Do you think stay at home moms and working moms are supportive of eachother?

@miamilady (4910)
United States
August 13, 2007 11:08am CST
Or do you think we are critical of eachother. I've gotten the impression that we are more critical of eachother than supportive. I don't agree with it, but that's what I've seen. I think we each do what we feel is best for our families and ourselves. I don't think there is a right or wrong answer when it comes tot he choice of staying at home or going to work. It think it is an individual decision. What do you think?
8 people like this
20 responses
@wiccania (3360)
• United States
13 Aug 07
I think that more often than not, working moms consider stay at home moms lazy. Many of them regard us stay at home moms with a certain disdain. I've actually had working moms accuse me of just wanting to sit on my @ss all day. If working moms really think that that's what stay at home moms do... then they should stay home with their kids more often, because they know nothing about raising children. On a daily basis, I clean my living room not once but at least 3 times. I also clean my son's bedroom at least once a day (he likes to dump his toys out of the toybox). There's also the bathroom -- he's just learning how to use the potty, so he gets it all over the place sometimes and that must be cleaned several times a day. Not to mention the mess if he throws up -- all over the toilet, the walls around the toilet and the floor. I gotta clean that up too. Then there's laundry and the dishes, the cooking, the kissing of boo-boos, the holding and calming him when he has a meltdown and having to constantly dress him (he likes taking his clothes off). Yep. I'm just sitting on my @ss all day. Personally, my attitude is "to each his own." Working moms either wanted or had to go back to work after having their child. I didn't have to. So I've been able to stay at home with my son. But I do get pissed and very vocal when someone says that I'm just sitting around all day.
3 people like this
@maehan (1439)
• United States
13 Aug 07
Hi wiccania, if someone say that, that's totally WRONG! I have been working for more than 20 years and 5 years as a working mom. Before I know that I going to become a stay at home in USA, I start to think and pondering can I manage the whole house just like my mom. She needs to do housework, nurture my boys, educate them and countless stuff to do. When I am working, I will put my boys into childcare center and my mom will pick them up later. After a hard work in the office, I get salary, leave and have medical leave if I am sick. But, as a stay at home mom, we work 24/7, we do not have a fix meal time, clean up the mess of the house, will always be messy if the children are at home. I can compare as I had experience both. Like what I say to those stay at home mom since their baby are born. Thumbs up! Great Job and I stand up straight and salute to you. I told that to mom too! I am still in the process of of learning to get there.
2 people like this
@babyfuzz (1078)
• Philippines
15 Aug 07
You wouldn't know something until you experience it. And I don't want to take comments/advices from those people who don't really know what they're talking about. I mean, those people who like to stick out their noses to and talk this and that, esp. about parenting or motherhood, or being a stay at home mom or a working mom. They just don't understand how hard it is to be a Mom.. period!
2 people like this
@DavidReedy (2378)
• United States
13 Aug 07
My sister is a stay-at-home mom, and recieves criticism from men and women alike who work. The cost of daycare offsets most income she could make from working, and most of these people are okay with dumping their kids in daycare... I wonder who'll be the better parent in the long run?
2 people like this
• United Kingdom
18 Aug 07
Well said I think. Personally, I find working mums more critical of full time mums which to me is the wrong way round as, as far as I'm concerned, it's the full time mums who are doing the right thing. It's also true that working mums must rely on someone else to bring up their children and therefore must find someone who is going to do a good job. From my own experiences, good childcare providers are few and far between. I also understand the point about costs. I would love to be able to earn a bit to help out so we don't have to struggle but as you say, the cost of childcare would offset any income I might make. I also think that people who so willingly dump their kids can't be good parents. (Of course there are exceptions where people genuinely don't have a choice but I mean when they do have a choice) and so few working mums seem prepared to make any sacrifices, apparently believing 2 weeks on holiday every year with their kids will make up for the time they haven't bothered with them and that having big houses and luxury cars is important. These are some of the reasons I find it so hard to be supportive of working mums because I genuinely don't think they are doing a good thing.
