sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Constitution 101...installment #1. "seperation of church and state  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,985 in politics 3 years ago

I decided to start this because of a few discussions that quoted the "seperation of church and state". There seems to be some confusion in this and I thought it should be cleared up. The term "seperation of church and state" actually stems from a letter from Thomas Jefferson to Bishop James Madison.
The actual text from the constitution is worded as follows:
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
Often called the "Establishment clause" the portion of it mentioning religion dictates that congress shall not mandate a particular religion .establish an official national religion, nor may it create laws that prohibit the free exercise of one's religion.
Though many of the founders weren't what we in the modern world call "true christians" they all held a belief in "God" or a god and had deep faith and belief. This is evident through out history, documents and letters of the founders. Though they did not wish to have an established religion, they were people of deep faith and this faith guided their every move. the whole premise of our constitutiona dn declaration of independence is that our rights are granted to us by our creator...our "God" and not by our government, because our rights are something that are simply beyond the command of mere man and government.

 

politics
sponsors
Find Attorneys
Need a Lawyer? Search our Directory
yellowpages.com

The Spear Temple's Key[]
Blink Past the Blackness -the Temple is Forming;<>/O A New Beginning.
cinetemple.com

Meet Christian Singles
Christian and single? Meet your match! Start your Free Trial today.
ChristianCafe.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  constitution, church and state, mature content, christianity, first amendment
 
1. myLot reputation of 82/100. spalladino (11857)   ranked 127 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

Thank you for posting this, x. It does come up from time to time and I hate looking like a nag when I correct someone's misconceptions about this issue. Our founding fathers considered a lot of things when drafting the Constitution and keeping our religious beliefs safe from government interference was one of them. Their intention was not to keep our faith in God out of the government...just to keep government from regulating our faith.


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

"Their intention was not to keep our faith in God out of the government...just to keep government from regulating our faith"
wow, I don't think I have ever seen it worded so comprehensively, thank you for that spally, you rok!

Find Attorneys Need a Lawyer? Search our Directory  yellowpages.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 20/100. PrarieStyle (1161)   ranked 234 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

Thank you for posting this. I think we should have a lot more topics on our constitution. We should know it well.
It's the only thing that can save America. America is about the last free nation left on Earth.
Let freedom ring!


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I hope to post more of these. People seem averse to actualy reading the constituion. either out of intimidation or apathy, so, to borrow a religious phrase, if you can't get Mohamehd to the mountain, then you bring the mountain to Mohamehd.


myLot reputation of 75/100. mike1976 (1093)  3 years ago

There may still be a couple of free countries left apart from the US. I was pretty free last time I checked !!

The Spear Temple's Key [] Blink Past the Blackness -the Temple is Forming; <>/O A New Beginning.  cinetemple.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 78/100. suspenseful (19613)   ranked 217 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

It is amazing how many interpret that to mean that there shall be no mention of Christianity in public life. They seem to forget that secularism is also a religion as is also atheism, which is what was the prevailing belief in Communist countries. Yet they do not apply the same restriction to Islam, Paganism, Buddhism, and to a lesser extent to Judiaism. So they will not let public officials use In Jesus's name, or even pastors pray for the troops mentioning HIS name, because they think separation of church and state means no church or no mention of God with reference to HIS son.


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

You guys aren't so hung up on keeping religion out of public view up there, at least that was my experience in my time up there. Some people here seem to have almost a rabid reaction to even the mention of god in public. It is indeed sad when kindergarden class has to rename a christmas play to a "holidat play" or a "winter play" to avoid offending one or two people.


myLot reputation of 78/100. suspenseful (19613)   ranked 217 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I am not against religion in public life. In fact I am all for freedom of religion. But it hurts me, being a singer, when I hear that in some Malls they cannot even sing Christmas Carols. So do not think that I am against religion in public life because I am not. I am referring to others. It hurts me when I read that because of political correctness they call an Easter Concert a Spring Concert, and a Christmas Concert a Winter Festival. I do not want that the only time you want to hear Hark the Herald Angels Sing or Christ the Lord is Risen Today is when you go to a Christian School.


