sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Move or stay? What should I do?:( email this discussion to a friend?

JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener2 months ago

I live in Alabama, and I recently got engaged. My fiance is from New York. All my family lives here in Alabama, and all of his family besides his mom live in New York. We got a call yesterday and his mom told us that she is moving back to New York, too. She wants him to go with her, and now he's asking me if I will move to New York. I would love to move away and start over somewhere new, but I don't know if I could leave my family, you know? I need some advice please, I don't know what I should do.

Thank You!

 
 
listener
sponsors
United Kingdom Passport Service in US
Urgent Experts Handling, On time solutions. Call us for instructions.
www.passportdocs.com

Do You Have Coffee Teeth?
An Underpaid, Overworked Single Mom Reveals $4 Teeth Whitening Secret.
News13KDTV.com

Bose
Read reviews for this business wit directions, offers and more
Washingtondc.Citysearch.com

nagikka (226) response was accepted on 10/12/2009.
denotes best response.
tags:  new york, relationship, moving, listener, alabama
 
1. myLot reputation of 89/100. nagikka (226)   ranked 1,168 out of 1,746 in listener   2 months ago

Dear Jessica, that's a decision that's entirely up to you and we can't do much about it:) I don't know how you feel about your family, could you go months without even seeing them? because, for instance, I could never live like that especially knowing that my parents get old and could need my help. They've always been by my side, ALWAYS, and I could never pack my things and move away BUT this is just the way I feel. I suggest that you think twice about your decision, consider that:
- you'll be far away from your parents
- you will have to make new friends
- you'll have to get a new job
Like you said, you'll have to start all over, which can be stressing in the end. It's all up on you and how strong you can be:) whatever your decision might be, I wish you the best of luck.


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Thank you:)

Great advice! That's what I told my fiance, I was like, "My grandparents are getting old and what if something happens and I'm all the way up in New York?!" I would be a mess. Getting a job would be the hardest part these days, especially in the part of New York they live. Huntsville Alabama is rated number one to survive the economy, so I'm thinking stay here is way smarter.:D


myLot reputation of 90/100. srganesh (3342)   ranked 320 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Is it easy to break the engagement and will it not be a problem for her in the future?How can she remain with her family,if she is going to get married?I think,she can move to Newyork and can come back whenever she wishes to meet her family members.That will be a good advise.Cheers!


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Thanks for your comment! Moving up to New York and coming back to visit when I need to would definitely work out.

United Kingdom Passport Service in US Urgent Experts Handling, On time solutions. Call us for instructions. www.passportdocs.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 13/100. Tom728 (171)   ranked 1,141 out of 1,746 in listener   2 months ago

Just stay. Family is more important that should be why you are getting married.


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Thank you, Tom. I appreciate your advice.:)

Do You Have Coffee Teeth? An Underpaid, Overworked Single Mom Reveals $4 Teeth Whitening Secret. News13KDTV.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 90/100. stacysmomstl (159)   ranked 965 out of 1,746 in listener   2 months ago

I have to say I agree with Tom728. I don't know when or if you guys set a wedding date as of yet, but it seems as though if he wants you to move, then he'd maybe mention moving the date up.

I will tell you that 9 years ago I was facing something similar to this. I wasn't engaged to the guy, but we had been dating for several years. My mom had passed after an illness and I was ready to move for a change. I had never thought twice about uprooting me and my daughter and moving someplace else. So I told my bf at the time that I was thinking about moving away. He gave me so much guilt. Told me I wasn't thinking about our relationship, I was being selfish, I wasn't giving he and I a chance. How can I just move, I was grieving, blah, blah, blah.

So like the big softy I am I decided to scrap that idea. I rehabbed a house and put down roots. Well not even a year after that, I found out that this guy was never faithful, was into some very sick sexual things that I thought were pretty disgusting, and he was just a big fat liar period. (I'm not saying this is your fiance, though. I'm sure he's a great guy.) My point is that if I had followed what I wanted to do I would probably have a very different life right now. (Happier). But I didn't follow my dreams and now I feel stuck most days.

