sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

Neiman-Marcus cookies...interesting e-mail email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies3 months ago

This is kind of long and might be viewed as a 'v' by some people, but it's not really. I just got this e-mail from a friend. It's a pretty interesting story. I kind of knew where it was leading before the point was actually made. I have no idea if there's any truth behind it...that's why I'm posting it in it's entirety here!

Have you seen this before? Do you think it's true? Would you pay that kind of money for a recipe? If it is true, should Neiman_marcus refund the woman's money? Could a lawsuit be brought by either side?....see this really is a discussion!

When decent people get screwed over, this is the result!

A little background: Neiman-Marcus, if you don't
know already, is a very expensive store; I.e., they sell
your typical $8.00 T-shirt for $50.00.

Let's let them have it! THIS IS A TRUE STORY!

My daughter and I had just finished a salad at a
Neiman-Marcus Cafe in Dallas, and we decided to have a
small dessert. Because both of us are such cookie
lovers, we decided to try the 'Neiman-Marcus
cookie.' It was so excellent that I asked if they
would give me the recipe, and the waitress said with a
small frown, 'I'm afraid not, but you can buy
The Recipe.' Well, I asked how much, and she
responded; "Only two fifty - it's a great
deal!" I agreed to that, and told her to just add
it to my Tab.
Thirty days later, I received my VISA statement,
and the Neiman-Marcus Charge was $285.00! I looked
again, and I remembered I had only spent $9.95 for two
salads and about $20.00 for a scarf.. As I glanced at the
bottom of the statement, it said, " Cookie
Recipe-$250.00. " That was outrageous! I
called Neiman's Accounting Department and told them
the waitress said it was " two fifty ",
which clearly does not mean 'two hundred and fifty
dollars' by any reasonable interpretation of the
phrase.
Neiman-Marcus refused to budge. They would not
refund my money because, according to them, 'What
the waitress told you is not our problem. You have already
seen the Recipe. We absolutely will not refund your
money at this point.' I explained to the Accounting
Department lady the criminal statutes which govern fraud
in the State of Texas I threatened to report them to the
Better Business Bureau and the Texas Attorney
General's office for engaging in fraud. I was
basically told, " Do what you want. Don't
bother thinking of how you can get even, and don't
bother trying to get any of your money back.'
I just said, 'Okay, you folks got my $250,
and now I'm going to have $250 worth of fun.' I
told her that I was going to see to it that every Cookie
Lover in the United States with an e-mail account has a
$250 cookie recipe from Neiman-Marcus...for free. She
replied, 'I wish you wouldn't do this.' I
said, 'Well, perhaps you should have thought of that
before you ripped me off!' and slammed down the
phone.

So here it is!

Please, please, please pass it on to everyone you
can possibly think of. I paid $250 for this, and I
don't want Neiman-Marcus to EVER make another penny off
of this recipe!

NEIMAN-MARCUS COOKIES (Recipe may be halved)
2 cups butter
24 oz. Chocolate chips
4 cups flour
2 cups brown sugar
2 tsp. Soda
1 tsp. Salt
2 cups sugar
1 - 8 oz. Hershey Bar (grated)
5 cups blended oatmeal
4 eggs
2 tsp.. Baking powder
2 tsp. Vanilla
3 cups chopped nuts (your choice)

Measure oatmeal, and blend in a blender to a fine
powder. Cream the butter and both sugars. Add eggs and
vanilla, mix together with flour, oatmeal, salt, baking
powder, and soda. Add chocolate chips, Hershey bar, and
nuts. Roll into balls, and place two inches apart on a
cookie sheet. Bake for 10 minutes at 375 degrees.

Makes 112 cookies

So there it is, what do you think?

 
 
cookies
sponsors
Neiman Marcus
Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today.
www.ebay.com

Great Tasting Fortune Cookies
Fast, Fresh, Fabulous, with special 25th Anniversary Rollback pricing.
www.e-fortunecookie.com

Remove Cookies Now
Remove All Cookies Created By Your Browsing - Get Your Free Scan.
www.WinClear.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  cookies, recipe, email, scam, neiman marcus
 
1. myLot reputation of 94/100. ljegbers (5762)   ranked 237 out of 297 in cookies   3 months ago

I think that this e-mail is wonderful. I've already copied and pasted to my recipe file.