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I know your not oposed to it.


myLot reputation of 78/100. suspenseful (19613)   ranked 217 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

Actually I am against having a certain belief or denomination proposed by the State, like in England, their state religion is the Anglican religon, in France it is Roman Catholicism, in Arabia Islam. I am against a state deciding that public officials cannot be Christians, Jews, Muslims, and that they cannot pray to God, Allah, or whomeer in public.
I am against the removal of the Ten Commandments, references to the Bible and creches from public displays. I feel if it is all right to have the Star of David, the Crescent Star, a saying by Buddha, etc. there should be right to show the words of Jesus. Unfortunately as in Animal Farm, some religions are considered more equal than others.


myLot reputation of 74/100. thedogshrink (686)   ranked 308 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

suspenseful, I think you really hit the nail on the head. The proponents of all this mess are "interpreting" the Constitution to mean what they want it to mean, not what it really means. Then they have counted on the ignorance of so many people who blindly follow when they teach that it says separation and that separation actually means complete isolation. While they're at it (mangling words and the Constitution), why should they bother to include those religions that you mention that are religions, even secularism and atheism (they are a value system, regardless of what their values are) -- they are already misleading people and reteaching people, so they obviously don't care that they are teaching lies. One more lie, that atheism for example doesn't count, is nothing to them. But we, the people, NEED to educate ourselves and each other and stop following blindly anything that "they" say.

So as it turns out now, our government is embracing and enforcing (more and more) a secular/atheistic/humanistic (I know they're not exactly the same, but they all are being embraced, enforced, and pushed) religion on us -- which is against the Constitution.


myLot reputation of 75/100. mike1976 (1093)  3 years ago

The UK doesn't have a state religion. The Queen is Head of State and also head of The Church of England. Due to the fact that we are a Constitutional Monarchy the Queen has no power and the Prime Minster is the real head of the country.

Religion plays little or no part in the politics of the UK and never will. The Church is not a strong institution in the UK so we have no problem with religious interference.


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

SUspensfull, you guys still have a bit more of a mix between the two, religion and government, for example, your government's support of catholic schools as a part public school system.

Meet Christian Singles Christian and single? Meet your match! Start your Free Trial today.  ChristianCafe.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 78/100. spicysweetie21 (1542)   ranked 360 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

First of all I am thinking that you are referring to some of my discussions in which i say that, and i will once again point out that many many people word that clause as separation of church and state, and i will point out that i have never ever said that a person shouldn't voice their love of god or religion, all i said was that government/politics and religion should not be mixed together, i myself have never seen anyone else who stated "separation of church and state" saying anything like that either, and people who quote it aren't making things up because Jefferson was the one who came up with the first amendment aka "bill of rights", and thus since he was the one who said the term "separation of church and state" immediately after stating the clause thats in the first amendment means that people who say that term are not just talking out of their butt because Jefferson came up with it and thats the way he worded, Madison wrote the amendments so he was the one who got the final wording, but it was Jefferson's idea and thats the way the original idea was worded....don't attack or say someone is wrong just because they believe the same principle but they just word it different


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I think you may have taken this a little personaly. It was not directed at you specificly, this has come up many times before with others as well over a long period of time, so don't take it to heart, ok? it wasn't an attack at all. :)
I do need to correct a typo of mine though, the letter was to the Danbury Baptist association association, I had pasted some other text as reference and missed some when deleting it. Here is a copy of Jefferson's Letter:

Gentlemen

The affectionate sentiments of esteem & approbation which you are so good as to express towards me, on behalf of the Danbury Baptist association, give me the highest satisfaction. my duties dictate a faithful & zealous pursuit of the interests of my constituents, and in proportion as they are persuaded of my fidelity to those duties, the discharge of them becomes more & more pleasing.