I guess what I am trying to say is what does your heart say? If you guys are getting married anyway, why not do it and you guys can be together and start your new life together as husband and wife. My question to you is why is he following his mother? He just recently asked you to marry him now he's moving because his mother wants too? You guys need to determine together where you want your married life to be. It's good practice for married life, making decision together.

Good luck.


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Wow, what a great comment!:) The date is actually set for May 30, 2010. See, I went through/am still going through a situation kind of like what you went through. I lost my very best friend in a car accident in August of 08. A lot of things went downhill for me when that happened. I had just started my senior year in high school, and after the wreck happened, I had no motivation for anything anymore. I didn't ever want to go to school, I didn't care about anything at all. I eventually got unenrolled 6 weeks before graduation because I missed too many days of school. Things have started looking up and I'm a lot better than I once was. My fiance also mentioned just moving somewhere completely different, not Alabama or New York. I just told him I needed some time to think about it all. It's not a decision to just jump into anyways.:) Thank you so much!


myLot reputation of 90/100. stacysmomstl (159)   ranked 965 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

I'm so sorry to hear about your friend. That's sad. My daughter has a friend that goes to a different school that just had something similar happen. It's very sad. My daughter is 16. That's very young to lose a life. I don't know how you got through that. You are very strong. My daughter's friend still has nightmares about her classmate. It really puts a damper on the fun times you are supposed to be having while in high school.

I know things will work out with you and your fiance. It makes a little bit more since now that I know you guys are in your early 20's or so. I can see where moving with his mom might be something he'd want to do. But he has to remember that he does have you to think about now too. You will be family soon too and he shouldn't forget that.

Let us know if you move or not!


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

I'm so sorry to hear about that. I know exactly what she is going through and it isn't easy at all. I was only 17 when I lost my best friend, and he had just turned 16. He didn't even get his first car. It's so sad.

Thank you so much for your input, it means a lot!
And I sure will let you know if we make the move or not!:)

Bose Read reviews for this business wit directions, offers and more Washingtondc.Citysearch.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 93/100. dlr297 (2803)   ranked 240 out of 1,746 in listener   2 months ago

I lived in ohio all my life, and my husband always wanted to move back to tennessee where he was born. and six years ago we did. Most of our family is in ohio our kids, most of my brothers My Mom. He has 2 sisters and his parents live with in a hour of where we live now.

Even though i only get to see my family two or three times a year, and i miss terribly not seeing my grandkids. I am happy with the move that we made. I love it here in Tennessee, and i am hoping that the kids will eventually all move here someday. 1 already has.

If anything ever happens where i need to be with my mom im only 9 hours away, and can go to be their anytime that im needed.


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Ah, one comment that gives me hope it will be okay.:) That's exactly what my fiance told me, "You know if something happened in Alabama, we'd be there in a heart beat." I have no worries I could get here if something happened, it would just kill me if something did happen and I wasn't around. I guess you have to grow up sometime.:) I think a move would be a good change for me, but who knows? Thanks for your comment!

Washington Car Title History at Carfax Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports. www.Carfax.com
 
5. michael_walsh (32)   ranked 992 out of 1,746 in listener   2 months ago

Hey Jessica,

I think you should make a list of pros and cons about moving and staying and see which turns out to be more positive for you. Maybe you can tell your fiance how you feel and see if he could move to alabama instead. Or you two can compromise and move somewhere that's in between both families.


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Thank you, Michael. My fiance knows how I feel about it and he says the decision is completely up to me. Thank you for your post!


michael_walsh (32)   ranked 992 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

glad to hear that! Thanks for adding me:)


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Thank you very much! And you're welcome. Always looking for new friends on here.:)

Washington International Stay Park And Fly Hotels Don't miss your flights - Washington airport parking & hotel packages. www.ParkSleepFly.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 97/100. TrvlArrngr (1138)   ranked 1,157 out of 1,746 in listener   2 months ago

It depends where in NY and will you have a job that you can transfer to?


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

His sister in law has a job for me if I move up there, but I haven't decided if I want to or not.

Moving And Storage Company WA Free Truck Rental with move in. Reserve now. No CC required. www.MiniuStorage.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 97/100. bounce58 (742)   ranked 484 out of 1,746 in listener   2 months ago

Hello JessicaSearcy! My advice is to go to NY. I know it is going to be hard, but I feel that is just part of growing up. This way you expand your horizon and open yourself up to more possibilities in life. Also, being away will make your visits to your family all the more special.
One last thing, its NY! If you can make it there, you'll make it anywhere...