I agree that the BBB should be contacted. I've had some great success with them before with issues of fraud. Thank you for sharing this and I'll be sure to pass it on!


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

I think I'm going to have to search around to see if I can find out anything else about this....if it went any farther than the email or not. I'm saving the recipe too, I'll have to at least halve it but it sounds fairly good.


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

*giggles* NOW it dawns on me to check snopes....oh well, I never said it was true, I just asked for opinions about it!

Neiman Marcus Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today. www.ebay.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 97/100. lilybug (8129)   ranked 1 out of 297 in cookies   3 months ago

I am glad that she is sticking it to Neiman-Marcus. I personally so not think that recipe is worth $250. There is nothing special about that recipe.


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

It is a pretty basic recipe...no "secret ingredient" that no one would have ever thought to put in a cookie. I'm also curious what happened to the waitress since it was her misleading statement that started it all.


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

oops...see my 2nd comment on #1


myLot reputation of 97/100. lilybug (8129)   ranked 1 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

Oh, well so what if it was not true. It was funny!

Great Tasting Fortune Cookies Fast, Fresh, Fabulous, with special 25th Anniversary Rollback pricing. www.e-fortunecookie.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 94/100. snowy22315 (4744)   ranked 2 out of 297 in cookies   3 months ago

I will use it and enjoy it. I will also boycott Neiman Marcus for you. I dont really shop there so it will be easy for me. I would post it wherever I can to make up for their skullduggery. That really bites!! I wouldnt give up on the attorney generals office either.


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

Oh, it wasn't me! I just got the email from someone else. I do hope she persues it further if this is a true story.


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

lol...check out my 2nd comment to #1...I made a blunder

Remove Cookies Now Remove All Cookies Created By Your Browsing - Get Your Free Scan. www.WinClear.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 99/100. Trace86 (2634)   3 months ago

http://www.snopes.com/bus...

I know that it is a fake story, but do you think the recipe is any good?
It would be great if it were true, wouldn't it?
Will you try it and let us know? I can't bake to save my life, so I would ruin them to start with. I wonder how the dough would taste raw. That is one of my favorite treats.


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

Yeah I already checked snopes...forgot about it until after I hit the "post discussion" button.

I tend to mess up when I divide recipes so I'm a little scared to try....and I don't know what I'd do with 112 cookies if they turned out to be hoorible! I might get brave and try it, I just haven't decided yet.

Cookie Recipes Everything to do with Cookie Recipes items. shopping.Yahoo.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 79/100. olivebranch56 (492)   3 months ago

Foxy I got this recipe when this was on the net about two years ago. OMG talk about some good cookies, they are melt in your mouth yummy lisceous One hint I will give you, Keep the cook time to the lowest amount, this way they are soft. You just have to try them. Hugs Marilyn


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

I do like soft, melt in your mouth cookies! Maybe I will do up a batch in a couple weeks when I have the extra money for the ingredients. Thanks for sharing your experience.

Christmas Cookies Free shipping. You'll love our wonderful cookie assortments. www.diet-cookies.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 98/100. cjgrooms (2569)   ranked 81 out of 297 in cookies   3 months ago

I have seen this several years ago, I thought then and still think that the women was ripped off and since she did pay for it and pay dearly Neiman-Marcus shouldn't have a chance in hades of suing her.But this is America so who knows?


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

Well chalk this one up to "should have checked snopes before I posted" but it still could have been an interesting discussion if more people would ignore the fact that it isn't true...oh well.

But my opinion is...if you pay for ownership of something, it should be yours to use in whatever way you wish. I know a loty of things don't work that way but I think they should to at least some degree.

gourmet cookie Find providers of cookies in our directory. www.business.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 96/100. ebsharer (1985)   3 months ago

Sorry but its not a real receipe. I shouldn't say it like that you can really use it. It really will make cookies but its not really from Neiman-Marcus.

Here is a link to tell you more about it...

http://www.snopes.com/bus...


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

Yep, we already established that. Thanks!

Free Cookie Recipe Get free cookie recipes from warm fresh bread to hot apple pie and everything in between. All absolutely free. www.a1-easy-gourmet-recipes.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 94/100. Pirate_Arg (267)   3 months ago

Ok, I'm going ignore the fact that this letter has been proven false on Snopes and talk about the silly woman in it because that is the point I find interesting.