1 person likes this
• United States
18 Aug 07
I couldn't agree with you more. It's just crazy, the world we live in. in the ideal situation, mothers would be able to be with their children (and would want to be.) Personally, I think there's something wrong with a woman that'd rather her children be raised by strangers. That being said, being a realist, I know that both parents in most households have to work to make ends meet--some 2 or 3 jobs a piece. I believe everyone should be commended for their hard work in either situation--as long as they're not attacking others for doing the best they can with what they got.
@pumpkinjam (8540)
• United Kingdom
17 Aug 07
I don't think we are supportive of each other. As a full time mum, I sometimes find it difficult to be supportive of working mums. Maybe it's because of the kind of people I know who are working mums. A lot of them do think that full time mums don't do anything, which I don't understand particularly when a lot of those working mums are sat in an office for 8 hours a day. I find that very hypocritical of them. And I also find that they don't seem to appreciate just how hard it is to be there 24/7 for your children. If you choose to go back to work then that's your choice but you shouldn't criticise others for staying at home. (I don't use the phrase "stay at home mum" any more because it does make it sound lazy. That's why I say "full time mum", it's more accurate as most good "stay at home mums" don't actually stay at home.) I do wonder though, why people who do have the choice would choose to have a child and then go to work. I can understand if there is financial difficulty or if they are a single parent but I can never understand why any mum would so willingly give up her time with her child for anything when there is no need. I try not to be judgemental but this is the way I see things. I have tried working full time, I did it when my oldest son was 2 years old. I only lasted 3 weeks and it was the most horrible 3 weeks of my life. I had left him with my sister so I knew he was in good hands but I hated not being with him and I felt so tired when I did get back to him that, apart from the time I was taking away from him to go to work, I so badly wanted a rest when I'd finished that I found it even harder to spend time with him. I had a little bit extra money which was nice but I didn't have the time to spend it on my son and for the amount I was paid, it wasn't worth it as I was paying half of it to my sister for looking after him. Now, my kids are 7 and 2. I'm looking for work again because we can not afford to live on my partners wage any more. I just don't know if we'll be any better off once we've paid for childcare, which is another thing I don't understand because I know working mums who seem to only earn what they spend in childcare so the finacial incentive disappears as well. I think all mums should support each other but in my personal experiences, neither understands the other unless they have had both experiences and even then, some working mums seem to want to "justify" their situation by putting down full time mums. And, to make this fair so I don't appear to be judgemental, there are some stay at home mums who are lazy, I want to differentiate between a full time mum who looks after her home and her kids properly and a stay at home mum who really does sit doing nothing all day and then spends evenings in the pub and stuff like that. I know some really awful mums who have stayed at home. One in particular who I can think of, she has obviously never actually really bothered with her children and now has only just got a job because her benefits stopped (I'm not judging people on benefits either because if I had to, I would and I would always be there to look after my kids if I could). This person has kids who are old enough to look after themselves so she didn't have an excuse any more. I know it can be hard to get work that fits round your kids once they are at school but I see no reason when your kids are more or less grown up why someone would still choose to be on benefits instead of working.
2 people like this
@ESKARENA1 (18261)
18 Aug 07
Although I agree absolutely, we should support each other. Human nature dictates however that we will criticise anyone making a life choice different to our own blessed be
2 people like this
@ESKARENA1 (18261)
18 Aug 07
I think we are critical of each other, often to an extreme extent. If someone is doing something different to ourselves we often feel threatened by it. Sad but true, difference scares us. The more insecure we are in our own lives the more likely we are to condemn anyone who chooses a different p0ath blessed be
2 people like this
@maehan (1439)
• United States
13 Aug 07
I think is individual decision. When I am a working mother back in Singapore, my sons have their swimming lesson on every Saturday & Sunday Morning. Then, gymnastic in the afternoon. My neighbor is a SAH Mom. At times, when I need to get back to the office in the morning, I will get her help to take care of my sons (bring them to the swimming class) and I will be back by noon. Vice versa, her husband work required extensive travelling. Once, her girl had a high fever and need to hospitalize. She called me to help her to pick up her son in school. When I became a SAH mom in USA, I understand the working mom may need help especially during peak period of work. Recently, my sons classmate grandparent need to return to vietnam for 2 weeks due to some urgent matter. My sons told me that his friend still unable to locate a baby sitter. His dad told me that it is difficult to get a afterschool care/ baby sitter for only 2 weeks. So I do understand both of them are working. So I offer my help to them by taking care of their 2 boys. I think regardless SAH mom or working moms, we need to support each other, this will make a happy living environment and so call win-win situation.
