sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

evolution email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)1 year ago

Do you honestly believe that primates are our ancestors? What makes you believe or not believe in the evolution theory? If you believe in evolution, who among the evolution theorists do you admire most and why?

 
 
sponsors
Audi A5 Discussion
Find Other A5 Owners Audi A5 Forums& Photos.
www.InsideLine.com

Map Control for ASP.NET
Easy To Use SDK For Programmers. Download Your Risk-Free Evaluation.
GIS.ThinkGeo.com

Find It at Local Pages
Looking for aspx web hosting? Search LocalPages.com.
Localpages.com

Chiang_Mai_boy (748) response was accepted on 9/17/2007.
denotes best response.
tags:  evolution, darwin, monkey, creation, god
 
1. myLot reputation of 98/100. bamabride (1161)   1 year ago

Yes, I believe in the theory of evolution as outlined by Darwin's Theory of Evolution. It has a lot of basis to it.


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  1 year ago

To further enrich the discussion, could you cite at least some of the bases of Darwin's theory of evolution? Would it be proper to assume that Darwin is your favorite evolution theorist? If yes, why? Thanks, bamabride!;)


myLot reputation of 19/100. Chiang_Mai_boy (748)  1 year ago

Darwin's theory is actually the 'Theory of Natural Selection,' Evolution is the resulting process. If you want the short course try;

http://evolution.berkeley.edu


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  1 year ago

Thanks for the very useful link, Chiang_mai_boy!;)


myLot reputation of 92/100. flowerchilde (5358)  9 months ago

I've read that link, all it says is thus and thus is what happened. And no support! Of course so many believe the theory/assumption to be proven and fact, who needs to support it. Most folks don't even know what the theory is.. nor the difference between it and natural selection.. here's just one example: We so often hear how bacteria developing resistance to antibiotics is a PROOF of evolution.. but all it is, is natural selection of traits "already present" not the growing or evolving of "new traits" or "new species"/new life. The antibiotic kills off the nonresistant bacteria, and the resistant bacteria multiplies. This is natural selection (of traits*already present*) long believed before the stretch proposed by Mr. Darwin and those who have taken it so much farther after him.. The evolution theory/assumption is just another belief.. one filled with lots of weird mythical creatures, like the Greek satyrs, half one thing, half another.. Answer me Mr. Dawkins (most famous evolutionist today) how did the land cow/whale survive all those thousands/millions/billions of years it was no longer efficient as a cow, but not yet efficient as a whale?? Best case scenario.. it might've.. it could've.. maybe/ imagine this.. That's the whole theory in a nutshell. [The state enforced belief/philosophy.]
- We need more evolution taught! To include the many (many) questions and problems with the theory, which now, however is suppressed. Here's a brief list of more of those problems and questions:
www.inner-monastery.com/evolution.html
..have a good day!:)


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  9 months ago

I definitely agree that "We need more evolution taught" in order to "include the many (many) questions and problems with the theory, which now, however is suppressed," especially since it could potentially lead to a more enlightened discussion and better understanding of such a controversial topic.

Thanks a lot for openly sharing your thoughts and feelings with regard to evolution and for providing that very interesting link!

Have a good day, too, and Happy myLotting, flowerchilde!;)


myLot reputation of 73/100. xd14keilrisker (161)  8 months ago

Evolution got many flaws and is not accurate. You can't say it has lots of basis into it.


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  8 months ago

Thanks a lot for openly sharing your sentiments as regards evolution, xd14keilrisker! Enjoy the holidays and Happy myLotting!;)

Audi A5 Discussion Find Other A5 Owners Audi A5 Forums & Photos. www.InsideLine.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 86/100. oneandonemakesix (24203)   1 year ago

I do not believe in evolution. I do not believe we evolved from monkeys. In fact I think that there has been evidence to disprove evolution...but these people worked to hard to get evolution into textbooks and schools.....

I believe what the Bible says on faith and that God created the heavens and earth.


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  1 year ago

For further enlightenment, could it be possible for you to cite some of the pieces of evidence that you've mentioned, which disprove evolution? Thanks!;)


myLot reputation of 92/100. flowerchilde (5358)  9 months ago

...there are 70+ ways of dating the earth.. many suggest a much younger earth than the millions/now billions/soon trillions of years needed for evolution to have occurred. There's but a handful of ways of dating the earth which suggest this great time span. And there are just as many ways of dating the earth which actually agree (yes agree) with the biblical time frame..
- Actually, since Mr Darwin's day, we have been able to look into the inner workings of "the cell" and have seen that it is like a great metropolis in its scope and networking (and couldn't have possibly evolved, no matter how much time is allowed).. and we have discovered the DNA strands in all living things.. The program. Now when someone shows me a program (and computer) which evolved into being, all on its own, why then they'll have something.. or what about the lowly and humble bird, more intricate and efficient than our jumbo jets.. show me how the jumbo jet came together and came to be.. all on its own, and I'll believe the bird did too. Mr. Darwin's evolution theory is outdated.. we need to move the debate on to "what sort of intelligence was involved in origins?" But the cons and questions of this theory are suppressed.. And like every untrue thing, its motto is "there is no other opinion" (allowed).


