sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Is it fair to receive salary from MOM? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 89/100. zandi458 (5905)   ranked 2 out of 1,304 in family3 months ago

I often wonder whether it is right for children to receive monthly salary from their mothers. As children, we should be the one giving to our mothers money instead of receiving money from our mothers. But this is something odd here as my mum is paying 3 of my siblings monthly emoluments which is to me inappropriate.

She is old but she still has a sharp mind and still active. In a recent family meeting we had she announced that as of next year she'll pay each of my 3 appointed siblings a sum of $1,500.00 per month to help her in her property management. Isn't part of the duties of children to help their aging parents without expecting something in return? confused

 
 
family
sponsors
Free $250 Assistance Plan
Get a Free $250 Grocery Debit Card. Just Enter Your Zip Code.
Free-GroceryCard.com

DC Area Attractions
Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more.
www.fxva.com

Stay at Home Mom Salary
Increase Your Salary When Boost Your Credentials – Earn Degree Online
www.FloridaTechOnline.com/Moms

LovingLife139 (519) response was accepted on 10/27/2009.
denotes best response.
tags:  salary, mothers, money, mother, parents
 
1. myLot reputation of 92/100. learn2earn (10911)   ranked 203 out of 1,304 in family   3 months ago

Well, in the world of employment, if a person works for someone, then he or she is entitled to a remuneration may be in the form of commissions, bonuses, or salary. If a young man or woman will work in the business or company of her mother, then there is nothing bad about receiving a salary from their mother. But if they are not doing anything and expect a salary, that is another story.


myLot reputation of 89/100. zandi458 (5905)   ranked 2 out of 1,304 in family  3 months ago

Tell you what, my mom is not running any company that is big enough to warrant full salaried employees. But I do not understand why she has to engage her children to help her out and making herself pay for nothing. We are supposed to assist her where ever we can without any monetary rewards as she has always been a savior to each one of us when we are in desperate situations. It kind of irk me to see my siblings taking advantage of her bounty. sad

Free $250 Assistance Plan Get a Free $250 Grocery Debit Card. Just Enter Your Zip Code. Free-GroceryCard.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 86/100. Hatley (21398)   ranked 25 out of 1,304 in family   3 months ago

hi zandi458 Well most moms don't have that kind of money
but stll its her business and she is giving them money
for managing her property. I suppose in a way children
could halp their parents without being paid but I think
in your mom's case she is actually paying them wages for
work they are doing for her.


myLot reputation of 89/100. zandi458 (5905)   ranked 2 out of 1,304 in family  3 months ago

I am lucky to have a generous mom who is always there when am in problem. She is always acting as welfare officer to all her children. She has not stopped giving her assistance regardless of family or public.

DC Area Attractions Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more. www.fxva.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 96/100. Shaun72 (11889)   ranked 180 out of 1,304 in family   3 months ago

Wow that is a lot of money that she is paying her own childern to help her. It sounds to me like that they would help their own mother out for free or at least not as much money.To me it sounds a little selfish. After all she did raise them as children.


myLot reputation of 96/100. vandana7 (1700)   ranked 585 out of 1,304 in family  3 months ago

Hi Shaun, if she can pay that much, she seems to be fairly rich lady!:) Well, I think it is a nice way of transferring wealth. If she was not paying it like that, she would be leaving it to them at the time of her death, and then it would attract estate duties. As things stand, they dont have to pay higher estate duties. Of course, if she had no monies, then any such services should have been absolutely free. I however dont agree with that - being nice with parents because they raised us. Being nice is fine with me. I want to be nice, because I am nice, and not because somebody including my parent did something for me. It implies that I need something from somebody to don that nice act. I didnt ask my parents to bring me into the world, or do all that they did for me. The point is even if they had not done what they did for me, I would have done those things free of cost for them.


myLot reputation of 89/100. zandi458 (5905)   ranked 2 out of 1,304 in family  3 months ago

That is what is in my thought - selfish. You know when it comes to relationship, like mother and children, working discipline is hard to monitor. It is unlike the formal working world where you have to work from 8 to 5 to earn the money. I know it may not be something like the real working world. They just have to be present in my mom's house everyday sit around, watch tv, chitchat and thats it, probably run errands for the old lady and being paid. My mom has her way of helping her children which doesn't sound too lenient.

