The Origin of the "Trick-or-Treating" Tradition
By Anna
@LadyDuck (488477)
Italy
October 22, 2025 7:17am CST
Most of myLot members surely know that "trick-or-treating" is a Halloween tradition in which children go door-to-door and recite the phrase to receive candy.
This tradition, called "souling", dates back to the Middle Ages, where it was particularly widespread in the British Isles.
The poor would go door-to-door on All Saints' Day and All Souls' Day, offering prayers and songs for the deceased. In return, they received "soul cakes." These were small, round cakes filled with sweet spices, similar to shortbread cookies.
Do you know any unusual Halloween traditions to share?
30 people like this
30 responses
@celticeagle (182775)
• Boise, Idaho
22 Oct
I recall reading about this. Halloween is my favorite holiday. I feel good.
I will be posting soon about some Halloween superstitions that I thought ere interesting. I hope you will as well.
5 people like this

@celticeagle (182775)
• Boise, Idaho
22 Oct
@LadyDuck .......Sweet bread? Interesting. The post is coming soon.
4 people like this
@LadyDuck (488477)
• Italy
23 Oct
@celticeagle I went to bed, now I am up and I check the new discussions.
3 people like this



@Deepizzaguy (116466)
• Lake Charles, Louisiana
23 Oct
I have no unusual Halloween traditions to share on this site.
3 people like this
@LindaOHio (207701)
• United States
23 Oct
No, I don't know of any unusual Halloween traditions. Thank you for sharing souling with us.
3 people like this
@LadyDuck (488477)
• Italy
24 Oct
@LindaOHio I remember that those sweet breads were so good. Individual bakeries have disappeared, what a shame!
2 people like this


@snowy22315 (199686)
• United States
22 Oct
I did not know about the souling. I thought Halloween was related to the old Celtic holiday Samhain.
3 people like this
@RasmaSandra (91535)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
22 Oct
There was no actual Halloween celebrating in Latvia when I lived there but at home we carved a pumpkin and jsut remembered spooky fun. They did do costumes at school and sometimes kids came but mostley no one was used to it, Of course, young adults caught on and filled the bars with Halloween mayhem,
3 people like this
@Marilynda1225 (87291)
• United States
22 Oct
Halloween is really big here and all the hoopla starts by the 1st of October. People now decorate their homes for Halloween like they do for Christmas. It was just a day for trick or treating when I was growing up but now it's become huge. Thankfully my town has limited the trick or treating to certain hours (6pm to 9pm) so there's no all day long with the bell ringing.
3 people like this
@Traceyjayne (6724)
• United Kingdom
23 Oct
Unfortunately it’s become more and more popular here the last few years. Luckily we dont get bothered with trick or treating.
3 people like this
@princessmarie (1121)
• Philippines
23 Oct
It is a good thing that Halloween is not a holiday here in the Philippines,yes people observed it but most of us during october- November we are going to the cemeteries to prepare for all souls day.
And I've watched several videos in other social media platforms buying expensive Halloween decorations spending hundred or thousands of dollars just for the decorations.
3 people like this
@MarieCoyle (51902)
•
27 Oct
I think I want to make some soul cakes. They sound delicious to me!
Halloween traditions, no...in the US it seems to be how many decorations a person puts up, etc. and then of course some have Halloween parties, dress in costumes, and others just basically hand out candy on Halloween night. I always did the candy when the kids were at home still. When I moved last time, I moved to an area that really encourages the families with kids to use the ''Trunk or Treat'' events that are hosted. These are mostly done for safety. Plus, the kids can get their candy and treats, there are a lot of adults, and these are usually held either outside in a well-lit parking lot, like a church or another large area that's similar. They offer things for the kids to do, like cake walks, bounce houses, etc. so no one has very many, if any, Trick or Treaters here that come to their homes. It's sort of a rule that if you want to give out candy, leave your outside porch light on.
2 people like this
@LadyDuck (488477)
• Italy
27 Oct
I also want to make some, I am sure that they are good and must be pretty simple to make.
I think that the way Halloween is celebrate where you are is much better. I would not want that my kids eat candies they get knocking at the doors. The world is weird now and I would not feel safe. You can poison even stuff that look perfectly sealed.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (51902)
•
29 Oct
@LadyDuck
I used to take my kids back when they were little. But, we went to only the homes of very close friends and some nearby family, that was all. They still had plenty of goodies with that, plus no door-to-door.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (51902)
•
30 Oct
@LadyDuck
One of our ''Swiss boys'' who lived with us for several years to go to college, had a sister who taught school in Switzerland. She liked the Halloween decorations, so he bought some here in the US and sent them to her for her class. She said they were a big hit with the kids she taught.
1 person likes this

@much2say (57714)
• Los Angeles, California
2 Nov
Souling - interesting term! I would love to try one of those "soul cakes"
!
I can't really think of any unusual Halloween traditions, but certainly Halloween has changed since my childhood. Less are participating in trick or treating these days (either going or giving).
So nice to see a post from you
.
!
I can't really think of any unusual Halloween traditions, but certainly Halloween has changed since my childhood. Less are participating in trick or treating these days (either going or giving).
So nice to see a post from you
.1 person likes this