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Thank you so much for your comment!:) I know, the sound of moving to NY sounds so great doesn't it?! I really would love to move away and start my life with my fiance and open up to many more possibilities. I know it will take effort to get to where I want, but I think I'd be happy.:)

Looking to Sell in DC? home staging washington dc Home Staging in Washington DC Area including Maryland and Virginia. www.stagingdesigndc.com
 
8. freewriter (12)   ranked 1,165 out of 1,746 in listener   2 months ago

I really didn't read all of the responses that you received, but it is my opinion that you two have to talk about this in it's entirety and come to a mutual decision that will make both of you happy. In a relationship many people make sacrifices, but are very unhappy. If a sacrifice is made between you and your fiance, please make sure the both of you are very happy, because this is where it all comes down to, happiness together, forever.


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Thank you for your advice, freewriter. Happiness is definitely the key to a long, successful marriage. That is my number one goal in life- to be happy. I'm sure my fiance and I will come to a mutual decision and be happy wherever that may be.:)

Washington DC Real Estate Appraiser Flanagan Associates Residential Appraisers. Fast Quality Service you can count on. www.flanaganappraisals.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 94/100. LadyMarissa (2691)   ranked 126 out of 1,746 in listener   2 months ago

I was in much the same place as you about 40 years ago. I chose love over family. A couple of years later he had run off with another woman & I was too ashamed to ask to go home. Once again I chose love over family. He drank himself to death so I swallowed my pride & moved back home. All I can tell you from the bottom of my heart is your family will NEVER turn their back on you in the same way a lover will. You have to decide which is more important to you...your man or your family. I can tell you there is a HUGE difference between Alabama & NY. I would think long & hard before making such a move!!! You didn't say why you want to start over somewhere new.


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Thank you, LadyMarissa! I'm very sorry to hear about your experience moving. Alabama to New York IS a very long way to go and I am going to do some major soul searching to figure out what it is I think will be best for me in the longrun. I would like a fresh start or to just start over because I lost my bestfriend in a car accident in August of 08. Since then, things have really went downhill for me. The only thing good that has happened since then was meeting my fiance. It's been a hard year to get through, and going somewhere new sounds really good to me at times.


myLot reputation of 94/100. LadyMarissa (2691)   ranked 126 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Oh Honey, I'm sorry for your loss. Grief is something that takes time. Moving away probably won't leave that grief behind. It's something that sticks with you forever. However it does lessen over time. I'm getting the feeling that you've already made up your mind & I don't think anything I say will change it. I moved from Georgia to Washington DC. I thought I had the world by the tail. At the time I really didn't think of my family. I thought I could just visit home any time I wanted to. Once I moved I didn't have the money to return home often. On a good year it was twice a year. My parents resented the control my husband had over me & he wasn't welcomed in their home & he resented their love for me & didn't want me to visit. Being forced to choose between your husband & parents is not a good place to be. By the time I returned home, I had missed 25 years with my family. My grandparents both died not long after I returned home so that 25 years was time I lost with them. Time that should have been cherished!!! I could go on & on for hours with reasons NOT to go. I think deep inside you know them ALL. Love is a good reason to go though. Since there is NO way for you to see into the future, there is no way for you to clearly see what you should do. My hindsight is 20/20. My foresight sucked!!! I don't want to think I kept my mouth shut & just blindly let someone else make the same mistake I did!!! Good luck no matter what you decide to do. Just remember we ALL are responsible for the choices we make. A wrong choice stays with us for life!!!

Travel to Washington DC Going to Washington? Use Travelzoo to Find the Best Deals. Browse Now. www.Travelzoo.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 97/100. daliaj (2746)   ranked 314 out of 1,746 in listener   2 months ago

It is your personal decision. You need to think really well before taking the decision. I think it is fine for a girl to live away from her parents after marriage. I don't know what is the difference between Newyork and Alabama. If I were in your position, I would have never dropped my lover for the reason of shifting.