2 people like this
@mistissa (1349)
• Netherlands
18 Aug 07
I agree with you, but you are also right that it is a personal decision. I am a stay at home mother but I also work from home. So I think it is even harder, because while working I am most of time also doing the kids
2 people like this
• United Kingdom
21 Aug 07
I think in some ways it's good if you can work from home but in some ways. Although I wonder how you manage to divide your attention that way! I think if you can get it so you are working at home while the kids are in bed or something, that's probably the best thing but I know people who think they are doing both jobs (ie. working and caring for their kids) but they may as well work outside the home because they work so many hours that they don't have time to pay attention to their kids anyway.
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
13 Aug 07
Yes it is up to the person if they want to work also some have to go to work to help with bills if hubby dont make enough to go around. Then we have single moms that have to get out there and work to support their kids.
1 person likes this
@Geminigirl (1909)
• United States
13 Aug 07
I would like to think supportive of one another. After all, each family situation is unique. It is not a one size fits all. It would not be fair to critique someone if you have not walked in their shoes.
1 person likes this
@carlaabt (3504)
• United States
15 Aug 07
I think there are a lot of moms who are very critical of any mom who does things differently than they do. I've had several other moms ask me what I do all day since I don't work. I tell them I do the same things for my child that the babysitter does for theirs. Clean up after him, cook for him, read him stories, give him baths, play outside together, etc. I worked when he was a baby, and there were just as many people then telling me that I needed to be home with him instead. At that time, we needed the extra income to get some stuff paid off. Now we can afford for me to stay home, as long as we watch our budget closely. Everyone in our family is happier, but that's definitely not the way it would be for some families. I know some women who would hate to be home all day, and love working. So that's what they need to do. I know others that would love to stay home with their kids full time, but haven't figured out a way to afford it, so they have to work. The reasons that moms choose to go to work or to stay at home differ with every family.
1 person likes this
@miamilady (4910)
• United States
19 Aug 07
"I tell them I do the same things for my child that the babysitter does for theirs. " Great answer!
@pismeof (855)
• United States
13 Aug 07
Miami,I agree with you that there are those that criticize each other.I think that it stems from jealousy or envie where one party wishes they had what the other has. It would be interesting to see a nation wide poll about such matters. I personally feel that a Mom should stay home,at least when the children are around.Just work parttime so that there is stability in the home at least while the children are under the age of 13 or 14. We all understand the economic pressure families face today..However the emotional welfare of our kids should be a higher priority.
@YoungInLove (1254)
• Canada
20 Aug 07
I think it all depends. I havent been able to experience either, because Im only 17. But I do know of some stay at home moms whos children are in higschool and they just dont go to work because they dont feel like it, and I do know of others who work their butt off taking care of household chores and laundry and taking care of children. So thats why im on the fence with this decisions. I think stay at home moms deserve more credit, but some are giving the hardworkers bad reps because they are the ones that sit around and do nothing "because they can" But just because working moms arent taking care of their kids ALL day im pretty sure its tough when they come home to keeping up with work and chores. To each its own I guess.. they both work equally hard at what they do, they should both get credit for what they do..equally.
1 person likes this
@trk918 (254)
• United States
14 Aug 07
I'm sure it goes both ways but here is what I see. The stay at home moms look down on us working moms because we can't be there for all of the parties and field trips. They look at us like we are neglecting our kids. Being single we also get looked down on because we are not married and it doesn't matter why we are not married. You can catch them talking about us behind our backs. It's wrong. I don't think a stay at home mom is any lazier than a daycare provider meaning not at all. I was home with my son for 5 months while unemployeed. I know what it is like so I guess I'm one of the few that can see both sides. If you are able to stay at home and raise your kids I think that is wonderful. Kids need their parents. But on the other hand if you need to work to provide a good home for your kids than that is what you have to do. I think more stay at home parents should consider this while passing judgement and visvera.