Believing with you that religion is a matter which lies solely between man & his god, that he owes account to none other for his faith or his worship, that the legitimate powers of government reach actions only, and not opinions, I contemplate with sovereign reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, thus building a wall of separation between church and state. [Congress thus inhibited from acts respecting religion, and the Executive authorised only to execute their acts, I have refrained from presenting even occasional performances of devotion presented indeed legally where an Executive is the legal head of a national church, but subject here, as religious exercises only to the voluntary regulations and discipline of each respective sect.] Adhering to this expression of the supreme will of the nation in behalf of the rights of conscience, I shall see with sincere satisfaction the progress of those sentiments which tend to restore to man all his natural rights, convinced he has no natural right in opposition to his social duties.

I reciprocate your kind prayers for the protection and blessing of the common Father and creator of man, and tender you for yourselves and your religious association, assurances of my high respect & esteem.

(signed) Thomas Jefferson
Jan.1.1802.


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

and even in correcting my typo I have another typo....sigh....lol.


myLot reputation of 82/100. spalladino (11857)   ranked 127 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

They sell keyboards at Walmart, x. wink


myLot reputation of 83/100. xfahctor (7620)   ranked 42 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

yeh, but do they sell typing skills?

Apocalypse End Times Come and see what the beast setup to end the world.  http://oliver-clark-ministries.org
 
5. myLot reputation of 73/100. bobmnu (4820)   ranked 222 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

This post contains content of a mature nature. You must be Signed in or Registered to have the option to view this content.


myLot reputation of 88/100. grammasnook (1333)   ranked 129 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

This post contains content of a mature nature. You must be Signed in or Registered to have the option to view this content.


myLot reputation of 88/100. grammasnook (1333)   ranked 129 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

An environmentalist is a person who may advocate the sustainable management of resources and stewardship of the natural environment through changes in public policy or individual behavior. In various ways (for example, grassroots activism and protests), environmentalists and environmental organizations seek to give the natural world a stronger voice in human affairs.


myLot reputation of 73/100. bobmnu (4820)   ranked 222 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I find it interesting that it is rarely the Christians who are filing protest over others beliefs but are the victim of the attacks. I have seen displays for Ramadan, Kwanzaa, and Hanukkah, without my Christian friends say anything about it. They do get upset at a news story that talks about the Holiday season with out mentioning Christmas but then does a feature on Ramadan or Kwanzaa. My granddaughter came and told me about Kwanzaa and how they had learned about it in school, yet they could not have a Christmas Program, because some one might be offended. In a world History course my daughter learned about the Major faiths of the world and the text book only had a paragraph on Christianity (mainly the Spanish Inquisition) while the other religions had a sub chapter on them. She learned about socialism, Communism, and Monarchies but all she learned about Capitalism was the Robber Barons. We need to be teaching our children about our country and what made it great.

Being Christian Visit mormon.org to learn more  www.mormon.org
 
6. myLot reputation of 92/100. justinus (592)   ranked 1,836 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

In my country, there are still debate about secular or religious state among leaders, menas that the religious group leaders aspireing that any rules and regulations based on religions teaching (Islam) while the other group commited to apply constitution as the basic of any rules and regulation for citizens at general, for instances is that order to pray 5 times a day for moslem doesnt regulate by state but by their internal own group means that the state has no right to take sanction to people who do not pray. The only religion's rule which is applied only marriage especially at moslem populated region, that the state will only allow a bridge as legal if they were married at mosque for moslem and at church for chritian, there will not allow mix religion marriage. The only region whic allow their people married in mix religions is only Bali, because the most of them are Hinduism

American Flag Superstore Low prices, 6 months warranty, fast shipping. Yahoo Top Service Award  United-States-Flag.com/American
 
7. myLot reputation of 79/100. Rollo1 (2827)   ranked 89 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

As many of the original colonists came to this land to seek religious freedom, it was on the minds of the framers of the Constitution to avoid any national religion and to allow free practice of religion to all citizens. The rights of the citizens did not include protecting them from anyone mentioning religion. Free speech is supposed to cover that.