On the other hand, I live in India and I married a guy who lives in America. India and America are in differnet continents and it takes a lot of issues like visa, air ticket, etc. to travel to the other place. Also, the journey takes 2 days by air. Now, I am waiting for my visa to move to my husband's place and see his family. I had been with my family for 25 years and I think it is fine to shift now.

I am not cutting relationships with my family. I will be in touch with them always. I can visit them once in a while - once in a year; the air fare will be around 2000 dollars for round trip:-(((. We live in 21st century and it is very easy to keep in contact with people in different parts of the world. I can even see my parents, brother, and sister in India using google video chat or yahoo messenger even though I am in USA.


JessicaSearcy (59)   ranked 40 out of 1,746 in listener  2 months ago

Thanks so much daliaj! I agree with you, completely! Making the move is a huge decision, but I believe it is a great opportunity for me and my fiance wanting to start our new lives together. From Alabama to New York is about a 14 hour drive. We actually made the drive a couple months back, and it wasn't half as bad as I expected. And you are most definitely right, we do live in the 21st century now. We have plenty of ways to keep in touch with each other, no matter the distance. For instance, I'm talking to you all the way in the US and you're in India.:) I wish you the best of luck on your move!

Young Frankenstein the Musical Don't miss the musical this holiday season! Tickets start at $37 here. Kennedy-Center.org
 
sponsors
Washington Car Title History at Carfax
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports.
www.Carfax.com

Washington International Stay Park And Fly Hotels
Don't miss your flights - Washington airport parking& hotel packages.
www.ParkSleepFly.com

Moving And Storage Company WA
Free Truck Rental with move in. Reserve now. No CC required.
www.MiniuStorage.com

similar discussions
IF you can reach at New York what you willl vizit firs?
I'm wondering what you visit first when you go to New York. I think if i go to New York i wold...
If I were a friend visting New York the 1st time, name 3 places you'd take me to
I just love New York, but I have never been to what I consider the best city to be in. Just for...
My Visit to New York
I was able to go to New York over the summer. I enjoyed seeing the Statue of Liberty. She is very...
which city is your favor to live in?
today,many cities are polluted seriously.if you have enough money,you wanna live in which city.
What is the lesson of the 23rd Congressional Race?
I think the lesson to be learned by both parties is that they have to listen to the people. Eleven...
NY Nurses To Be Forced To Take H1N1 Vaccine
This is a touchy subject for me. I would completely understand how these nurses feel, being told by...
Rising seas 'to hit New York hard'
A predicted slowdown in Atlantic Ocean currents will cause sea levels along the US northeast coast...
The most expensive thing you've ever bought?
The most expensive thing I've ever bought were a pair of 320 dollar distressed denim jeans. What...
How many of you loved the Gangs Of New York?
What a great movie! Historical, intriquing, well produced, well acted- loved it! I love a money...
Is it true that New York City people are rude?
I've been reading a lot of comments from foreign people about the nicest people in the world and I...
sponsors
Washington Car Title History at Carfax
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports.
www.Carfax.com
Washington International Stay Park And Fly Hotels
Don't miss your flights - Washington airport parking & hotel packages.
www.ParkSleepFly.com
Moving And Storage Company WA
Free Truck Rental with move in. Reserve now. No CC required.
www.MiniuStorage.com
Looking to Sell in DC? home staging washington dc
Home Staging in Washington DC Area including Maryland and Virginia.
www.stagingdesigndc.com
Washington DC Real Estate Appraiser
Flanagan Associates Residential Appraisers. Fast Quality Service you can count on.
www.flanaganappraisals.com
Travel to Washington DC
Going to Washington? Use Travelzoo to Find the Best Deals. Browse Now.
www.Travelzoo.com
Young Frankenstein the Musical
Don't miss the musical this holiday season! Tickets start at $37 here.
Kennedy-Center.org
Washington DC Movers
Local Movers & Moving Services - Door to Door & Long Distance.
Movers.YellowPages.com/WashingtonDC
Free DC Dating Personals
No credit card required; email local singles for free.
www.SinglesNet.com
Lobbying in Washington, DC
Marlowe & Company provides cities and counties with results and personalized service. Established 1984.
www.marloweco.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.