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  8 months ago

Do you think that there's something wrong when "these people worked to [sic] hard to get evolution into textbooks and schools?" If you do, could you kindly share it with us?

Thanks a lot for sharing your views and Happy myLotting, oneandonemakesix!;)

Map Control for ASP.NET Easy To Use SDK For Programmers. Download Your Risk-Free Evaluation. GIS.ThinkGeo.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 19/100. Chiang_Mai_boy (748)   1 year ago

Yes I do believe that primates are our ancestors although we split, genetically, from them 4.5 million years ago. There is really no evolutionary theory. Evolution is an ongoing process that has been clearly demonstrated. There are no evolutionary theorist that I know of. There are a lot of scientist whose work take them into the study of the evolutionary process. They come from all fields, from anthropology to zoology. One that I admire is Dr. Francis Collins who is the director of the Human Genome Project.


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  1 year ago

Thanks for the clarification, Chiang_Mai_boy. I'll try to check the works of Dr. Francis Collins to further my understanding of evolution.

Find It at Local Pages Looking for aspx web hosting? Search LocalPages.com. Localpages.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 89/100. crystalball (1244)   1 year ago

Hi Acme:

No I don't believe that.

The scientist can't prove it, it's called 'the missing link'.

If we were any thing before we were humans we would have been a fish with legs. The earth was all water and when part of it died we could walk onto the sand.

Have a nice day.

Lyla


myLot reputation of 19/100. Chiang_Mai_boy (748)  1 year ago

Sorry there is no missing link. The science of Comparative Genomics shows that the human genome diverged from the chimpanzee 4.5 million years ago. That is when we became human. There is nothing missing so there is no missing link.


myLot reputation of 96/100. gharinder (1090)  10 months ago

well, the most immediate ancestors of humans are definitely primates, the origin of life was first seen in oceans, in deep oceans, as there was no ozone layer and uv rays could reach the earth and then with time organisms evolved that could live on land. so the first organisms that evolved on earth were those that used to live in water


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  10 months ago

Thanks a lot for that interestingly valuable piece of information about evolution, gharinder!

Happy myLotting!;)


myLot reputation of 92/100. flowerchilde (5358)  9 months ago

..Clarification: it is believed by some, the human genome diverged from the chimpanzee 4.5 million/billion/trillion years ago.. There are plenty of scientists which do not believe in the theory of evolution.. And if we listen to the debates, rather than one side, the "Intelligent Design" theorists are ahead by a mile when it comes to both logic and evidence. But still the band plays on.. it's proven.. it's fact.. If ya say it long enough, why that's what makes it true.
- As far as missing links, they have a handful of particles.. No liovng links found, ever. No fossil links found.. just desperate attempts, where part is found here, and another part ten miles away.. weird things like that! I don't call that science.
- The human genome proves evolution as an origin of life, or even species, cannot occur. The DNA strands are the program. The information. Where does information come from? Programs?


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  8 months ago

Thanks a lot for sharing your inputs as regards evolution, flowerchilde! Happy myLotting!;)

 
5. myLot reputation of 66/100. barehugs (2508)   1 year ago

Theres absolutely no Doubt in my Mind..... We evolved from Monkeys!
Turn on the News.... theres bound to be at least 2 incidents on each Newscast...... where people are behaving and, or, thinking like Monkeys. Pick up a magazine, look at the fashion pages..... See all those People dressed like Monkeys? and not only clothes... Look at their Hair!
People steal from their neighbors, cover the walls of buildings with Graffiti, eat Bananas and throw the skins in the street.
You don't have to be an Einstein to subscribe to this theory, anybody can see it. Just walk down the street and observe!


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  9 months ago

Thanks a lot for sharing your unique view and Happy myLotting!;)

 
6. myLot reputation of 19/100. leavert65 (173)   1 year ago

You can find a mini video series on the topic by clicking on my photo


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  10 months ago

Thanks a lot and Happy myLotting!;)

 
7. myLot reputation of 97/100. sarahruthbeth22 (6973)   10 months ago

Why not. Who's to say that G-d couldn't have started with the apes and then His vision evolved?


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  10 months ago

Thanks a lot for sharing your opinion on the matter!

Happy myLotting, sarahruthbeth22!;)

 
8. myLot reputation of 96/100. gharinder (1090)   10 months ago

there is no reason to disbelief that primates were our ancestors, i belief in the evolution theory, as such i dont admire any theorists, but i find both the theories of darwin and lamarck interesting.


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  10 months ago

I truly appreciate your fine contribution to this discussion, gharinder.

Thanks a lot and Happy myLotting!;)


myLot reputation of 73/100. xd14keilrisker (161)  8 months ago

There is a big reason to disbelief that primates are our ancestors. The reason is that is a BIG lie. The theory is not so accurate. And there are many reason why human do not come form primates. That theory is a mere speculation.