Unfortunately, as you point out, many people consider this the "separation of church and state" clause. Of course, the entire point of this amendment was to protect the church from the state, not the other way around. The other day there was a story about angry parents, who complained when they found out someone had given their kids a free bible on school grounds. I wonder if they would have been so angry if it had been some other book with a religious theme.

The only religion that people seem to want separated from public life, is Christianity. Other beliefs seem to take on entire sets of rights. If my children can sing a Kwanzaa song and a Hannukah song in the school winter concert (not allowed to call it Christmas) then why is Silent Night banned? I don't have any problem with them singing the other songs, I only have a problem when my religion is the only one that is considered offensive enough to be erased from the holiday that celebrates its beginning.

Buy Military Ranks Military Rank Inisignia, Ribbons, Medals, Accessories,...  www.vanguardmil.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 74/100. thedogshrink (686)   ranked 308 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

Here's an excerpt from my post on another thread:
It is the religious foundations of this country that gave us the rights and freedoms we have -- and the so called, misnamed, separation of church and state. Our Constitution NEVER stated there was a separation of church and state. It is BETTER than that. It simply states that government cannot make any law regarding practicing of religion. Hmmmm.... seems we have already crossed that line.
Our founding fathers were all deeply spiritual men. They weren't all Christians, but not a one of them ever objected to public prayer before or during any event, including their meetings on the Declaration of Independence, and the Constitution, and the rest -- they began every meeting with prayer, asking for Divine guidance on their meeting. There was one time I remember reading about when there was much anger and inability to have a meeting of the minds, and I believe it was Benjamin Franklin who stood up and suggested to remedy the situation, they should take a break and pray.
They did. And the rest as they say, is history.


And to Spicysweetie:
As you can see from the letter that X posted, Jefferson was a man who chose his words carefully and knew full well the tiny nuances of each word. If he intended separation of church and state in the way people are using it today, he would have made that very clear. Instead what is made clear in both the Constitution, AND this letter from Jefferson, is that he was concerned about the government making rules and regulations about religion, NOT about public prayer or other public displays of religion (PDR? lol I guess you establishing/had to be in the military ...). Indeed, he and the others who made our Constitution regularly participated in public prayer, and publicly beseeching God. And they did not all have the exact same beliefs, which was the whole point. We are not supposed to be forced to hide our beliefs, change them, or adhere to the state's belief. So yeah, even tho Jefferson one time in a particular spot mentioned a wall of separation, that does NOT translate to saying that when people say it today they are only copying him, and following his intent. They are twisting his intent into something that more and more resembles exactly what he was trying to PREVENT.e

US Made Toys & Games Great games, toys, flags and more. We sell American made goods.  www.protensus.com
 
9. MrPKitty (93)   ranked 1,358 out of 3,985 in politics   3 years ago

One question, is it that the founding fathers are not what the modern world would call "true Christians" or could it be that the Christians of today are not what the founding fathers would have called "True Christians?"

After all, the beliefs they held then are not quite the same as the ones expounded today.


myLot reputation of 74/100. thedogshrink (686)   ranked 308 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

Could you give a bit of detail as to what beliefs are different? I'd love to answer but I don't want to mistake your meaning.


MrPKitty (93)   ranked 1,358 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

When we finally declared our independence one of the first things we dumped was Christmas. We considered it a custom of England and not wanting anything to do with England, it was out the door. No celebration, no special masses, just another day of the week.
And then there's the church taxes, when the Sabbath starts and what can be done on it and separation of the sexes and so on.


myLot reputation of 74/100. thedogshrink (686)   ranked 308 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

I'm sorry, like I said I really wanted to answer your question, but I have even less idea what you're talking about now than I did before! We dumped Christmas when we declared our independence?? In what universe? Separation of the sexes??
What are you talking about? Are you in the US?


MrPKitty (93)   ranked 1,358 out of 3,985 in politics  3 years ago

Check you American history

http://www.thehistoryofch...

"After the American Revolution, English customs fell out of favor, including Christmas. in fact, Congress was in session on December 25, 1789, the first Christmas under America's new constitution. Christmas wasn't declared a federal holiday until June 26, 1870."

yes I am in the US and I do know our history.