@much2say (57714)
• Los Angeles, California
3 Nov
Oh sweet @LadyDuck - I have missed you too
.
That reminds me of Cinco de Mayo here . . . it's not celebrated in Mexico, but it is here . . . and it gives people an excuse to party and drink
. Drinking celebrations often mean too many dangerous drivers on the road - I hate that.
Thank you for the Soul Cake recipe! This is a good change from the typical candy and color ridden cupcakes the kids get here. Do you make these each year?
.
That reminds me of Cinco de Mayo here . . . it's not celebrated in Mexico, but it is here . . . and it gives people an excuse to party and drink
. Drinking celebrations often mean too many dangerous drivers on the road - I hate that.
Thank you for the Soul Cake recipe! This is a good change from the typical candy and color ridden cupcakes the kids get here. Do you make these each year?1 person likes this
@LadyDuck (488477)
• Italy
3 Nov
@much2say - In our days it seems that no matter which celebration is an excuse to party and get drunk, it's no more pleasant.
I did not make the cakes this year, I am still adjusting at our new apartment and I have to replace some of my pots and pans, I had gas stove in Switzerland and here it's induction. I am adjusting but it takes a little time.
1 person likes this
@LadyDuck (488477)
• Italy
2 Nov
Hello, it's also so nice to see you around, I missed you. Halloween it's not very popular here in Europe, but it seems an excuse for teenagers to do stupid pranks and to get drunk. I regret it was "imported".
This is a recipe for the soul cakes
Soul cakes are a British treat traditionally served during Halloween, All Saints Day and All Souls Day. Sweet, delicately spiced & packed with juicy currants. Shropshire soul cakes are quick & easy.
1 person likes this

@crossbones27 (51776)
• Mojave, California
15 Nov
I do not, just that no one ever does tricks. It should just be just treats here in the states. I never seen one person go let me show you a trick. 

1 person likes this

@crossbones27 (51776)
• Mojave, California
15 Nov
@LadyDuck In America, you might get arrested for saying show me your trick. Well shows how trustworthy people are if they scared of the word trick. I know I am. This place was always crazy till the 1940'S and 1950's and kind of tame then 1960's America was back to be like a softer version of wild west. 

1 person likes this
@LadyDuck (488477)
• Italy
15 Nov
@crossbones27
I will keep in mind never to say "show me your trick". Trick-or-treat" did not catch here in Europe. People do not want to be annoyed by kids knocking at their door.
I will keep in mind never to say "show me your trick". Trick-or-treat" did not catch here in Europe. People do not want to be annoyed by kids knocking at their door.1 person likes this

@moffittjc (126504)
• Gainesville, Florida
2 Nov
That is very interesting. I never knew the origin of the modern trick-or-treat tradition we follow.
1 person likes this

@LadyDuck (488477)
• Italy
3 Nov
@moffittjc - Look at Christmas, nothing is left of the real meaning of this holiday, it's all commercial now.
1 person likes this
@moffittjc (126504)
• Gainesville, Florida
2 Nov
@LadyDuck That's what I thought as well. Everything seems to be commercialized these days, even ancient traditions.
1 person likes this

@noni1959 (11403)
• United States
28 Oct
@LadyDuck Hi Anna! I'm am doing well. I hope you are as well. I was excited to see a new posts by you. I agree with Marie. The trunk-or-treats are safer. Churches do the Harvest events with games, candy, and fun too. Someone said some of the businesses are going to stay open later for kids can drop by and get candy.
1 person likes this

@JudyEv (366736)
• Rockingham, Australia
23 Oct
Halloween has invaded our shores too over the last generation or so I guess. My BIL's neighbour has a huge redback spider on his roof and a blown-up giant thing on his verandah. I think he is Irish but he is really getting into the whole Halloween thing. I didn't know that about All Saints' Day. Thanks for the information.
2 people like this
@AliCanary (3505)
•
16 Nov
The soul cakes sound delicious! My birthday is on All Saint's Day (Nov 1). I know two other traditional holidays that occur at the same time as Halloween and probably lend many traditions to it: Samhain, the Celtic Pagan celebration of fall and the harvest, and El Dia de Los Muertos, a Mexican folk tradition that honors the departed and is a reminder of our mortality. People dress up as skeletons and decorate sugar skulls, so maybe that's where the scary-but-fun costumes and candy came from.
1 person likes this

@LadyDuck (488477)
• Italy
18 Nov
@AliCanary For us it's not marigolds, but chrysanthemums.
1 person likes this
@AliCanary (3505)
•
18 Nov
@LadyDuck Yes, they do that In Mexico, too. They visit the graves and take marigolds, that's the special flower for it. And then at night they party and dance with big papier-mache skeletons :)
1 person likes this





I would hate to be pestered by children wanting stuff. No fireworks here, I have to say that I am glad that is not a holiday we celebrate.
















