, I agree letting them know about this wouldn't be a bad idea. I'd also like to suggest you contact some of the more liberal commentators like Keith, Rachel and Ed despite your feelings about them. I really think something like this should transcend liberal and conservative viewpoints, it's just plain WRONG no matter what side of the aisle you're on. I think I'll do that myself but if there are more than one it might be more likely to get their attention. I'm also going to try to "Twitter" them if I can figure out how. I signed up for Twitter but I've never tweeted.
Annie


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

thanks for the help annie. This poor kid can use all the help he can get. I can't help you with the twitter situation. I have never done it either.
I have an account...just not twittered or whatever you call it when you put out a message.


DesertRose1959 (35)  3 years ago

Our rights have been diminishing for quite sometime now, but never as quickly nor as insidiously as after 9/11 when the Patriot Act was instituted. It has opened a doorway to abuse that they will not voluntarily close. Rampant abuse of power seems to be the virus running through Washington not H1N1.
These abuses will continue until the American People stand up a s one and say no more. We have been quiet far too long. Has anyone noticed that Congress could care less what their constituents think? They pass laws without reading them, they do not listen to the protests of the people. They laugh or call them extremists, bottom line is they have lost their fear. I honestly believe that the only thing that will curtail their total disregard for the wishes of the People would be the loss of their jobs. It is our only leverage. There are so many measures coming before Congress that will affect our daily living that the concept boggles the mind.
This boy is the fist victim of their abuse, I have a sinking feeling there will be more ahead. Especially with the unrest that we are seeing throughout the Nation. The only thing I believe will see us through this is to stand together and speak as one voice. We must fight for our rights and remind Washington that they work for us not the Other way around!***On a side note: Glenn Beck also has a radio show the site does not have an on air phone number, it does have a blog, however. http://www.glennbeck.com/
Perhaps he gives a call in number during the show. Not sure, sorry wish I could be of more help.


myLot reputation of 67/100. anniepa (11669)   ranked 329 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

Hey, Lil, we're both Twitterers who have never tweeted...or whatever it is they do...lol!
Annie

criminal investigations View Anyone's Criminal History & Investigate Backgrounds In Seconds.  www.InstantCheckMate.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 90/100. DarthJustice (1780)   ranked 280 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

I agree. This definitely shows why we need to get rid of the Patriot Act. Even if the guy really did make those threats, I hardly think he's an 'enemy combatant' despite how wrong it was. There should be nothing in place that supercedes the Constitution and can easily strip someone of their constitutionally guaranteed rights.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I completely agree. But it seems the government doesn't.

Checkmagic Prints Quickenr Quickbooks checks on blank check paper.  www.checkmagic.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 62/100. gewcew23 (5064)   ranked 414 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

This just does not make any sense. Okay I get it that the 16 year old might have done something on the ignorant side of life, but what exactly is the crime he committed? Why is a threat a crime in the first place. I could say to you, Lilwonders that I am coming to steal all your candy, now that is a threat but hopefully you will not call the FBI on me.
Yes the Patriot act has been abused but simply having a Patriot act is an abuse of the Constitution.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

Here I will share my candy with you (handing you a pink starburst). But I won't share with the FBI. They don't deserve candy.

I agree that even having a patriot act is an abuse of the constitution.
I also think that people need to what up and realize that people's rights are being violated and the constituiton ignored.

This poor mom has been every where looking for help and no one can help her. Why? Because the patriot act give the government the right to ignore anyone they want.
While her son, who may have done a stupid thing, is sitting in jail for two months without legal councel and without any rights at all.

If I was that mom they would not like me very much. Besides sueing them I would be holding massive protests and pressing charges against not only the FBI but homeland security and every member of congress who voted for the patroit act.
Not to metion being on every TV channel I could get my hands on and giving interviews in every newspaper.


myLot reputation of 62/100. gewcew23 (5064)   ranked 414 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

Pink Starburst, that sounds good.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

They are my favorite.