Stay at Home Mom Salary Increase Your Salary When Boost Your Credentials – Earn Degree Online www.FloridaTechOnline.com/Moms
 
4. myLot reputation of 95/100. suzzy3 (3995)   ranked 162 out of 1,304 in family   3 months ago

If it is a proper business and proper work then yes they should get paid and be lucky they can work in the family business instead of joining the queue for work.The only time is if they are not doing a proper job bearing in mind if they let her down she will sack them.That is a lot of pressure.After all you will all benefit in the end and it is better than letting the business be run by complete strangers who might diddle you out of your inheritance and your mother out of her business.It is a childs duty to make sure your mother is looked after in illhealth and her house be kept nice for her.Business is business and why should they work for nothing could you afford to.


myLot reputation of 89/100. zandi458 (5905)   ranked 2 out of 1,304 in family  3 months ago

My mom doesn't actually have a licensed business to talk about. I think she pick and choose those who she find not so progressing in life and instead of giving them free money, she created something so it won't look like a welfare department. well, she does have housing estate she rented out but it is only minor and only demand minimal work.

ABC Limo Service We provide nice limousine, sedan, van, minibus services in Washington, DC metro area, Virginia, and Maryland for weddings and special events. Flat rate to all airports. www.limowashington.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 97/100. danishcanadian (20673)   ranked 24 out of 1,304 in family   3 months ago

Parents often do this as a way to teach kids how to earn money. And as kids going to school, how else are they going to earn money? If kids work around the house and the parent "pays" them (mine paid me $15 a week), this teaches the kids a glimpse of what it is to work for money, and earn money. As for kids, we didn't choose to be born, our parents choose to have us, thus it's their responsibility to raise us, and that includes teaching us how to use money responsibly.


myLot reputation of 89/100. zandi458 (5905)   ranked 2 out of 1,304 in family  3 months ago

I agree we didn't asked to be born and it is the responsibilities of the parents to bring them up and guide them to be responsible people. It is not the responsibility of parents to feed them forever. Once married the children should fend for themselves and in turn should look after their aged parents.

Washington Car Title History at Carfax Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports. www.Carfax.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 90/100. kawalnarang (693)   ranked 114 out of 1,304 in family   3 months ago

A child gets from the parents as a child,,,,,,, eg love,education,,clothes,,accommodation,, and whatever when they are a child,,But we all feel that as they grow up,,they look for their own comfort according to the abilities(decided by the spouse as well If married),,as far as possible a child can help the parents,, in such cases,as this,, and not look forward to getting emoluments(unless there is a severe need,,, but in these days,, NAH,, let the education received work for them


myLot reputation of 89/100. zandi458 (5905)   ranked 2 out of 1,304 in family  3 months ago

With good education, a person can survive anywhere in the world. But laziness can be a hindrance to progress in life. Nowadays, children are so pampered that instead of working to earn their living they are still hopeful to get something from their parents. sad

Rachel Valentino, Adams Morgan Real Estate Expert Rachel Valentino, Professional Washington, DC real estate agent…. www.rachelvalentino.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 99/100. catdla1 (2739)   ranked 276 out of 1,304 in family   3 months ago

Children should help their parents without expecting anything in return. What your mom is doing may not really be about working for the money. Not knowing what your tax structure is, she might be doing it for tax reasons. Assuming that all profit are taxed, in dispersing it to your siblings who are helping her, she's avoiding paying taxes on that money. The other possibility is that if she's financially secure, she just wants to see her children enjoy the money while she's alive and not all after she's gone. All of my grandparents dispersed a significant portion of their assets for that reason.


myLot reputation of 89/100. zandi458 (5905)   ranked 2 out of 1,304 in family  3 months ago

I guess it is just her way of helping out but classified it as working so as not to make it too obvious which might create a rivalry among the siblings.

Midway Roofing Find prescreened roofers in Midway Washington in just one click. contractors.clicksmart.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 99/100. ladym33 (5558)   ranked 295 out of 1,304 in family   3 months ago

Well yes we should help our parents as much as we can without expecting payment in return, but if they are going to be doing actual work for her managing her properties of which she earns money then that is valid, they will be doing actual work which means they should draw a salary. But they should not take or accept money for doing things for your mom that are just under the title of general care, but actual work yes, their time is worth something, as long as they don't have their hand out every little time they do something for her.


myLot reputation of 89/100. zandi458 (5905)   ranked 2 out of 1,304 in family  3 months ago

I agree with you, work that involves generating some income from the properties should deserve some kind of pay but not something that involves personal caregiving. We are duty bound to care for our parents without any form of incentives.