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  7 months ago

^Your claim that evolution "is a BIG lie," "is not so accurate," or "is a mere speculation" seems really interesting.

To be clear and for our enlightenment, though, can you share some of the "many reason why human do not come form primates?"

Thanks a lot in advance and Happy myLotting!;)

 
9. myLot reputation of 90/100. drannhh (4429)   10 months ago

I did for a while when I was younger, but the more time I've had to think about it, to tell you the truth, the less I believe that primates are our ancestors. Although I have met some people who acted very much like THEIR ancestors may have been apes, I don't think mine were. Reptilians, maybe, but not apes.

I never cared much for Darwin, actually, but neither do I buy any of other prevailing theories. It would be better if people just postulated their ideas without either science or religion trying to shove their pet theories down everyone else's throats. Did you ever see the movie or read the book about the Scopes Monkey Trial? Scary times, but I'm not sure much as changed.


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  10 months ago

To be honest, drannhh, I haven't had the opportunity to read or watch Scopes Monkey Trial yet, but I surely want to read and watch it to understand better essentially where you're coming from.

Who's its author and who directed the movie version, if I may ask?

For our enlightenment, why do you say or prefer to believe that your ancestors are "Reptilians, maybe, but not apes?"

Just to clarify and further enrich this discussion, too, since you clearly said that "I never cared much for Darwin, actually but neither do I buy any of other prevailing theories" and "It would be better if people just postulated their ideas without either science or religion trying to shove their pet theories down everyone else's throats," would you be so kind to share what your beliefs are, if any, in so far as the origin of our species is concerned, at least?

Thanks a lot for your substantial contribution to this discussion and Happy myLotting!;)


myLot reputation of 90/100. drannhh (4429)  10 months ago

Stanley Kramer directed what is probably the best film version of this story in 1960 with Spencer Tracy and Fredric March acting. Also, there is a lot of information about the case on Wikipedia:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scopes_Trial

It is a difficult and complicated piece of history, but I think very important. If this were science, I should be happy to share my personal views, but it would be impossible to do so without veering off into religion and politics and those are two subject I prefer not to discuss in this kind of setting.

My comment about "Reptilians" was meant to be a humorous reference to a book by David Icke called Children of the Matrix, the content of which is not completely unrelated to the kinds of issues brought up in the Monkey Trials. Happy myLotting to you, too!




myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  10 months ago

I perfectly understand, drannhh.

Anyway, thanks a lot for the clarification and for the very interesting link.

Happy myLotting!;)

 
10. myLot reputation of 68/100. RosieS57 (667)   10 months ago

I ike E.O.Wilson and sociobiology. Study bee hives like he did and you can't help but marvel at the sophistication of behavior and communication that has evolved in bee soicieties worldwide.

Humans share 99% of their genome with chimpanzees. The gorilla and the orangutan are genetically the next closest species to Homo sapiens sapiens. There really is no doubt that the greater apes gave rise to hominids who gave rise to Neanderthals and Cro-Magnon man. Some factions may not like it, but the genetic evidence doesn't lie and can't be disputed.


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  10 months ago

I must agree that some factions may surely not like what you've just stated.

Nevertheless, thanks a lot for your significant contribution to this discussion!

Happy myLotting, RosieS57!;)


myLot reputation of 95/100. jwfarrimond (1166)  9 months ago

I read recently that scientists had managed to recover some Neanderthal DNA and that it was quite unlike the same DNA sequence in us. This possibly indicates that Neanderthals did not evolve from us, but where a separate branch. I can't cite a reference for this at the moment but I'll try to do so later on.


myLot reputation of 95/100. acmepride (652)  9 months ago

Thanks a lot for that interestingly relevant piece of info, jwfarrimond. I would truly appreciate any other data you could provide to further broaden the scope of this discussion and, hopefully, deepen my understanding of evolution.

Again, thanks for your participation and Happy myLotting!;)

 
similar discussions
Creation or Evolution?
How do you think we got here? Did we begin our existance as Plankton, and then evolve over...
Why animals' teeth are usually better than human beings' teeth?
It is not fair. As we use tooth brush, toothpaste, gloss, brushing liquid etc. However, our teeth...
Did Darwin really denounce Evolution on his sickbed?
I keep hearing Christians talk about how they don't believe in Evolution. Which is fine. Everyone...
We humans
What do you think a human should have (or not) apart from what it already has?
Evolution and how the world relates
It seems that the right thing to do is always to help each other out. If there are people starving...
Evolution Of Life
do you believe that man came from apes?me?i truly not believe that because i believe what are...
Humans of the top of the evolutionary ladder.
Here is something interesting which i came across while reading a book. It talks about our...
Evolution
Now, I personally don't beleive in evolution - but I had a question for anyone out there who did....
Has evolution stopped?
What do you think about it? Does the history of the world make sense about that? I mean, species...
Evolving From Ape to Man - Have We Been Lied To?
The other day while watching the Science Channel, I really started doing some thinking about double...