Mortgage Rates at 2.25% $200,000 home mortgage for $764/mo. See New Payment. No SSN Required.  Mortgage.LeadSteps.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 45/100. murderistic (1046)   ranked 835 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

The USAPATRIOTACT is a disgusting excuse of heightened national security laws. It trumps over our basic constitutional and human rights. It needs to go.


myLot reputation of 84/100. milkmaid (375)  3 years ago

Absolutely. I was outraged when it passed, and anyone who has ever seen a government abuse it's own power knew it was only a matter of time before something like this happened. I do wonder how many other times similar things have happened, that we didn't hear about because it was much sooner after 9/11 or because it wasn't a 16 year old kid.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

xactly. I wonder how many other people this has happened to.


myLot reputation of 45/100. murderistic (1046)   ranked 835 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I think most of the time the abuses of the USAPATRIOTACT go unnoticed because it abuses the human rights of foreigners who happen to be Muslim. The act basically allows for legalized racial and religious discrimination. I mean, how can it not when it allows for arbitrary arrest?


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

Well this kids is not a muslim and is white. But I do think Homeland security and the FBI need to investigated. At worst this kid did a bad prank and should be held accontable for it.....but it not a crime that deserves this kind of punishment. Heck even serial killers are allowed more rights than this kid. he is not even allowed legal counsel or advice.


myLot reputation of 45/100. murderistic (1046)   ranked 835 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

Oh I know that, and that's why this case isn't being overlooked. If it was a Pakistani muslim boy in the same position, I doubt there would even be a thread about this, especially in his defense.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I would hope you would be wrong but you probly aren't. Which is sad.
As for this story...well CNN is not covering. Neither is FOX. Rush is not even talking about it. Only some bloggers, a few alternative news sites and the local news in south carolina. You would think this would be a big deal....but no one is making it out to be. I guess US citizens having their constitutional rights taken from them is no big deal anymore. Truely sad.


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

do you know any human rights organizations that would be interest in this?


DesertRose1959 (35)  3 years ago

I know that the Ron Paul Supporters group has already started circulating the video to this case around. I saw it this morning.
Here is the link : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gFVQ0HZz2mc


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

thanks for sharing the video

Fix Computer (New) Fix Computer Easily! Download Repair Tool.  DownloadUpdates.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 67/100. anniepa (11669)   ranked 329 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

This is absolutely outrageous! I was opposed to the Patriot Act from the beginning and haven't changed my mind but I never dreamed something like this could happen to a 16 year old American citizen! I also intend to do my research on this and to write some e-mails to politicians and to media members. If enough of us do that maybe we can get something done, at least get some attention paid to it.
Annie


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

thanks annie. IF you find anything out let me know.

Court Criminal Records Criminal Record Background Checks, Fast Employment & Tenant Screening  http://www.aaacredit.net
 
8. myLot reputation of 99/100. hotsummer (3660)   ranked 746 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

i totally agree with you. the child has every right to appear before the court. i am totally astounded with this news. a very helpless child being held up and kept like a dangerous terrorist even they have not seen any proof. what is coming to the justice system of the US. i expect more humanly treatment in US.

Ask Tech Support Online 18 Tech Support Reps Are Online. A Question is Answered Every 9 Sec!  Computer.JustAnswer.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 63/100. ParaTed2k (6358)   ranked 325 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

I hear stories like this a lot, but have yet to find a verifiable one. I know the ACLU has been posting things about abuses and challenging parts of the Patriot Act in behalf of groups, but I haven't found any ACLU articles that talk about any specific American whose rights have been violated.

The ACLU's website has an article called, "ACLU Releases Comprehensive Report On Patriot Act Abuses".. this comprehensive report lists a lot of generalities and ways the PA could be used against individuals... but there isn't a single case listed of someone being imprisoned or punished without trial under the PA.

