Is it necessary to get angry at young children?

@TheHorse (206648)
Walnut Creek, California
March 10, 2022 8:20pm CST
Child rearing varies greatly by culture. But one thing I've noticed about my work with young children is that I never get angry at them. I might say "no!" when a 1 1/2-year-old tries to open a gate and escape to the parking lot, but the child can tell I'm angry about the behavior, not them. Today, I had to wag my finger at my new 18-month-old buddy when he undid a gate latch and tried to get to the "big kid" area. But he could tell I was not angry at HIM, and we were best buddies again within about 30 seconds. We spend half an hour this afternoon filling buckets with sand and then dumping them out. He was a "pro" by the end of our time together. What is "discipline" like where you live? Has it changed over the decades?
16 people like this
12 responses
@LadyDuck (459353)
• Switzerland
11 Mar 22
I have no contacts with families with young children. My neighbor spanked her son when he was a young boy. He is now 18, very polite young man, he has a job, he grew up well.
4 people like this
@LadyDuck (459353)
• Switzerland
11 Mar 22
@TheHorse I have never been spanked, my brother a few times, he was stubborn and insisted in asking things until my Mom got mad... he has not changed a bit.
3 people like this
@TheHorse (206648)
• Walnut Creek, California
11 Mar 22
I got spanked as a kid. I turned out OK overall.
3 people like this
@vandana7 (98986)
• India
11 Mar 22
@TheHorse Actually, I do feel like spanking you at times...you did not get enough spanking.
3 people like this
@wolfgirl569 (95804)
• Marion, Ohio
11 Mar 22
It depends on the age first. At 18 months they are still learning all of the rules so no. But 4 year old Monsters that keep pushing buttons are a different story. I do always make sure she knows I love her. Its the behavior that I dont.
4 people like this
@TheHorse (206648)
• Walnut Creek, California
11 Mar 22
An important distinction!
3 people like this
@vandana7 (98986)
• India
11 Mar 22
I think children test the limits they can go to each time. So they will look at you while doing what they are told not to do to see when you will start reacting. Brats. LOL It is amusing and if we show we are amused...you bet they are not gonna listen then and another time... I tend to panic when they do things that are dangerous. Good thing I didn't have any. I would make them so sissy. LOL My father has been abusive. Nothing has changed. People still beat their kids around me.
1 person likes this
@xander6464 (40910)
• Wapello, Iowa
14 Mar 22
According to the research I've done at NebraskaCoEds.com, the discipline techniques of young ladies is pretty much the same. Except now they get paid for it.
@RasmaSandra (73749)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
12 Mar 22
I think children should just know who is the authority and learn to understand that no means no and learn right from wrong, Just yelling at a child never accomplished anything,
3 people like this
@porwest (78759)
• United States
11 Mar 22
Anger, for me, is a word similar to hate. They are deeper felt emotions, and most often are not descriptive of my true feelings. Most things only annoy me or irritate me. But anger me? That takes quite a lot. Disappointment is also a word I associate often with something I feel towards someone. I rarely hate anyone. I rather dislike them, or do not prefer them. But hate? It takes a lot for me to hate someone. I have never had kids, but I have had younger cousins and of course nieces and nephews, and I can't remember a time when I ever felt genuinely angry at them. Even when they get older, even into their teen years when some can get quite nasty, anger would be an emotion I would not have felt. As for discipline, however, I am a firm believer in corporal punishment—but there is a very discernable difference between a stern tap on the butt and and child abuse. A smack in the face would be something I would never do. That being said, that kind of discipline also did not destroy me. I was belted, bare butt spanked with a brush, smacked in the face, and even punched and it did not damage me mentally.
3 people like this
@TheHorse (206648)
• Walnut Creek, California
11 Mar 22
I see anger as displaced depression/anxitey. I'll write more later. I have to get to work.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (98986)
• India
12 Mar 22
@TheHorse Wow, that makes anger a forgivable emotion too. LOL
@porwest (78759)
• United States
11 Mar 22
@TheHorse You may have something there. Now, get to work!
1 person likes this
@DaddyEvil (137142)
• United States
11 Mar 22
It depends on how young the kid is. Littlies get a finger shaken at them. Toddlers, if they've been told over and over not to do something, then I might swat a diaper-clad little tush... ONCE. It's enough to startle but not hurt. Hopefully, it will help them remember the next time they're tempted to do something I don't want them doing. If YOU'RE the one doing something wrong, then I'd probably let vanny decide and administer the punishment. When I was a kid, we got a peach tree switch taken to our legs. When we were a little older, then dad used a thin leather belt on our tush. Now, if anyone sees someone raise their hand to a kid, no matter their age, you can bet the police and Family Services will be visiting very soon!
@JudyEv (326170)
• Rockingham, Australia
11 Mar 22
I don't have enough contact with young families nowadays to be able to comment on changes. Mostly, parents seem quite good although you sometimes get some in supermarkets that shout at their kids.
@Deepizzaguy (94944)
• Lake Charles, Louisiana
11 Mar 22
Discipline where I live is to be nice to my nephew who has special needs is to tell him "No." when he wants to play computer while it is being updated in a kind manner. No harsh language used.
@LindaOHio (157337)
• United States
11 Mar 22
Discipline has definitely changed. Parents can't spank their kids anymore as they did when I was a child.
@Adie04 (17360)
11 Mar 22
I am thankful to born in family of discipline parents. I saw some families nowadays, even me and my friend ever asked each other, why marry if they can't raise their family right. Have problems in terms of financial (majorly) and others.
@Hytton03 (5454)
• Philippines
11 Mar 22
Kids are kids and totally cute. I am very patient with the kids and if there's wrong i explain but sometimes they easily forgot . Because all they want is to play.