1 person likes this
• United Kingdom
18 Aug 07
I don't criticise single parents at all, I have been one myself and so know how hard it is. I totally understand what you are saying. I do feel that those mums who have the choice but still work are neglecting their kids. I also believe a good home is a loving one, it's not about having things. (although I know some people have to work just to make ends meet and that is perfectly understandable) I don't know why anyone would criticise a working mum who is single and has to cope on her own and has to do it.
@miamilady (4910)
• United States
19 Aug 07
As a stay at home mom, I am actually somewhat in awe of single moms and working moms... Sometimes as a stay at home mom my life seems very busy and I can't imagine having to juggle the things that I do AND work full time...and as a single parent, sometimes play the roll of mom AND dad. There may be some stay at home moms who judge working moms. I honestly have not seen much of that. I've more often heard working moms make comments about how they'd be bored if they stayed home and similar things. I don't think ALL working moms feel that way, but I know some truly feel like stay at home moms are fairly worthless. Thanks for your response and I commend you for being able to parent your child as you have. Take care.
@agnescav (566)
• United States
17 Aug 07
When I was a stay at home mom, I had friends that worked and those who stayed home. Since I met most of them through the Home and School Association, we had a common goal and there was no issue of this. I did have a working mother neighbor who frequently took advantage of stay at home moms, without ever really admitting she did it. She herself, was annoying. As a general rule, we were supportive of each other. It is a shame if things have regressed to before the 90's.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
13 Aug 07
I have done both...most stay at home moms work very hard at what they do and deserve all the respect in the world. There is a stigma about women who stay home i agree but I'm not sure why that is. you are right it is an individual decision and should be what is right for the family.
@Stiletto (4579)
13 Aug 07
Personally I had no choice but to go out to work because I was a single parent from the start. Well I guess I did have a choice - I could have lived on benefits (welfare) but that option just didn't appeal to me. I worked part-time until my daughter started school and from then on I worked full-time. I've never been critical of stay at home mothers - if that's an option that's open to them then fair enough it's their choice. I agree there is no right or wrong answer. I think it's as foolish to stereotype all stay at home mothers as lazy as it is to portray all working mothers as negligent - it's about what works for you and your family.
@cutepenguin (6431)
• Canada
13 Aug 07
I too think that each family has to do what's right for them. The thing is, for some women, you're never sure that you're doing the right thing. One way to affirm you're doing the right thing is if that is what others are doing. So people get really defensive about their choices, and conflict occurs.
@mkirby624 (1598)
• United States
13 Aug 07
I think the only reason one would be critical of the other is because they are not confident in their life decision. Most of the time career moms criticize stay at home moms because they wish they could stay at home more. Stay at home moms criticize career moms because they wish they could get out of the house like career moms. I'm not a mom, but I will probably keep my career when I become a mom because that is what I WANT to do. If I change my mind and WANT to stay home, I will. What others do won't affect my decision, not will what others do bother me.
@lucy02 (5016)
• United States
14 Aug 07
Well I'm not a mom but if I had children I would want to stay at home with them, especially when they are really young. Not everyone can do that and not everyone wants to. I don't think there is a right or wrong. I think a happy mother makes a better mom whether its working inside or outside the home.
@maddysmommy (16230)
• United States
14 Aug 07
Most definitely an individual or family choice, what works for one family may not work for others, and that does not mean one is worse off than the other. I have been in both situations and neither are easy, both require commitment, patience blah blah you name it, either situation is very hard and no one else can say to me which one is better because my family chose what was right for us at each time. I am glad that I have had the opportunity to be able to have done both - I don't feel my son has missed out entirely and I am glad that he is happy and safe, that is what is important to me. Now that he will be starting school next month I don't know what i am going to do? maybe take up a part time job or get fully involved in his school, we shall see. I am looking forward to having a bit of a break and quiet time for me though :)
@gradyslady (4054)
• United States
18 Sep 07
I know a lot of stay at home moms and a lot that go to work. Some of the stay at home moms say that they would never work, it's way too much of a hassle when the man can do it for them. I don't think that should be the reason of being a stay at home mom. I actually would like to be a stay at home mom, not because I hate working or whatever, but because I would be able to be there for my children and keep my home nice and neat. Also, I've had experience in the working world and I don't mind it, I just prefer to stay home and do those things.