Washington DC Real Estate Appraiser Flanagan Associates Residential Appraisers. Fast Quality Service you can count on. www.flanaganappraisals.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 88/100. EnglishTeaDuck (733)   ranked 716 out of 1,304 in family   3 months ago

Yes, I think we should support our parents. But as others have said, if they are working for her in that way then fair enough. If she is still sharp of mind, I guess she knows what she is doing.

If you don't mind me saying, does the fact that it is three of your siblings, but not you, come into your reasons for questioning it at all? Or is it just accepted that these are the family members who take this role?


myLot reputation of 89/100. zandi458 (5905)   ranked 2 out of 1,304 in family  3 months ago

Well, am surprise cos my mom is presently paying one sibling and she announced lately in our monthly family meeting that another two will be in the payroll effective next year. I don't see the need for another two as one person should be capable of taking care of the properties. Since I am staying quite a distance from them I am not in the position to help out and moreover I am quite contented as I am entrusted to run the family business in this part of the town where I relocated myself just to run the show of which everything I earned from the business is mine to keep.

Mother's Day Jewelry Find elegant, unique Mother's Day jewelry in & near Washington DC. yellowpages.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 87/100. starsailover (1180)   ranked 392 out of 1,304 in family   3 months ago

I think respect to your mother is not in contradiction with receiving a salary if you deserve it. I else think that a good mother can be a good boss and that, as a son you have then, the obligation to be as good as you can be doing your daily work.


myLot reputation of 89/100. zandi458 (5905)   ranked 2 out of 1,304 in family  3 months ago

It is our obligation as children to help out and a little incentive is a welcome.

WA Appraiser Course Become A Real Estate Appraiser Now Quick & Easy Home Study Courses. www.RealEstateLicense.com
 
sponsors
ABC Limo Service
We provide nice limousine, sedan, van, minibus services in Washington, DC metro area, Virginia, and Maryland for weddings and special events. Flat rate to all airports.
www.limowashington.com

Washington Car Title History at Carfax
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports.
www.Carfax.com

Rachel Valentino, Adams Morgan Real Estate Expert
Rachel Valentino, Professional Washington, DC real estate agent….
www.rachelvalentino.com

similar discussions
Have you raised the wages?
I feel the prices rise so fast and pay remains the same, it gets increasingly difficult to live...
Can you celebrate the Christmas holiday without spending?
Usually Christmas time brings joy to almost everyone, we cant avoid not to spend to add the fun and...
how to ask your boss for a salary increase!
One day an employee sends a letter to his boss asking for an increase in his salary...
Having a salary in one day and the next day it's gone
Have you ever had a feeling that you just received your salary and a few hours thereafter it is...
Settlement in foreign countries
It has been my dream to finish my education in India and settle in a foreign country. As per a...
How did you spend your first Salary ever?
In my case I got it wasted for food. Maybe I'm too exited during those times.If I can turn back...
do you mind if your parents ask for your salary to them?
sometimes my parents request some money from my salary every months. actually i dont mind. but when...
what will you do?
hello.i think this is a real headache.my boss give me many works at a daught .i really at a loss....
Will you wait for beginning of month.
Hi,The beginning of every month brings cheers. Because we will salary for our work what we have...
How you spent your salary!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
well! for me before salary day i already planned and budgeted my salary.Sometimes we eat outside in...
sponsors
ABC Limo Service
We provide nice limousine, sedan, van, minibus services in Washington, DC metro area, Virginia, and Maryland for weddings and special events. Flat rate to all airports.
www.limowashington.com
Washington Car Title History at Carfax
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports.
www.Carfax.com
Rachel Valentino, Adams Morgan Real Estate Expert
Rachel Valentino, Professional Washington, DC real estate agent….
www.rachelvalentino.com
Midway Roofing
Find prescreened roofers in Midway Washington in just one click.
contractors.clicksmart.com
Washington DC Real Estate Appraiser
Flanagan Associates Residential Appraisers. Fast Quality Service you can count on.
www.flanaganappraisals.com
Mother's Day Jewelry
Find elegant, unique Mother's Day jewelry in & near Washington DC.
yellowpages.com
WA Appraiser Course
Become A Real Estate Appraiser Now Quick & Easy Home Study Courses.
www.RealEstateLicense.com
600 Washington
Find top-rated Real Estate Agents near you Try Citysearch® now
Newyork.Citysearch.com
Washington Nursing Jobs
8-26Wk Nursing Jobs in Washington Make $95,000yr + Benefits.
www.TravelNursesNow.com/washington
Washington Post job with competitive salary
All Jobs. All Locations.
www.JobsRadar.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.