Boston outlawed christmas from 1659 t0 1681.

The first American christmasses where more of a drunken free for all than religious celebration.

And if it wheren't for the Dutch, we wouldn't be buying gifts for everybody.

There's a lot of history out there, you can't just take somebodies word for it, you have to go looking yourself.

American Flag Screensaver Download Free High Resolution Waving American Flag Screensavers!  ScreensaversAndWallPapersFree.com
 
10. motjuste (56)   3 years ago

THANK YOU for this concise elucidation of the Establishment Clause. I get so sick of hearing people attack Christian values and principles, or even simply god-fearing values and principles (the fact that we answer to a higher authority) in order to clamor against the display of the Ten Commandments or a menorah in December.

The fact is, the founders were religious men and knew that Americans were a religious people. They knew it was and would be important for us to exercise that freedom and live by our beliefs. While one is certainly free to be an atheist, since there really are no observations or holidays for atheism and atheists are certainly in the minority, whiners need to recognize what the law REALLY says and stop complaining when people popularly celebrate their religious holidays. I have no problem with everyone getting to celebrate but I don't think one faith should have to suppress their observation because another faith is offended. If you don't observe Saturnalia or the winter solstice or those great eight crazy nights or do the Santa thing or the manger scene thing, then do your own thing and let them do theirs--what's so hard and controversial about that?

Great post.

USA Flagpoles New 20'-25' Stronger than steel- 10 gage alum, Factory direct 15 years warranty  www.tele-pole.com
 
sponsors
Apocalypse End Times
Come and see what the beast setup to end the world.
http://oliver-clark-ministries.org

Being Christian
Visit mormon.org to learn more
www.mormon.org

American Flag Superstore
Low prices, 6 months warranty, fast shipping. Yahoo Top Service Award
United-States-Flag.com/American

similar discussions
"Liberal" news The Young Turks takes on Democrats who support NDAA
Attacked by their own fan base, they break down the wording in NDAA in this video and criticize the...
The U.S. oath of enlistment was changed in 1960, good decision?
This change went into effect 2 years later and in 1962 anyone who joined than had to use this oath:...
Witness protection - why cant it be made the responsibility of the accused?
If I were to draft Indian Penal Code and all relevant rules and laws, I would make accused...
Spending Problem or Income Problem?
Well, that's one of the easiest questions to answer, why? Because financial deficits are almost...
Here is a Poem I wrote
Yes it does have something to do with Politics so don't worry. They swore an oath An Oath to...
My friend is a future corrupt official!
Today I got into my buddy who is a schoolmate of mine but we differ in the course that we are...
Obama and the Christmas Tree Tax
That's right folks, the Dept. of Agriculture hasn't put in a request to Congress to come up with a...
Americans sign a petition to repeal the first amedment
A social experiment on the scary side. Mark Dice a anti-war, Christian conspiracy theorist decided...
Realizing I've been wrong about the border fence issue.
Yup, you read it right, I was wrong about the border fence issue. I'm among those who have been...
Does it really matter what party the President of the United States is?
Presidents come and go or stay for another term or so, but what is the difference between...
sponsors
Apocalypse End Times
Come and see what the beast setup to end the world.
http://oliver-clark-ministries.org
Being Christian
Visit mormon.org to learn more
www.mormon.org
American Flag Superstore
Low prices, 6 months warranty, fast shipping. Yahoo Top Service Award
United-States-Flag.com/American
Buy Military Ranks
Military Rank Inisignia, Ribbons, Medals, Accessories,...
www.vanguardmil.com
US Made Toys & Games
Great games, toys, flags and more. We sell American made goods.
www.protensus.com
American Flag Screensaver
Download Free High Resolution Waving American Flag Screensavers!
ScreensaversAndWallPapersFree.com
USA Flagpoles New 20'-25'
Stronger than steel- 10 gage alum, Factory direct 15 years warranty
www.tele-pole.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.