The website also has a link to a "Fact Sheet", with all sorts of interesting information about the Patriot Act and possible abuses under it... but that also fails to list any situations where someone was imprisoned or punished without trial.

There have been challenges to the Patriot Act, some were without merit, but others were very important. The PA is a great example of why legislation should never be passed without debate and discussion prior to its enactment.

The Patriot Act has been in affect since 2003, since then we have been told all sorts of horror stories about what "could happen" or "might happen", but even the ACLU can't seem to find a case where an individual was the victim of the horror stories.

This doesn't mean they can't happen, or that the PA shouldn't stand a lot of scrutiny. Most of the provisions in the PA have "sunset" dates, and Congress should look over the years they were in effect to determine if they were effective at all. Those that haven't been effective should be allowed to "sunset".. those that have been effective should be revised to be in full compliance with the Constitution, and also to make them more applicable to the threats of today and the future.

http://www.aclu.org/safef...


myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I am working on getting all the details on this one. His mother did a interview with the local news about it.
http://www.wral.com/news/local/video/5050332/

It is all over the web. But not on any of the major sites. I have some of my friends in the state of NC doing some fact finding for me.

I hope this is some elaborate hoax. I would hate to think of 16 year old boy locked away for two months with no legal council or due process. No matter what his crime was.

I will let you know what I find out.


Bank Mortgage Rate 2.87% Mortgage rates of Federal Reserve Bank drop. Lock-in a low rate  www.MortgagesBestRates.com
 
sponsors
Checkmagic
Prints Quickenr Quickbooks checks on blank check paper.
www.checkmagic.com

Mortgage Rates at 2.25%
$200,000 home mortgage for $764/mo. See New Payment. No SSN Required.
Mortgage.LeadSteps.com

Fix Computer
(New) Fix Computer Easily! Download Repair Tool.
DownloadUpdates.com

similar discussions
Obama never actually signed Patriot Act revision
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/28/us/politics/28sign.html Looks like machines are taking over...
The House just voted to block the extension of the USA PATRIOT Act.
Earlier tonight, the U.S. House DEFEATED legislation to extend three of the so-called “PATRIOT”...
Senators seek to make patriot act permanent
Sen Mitch McConnell, one of a number of senators calling for this, said this could "give US...
Obama on the patriot act and the people that expected it to be repealed
A lot of people voted for Obama because they felt he was going to repeal the patriot act (or...
Obama signs Patriot Act Extention today
The man who ran on how horrible the Patriot Act was...just signed into law a one year extention on...
Obama asks congress to EXTEND the Patriot Act.
Big surprise for all the sheeple who thought he would bring that unconstitutional garbage to a...
Why we need the Patriot Act
I believe that's why the feds prematurely arrested this Zazi guy. 0bama was starting to get a lot...
The Patriot (?) Act
Are you familiar with a little bill called the Patriot Act? Issued by former President Bush, and...
Patriot act not going away just yet
111th CONGRESS 1st Session H. R. 1467 To extend certain provisions of the USA...
Court rules against Obama
The Obama administration has lost its argument that a potential threat to national security should...
sponsors
Checkmagic
Prints Quickenr Quickbooks checks on blank check paper.
www.checkmagic.com
Mortgage Rates at 2.25%
$200,000 home mortgage for $764/mo. See New Payment. No SSN Required.
Mortgage.LeadSteps.com
Fix Computer
(New) Fix Computer Easily! Download Repair Tool.
DownloadUpdates.com
Court Criminal Records
Criminal Record Background Checks, Fast Employment & Tenant Screening
http://www.aaacredit.net
Ask Tech Support Online
18 Tech Support Reps Are Online. A Question is Answered Every 9 Sec!
Computer.JustAnswer.com
Bank Mortgage Rate 2.87%
Mortgage rates of Federal Reserve Bank drop. Lock-in a low rate
www.MortgagesBestRates.com
computer engineering
Current Trends in BI. computer engineering, Tools & Info.
www.ConvergedInfrastructure.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.