In what way does "two fifty" not mean $250? Does she really expect to get what would usually be described as a trade secret for less than the cookie probably cost? If she was stupid enough to agree to pay the price for an overpriced cookie recipe, that is in no way the person who sold it to her's fault. She knew it was an expensive place when she walked in.

If it sounds too good to be true, it probably isn't true.


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

You make a very valid point. It seems ridiculous to think anything would cost $2.50 at an expensive place. As to what "two fifty" means...I can see it going either way. I think when words like that are used a person needs to take into context the location. If in the story the waitress had said "twenty-five" which the woman took to mean $25 but was then charged $2500 I can better understand why it would seem like a scam.

Keep Your PC Clean - Fast Cookie Removal Computer slow? Losing your privacy? Get rid of cookies & spyware now. www.securetactics.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 86/100. sassygirlanne007 (2334)   ranked 19 out of 297 in cookies   3 months ago

Ya my mom received this email a couple of years ago. We printed it off and made are own batch and it was wonderful so now we make up lots so we can freeze them and eat them during the hot summer days cold.


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

Wow, that's a great idea for any cookie recipe! Thanks for sharing that.


myLot reputation of 86/100. sassygirlanne007 (2334)   ranked 19 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

ya its a great idea. As a kid growing up I always looked forward to getting one of moms cookies out oft the freezer.

 
10. myLot reputation of 70/100. Marley76 (100)   ranked 125 out of 297 in cookies   3 months ago

I hate to be the part pooper but this is a fake email. I has been going around for year. I think I even saw something on the Discovry Channel how this is not real and it never happened. It was some show on Urban Legends. I got this email about 7 years ago. I didn't pass it on but I made the cookies. They were okay. Not the best cookies, not the worst. So it may not be real but hey its for cookies so who cares.


myLot reputation of 94/100. foxyfire33 (5577)   ranked 3 out of 297 in cookies  3 months ago

You weren't a party pooper several others already pointed out that fact as did I before them. The recipe sounds good but maybe not amazingly good, just ordinary.

 
sponsors
Cookie Recipes
Everything to do with Cookie Recipes items.
shopping.Yahoo.com

Christmas Cookies
Free shipping. You'll love our wonderful cookie assortments.
www.diet-cookies.com

gourmet cookie
Find providers of cookies in our directory.
www.business.com

similar discussions
Does it count?
My fellow myLot friends, I am in a quandry here. I really need to watch my snacking as I'm...
Chocolate good for health?!!!
i am a chocoholic person. i've been a chocolate lover in its myriad forms from before i can...
Do you add things to your cookies like nuts, chocolate chips, m&m's or what?
When you bake cookies do you add things to them like nuts, peanut butter chips, miniature M&M's,...
This site is a front for a criminal gang
I know... Horrific isn't it! Here we all are busy posting discussions and making our responses to...
What is your favorite homemade chocolate chip cookie recipe? I need recipes.
I really have a craving for making some homemade chocolate chip cookies, but could use some...
end of soggy cookies yay!
Everyone loves cookies, well i do anyways, well good news for you guys that loves cookies and...
You deserve a cookie!
Ok so everyone loves cookies. What is your favorite cookie and brand of cookies??
You like to buy cookies or like to make in house?
special day? birthday, or christmas, or easter, you go and buy what you need for a good meal, or...
What's your record on the battle versus the ice cream??
When I'm really stessed out and need to cheer up, I looked for a pail of ice cream and try to beat...
instead of a birthday cake order.......
hello all of my good friend's here at Mylot. instead of a birthday cake order today, guess what?...
sponsors
Cookie Recipes
Everything to do with Cookie Recipes items.
shopping.Yahoo.com
Christmas Cookies
Free shipping. You'll love our wonderful cookie assortments.
www.diet-cookies.com
gourmet cookie
Find providers of cookies in our directory.
www.business.com
Free Cookie Recipe
Get free cookie recipes from warm fresh bread to hot apple pie and everything in between. All absolutely free.
www.a1-easy-gourmet-recipes.com
Keep Your PC Clean - Fast Cookie Removal
Computer slow? Losing your privacy? Get rid of cookies & spyware now.
www.securetactics.com