sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Do Some Works Of Art Make You Wonder?????? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker3 months ago

Okay maybe I'm weird......yes I am, but I've had an extensive study of art nearly all my life and have dabbled in painting myself at an early age. Having studied art, one VERY famous statue comes to mind...The Thinker by Auguste Rodin. It's a statue of a man, a nude man I might add, sitting down in deep, deep thinking contemplation. Okay..but...coughs, coughs.... whistle...ever since I first saw pictures of this statue all I can think of.....was Rodin capturing the moment The Thinker was sitting on the toilet taking a heavy duty dump?w00t
Okay folks am I the only one to think this? Are there any works of art you seriously questioned was behind the artist's mind? Name some of your weird interpretations of art of any kind.


The Thinker
 
 
thinker
sponsors
Washington Flooring
Find prescreened floor contractors in Washington DC in just one click.
contractors.clicksmart.com

Single and Over 40?
Meet Older, Sincere Singles Everyone is Serious and Screened.
www.MatureSinglesOnly.com

Used Honda Civic Si at Yahoo!
Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for a Honda Used Car.
www.honda.com/yahoo

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  art, thinker, mature content, weird interpretation of art, the thinker
 
1. myLot reputation of 99/100. zhuhuifen46 (2677)   ranked 11 out of 3,956 in thinker   3 months ago

Hi, pyewacket, your interpretation is really weird. But I agree first impression is hard to shake away. I have similar weird thought with the broken armed goddess. Everybody is admiring her perfect gesture, but I just cannot feel sorry for her, who stand there for show in such inferior status. Why not mend it in whatever way to make her at least complete. Maybe that is how it becomes an art piece deeply in our memory. Happy mylotting.


myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Are you thinking of the famous Venus di Milo statue? It could be her arm was broken off over age actually and not what the artist originally intended

 

myLot reputation of 93/100. hornetlover (2590)   ranked 177 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

But, still.... Venus don't have armsrolleyes

or maybe the artist ran out of clay to mold the arms and got lazy to get a new one?whistle


myLot reputation of 91/100. Annmac (789)   ranked 469 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Some facts you might like:
When the statue was originally found in the early 1800's the left arm was found with the two main pieces of the sculpture. (It's been joined in the middle). They didn't rejoin it as at the time as they thought it was a badly done restoration. Some sculptors didn't bother carving great detail on bits that couldn't be seen! It's believed she was holding the material around her lower body with the right hand and known she had an apple in the left.
It's a Greek Statue, very early and 'purists' call it Aphrodite of Melos. Venus is the Roman version of the same Goddess.

I often wonder if she'd have been as 'famous' if she was complete?

Washington Flooring Find prescreened floor contractors in Washington DC in just one click. contractors.clicksmart.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 98/100. mentalward (4233)   ranked 63 out of 3,956 in thinker   3 months ago

w00t I always thought of that statue as being a man who is thinking very hard on where he left his clothes. lol

I've often wondered exactly what was going through van Gogh's mind when he was painting because some of his paintings are VERY strange. And, of course, we all know that he was nuts enough to cut off his ear so there must have been a bit of insanity in every one of his paintings.
blink


myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Some of his paintings were actually great, but he did do that self-portrait of himself after his ear slicing episode.....that in itself was weird


myLot reputation of 96/100. BarBaraPrz (3351)   ranked 450 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Somewhere in the deep recesses of my addled brain lies a story about that, that it actually was Gaugin who nicked Vincent's ear in a duel over some broad...


myLot reputation of 98/100. mentalward (4233)   ranked 63 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Hi BarBara. Your comment made me do some investigating. I found an article about the debate over who, exactly, cut off part of Van Gogh's ear. It seems there is some controversy and no documenting evidence that Gauguin did it, as there is no "smoking gun" (or bloody rapier) to back that story up. But, the debate still continues.

Here's the link to that article: http://www.npr.org/templa...


myLot reputation of 93/100. hornetlover (2590)   ranked 177 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

ward, your interpretation is also funnylol Does the Thinker suffered from dimentia?whistle


myLot reputation of 79/100. amoyube1980 (664)   ranked 205 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

This post contains content of a mature nature. You must be Signed in or Registered to have the option to view this content.


myLot reputation of 98/100. mentalward (4233)   ranked 63 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Hornet, I think that he had a night on the town drinking heavily and woke up without his clothes. lol

amoyube, this information about the possibility of Van Gogh not being the one who cut off his earlobe has just recently been uncovered. It seems that, in the original police investigation, back when Van Gogh's ear was initially cut off, they had questioned Gauguin as the culprit because the two of them were roommates and often had violent arguments. But, since the truth was never uncovered, the romanticized version of Van Gogh cutting his ear off for his girlfriend was what became famous.

I doubt we'll ever know the truth but I like to think that the romantic version is the truth.


myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Yup--I had heard that possibility that it was Gaughin who chopped off Van Gogh's ear as well

Single and Over 40? Meet Older, Sincere Singles Everyone is Serious and Screened. www.MatureSinglesOnly.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 100/100. paula27661 (5150)   ranked 282 out of 3,956 in thinker   3 months ago

Ha! Ha! My thoughts exactly and I have often wondered why he is taking a dump in the nude. I am missing the real meaning too perhaps! I have often wondered what the Mona Lisa was thinking as she sat there...Was she romantically involved with Leonardo? I would love to know who she was...


myLot reputation of 96/100. BarBaraPrz (3351)   ranked 450 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

There is one theory that the model for Mona was Leonardo himself and therein lies the mystery behind the famous smile, or smirk in that case.


myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

That's what I heard too, that the Mona Lisa was actually DaVinci in, uh....drag...LOL--hence maybe that smile?


myLot reputation of 100/100. paula27661 (5150)   ranked 282 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Really? Da Vinci in drag? Well I did not know that, it's an interesting theory and probably true... happy

Used Honda Civic Si at Yahoo! Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for a Honda Used Car. www.honda.com/yahoo
 
4. myLot reputation of 96/100. youngpatrol (293)   ranked 972 out of 3,956 in thinker   3 months ago

I have to admit, it does make us wonder what goes through peoples mind's when they do art work. To me the thinker look's like he is sitting on the toilet thinking. Some painting's are just very strange and leave you wondering what were they thinking. Yet those are the painting's that sell for million's of dollar's.


myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Yes it really does make you wonder. I love his artwork but it makes me wonder what Salvatore Dali was thinking when he did his paintings...like the dripping clocks one


myLot reputation of 59/100. Maggiepie (1466)   ranked 51 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Dali craved attention & weirdness for its own sake. He once had a very long loaf of bread specially made just so he'd wow the press when he got off the train carrying it. He was disappointed & peeved when they didn't mention or even seem to not notice it. (I think they were used to his antics, & simply refused to rise to the latest bait.... rolleyes)

He was also heavily into mystic symbolism, & loved to do marvelous illusions (sort of doubling up; paintings are inherently illusions anyway....). He was one of my first (& still favorite inspirations), & heavily influenced my early works. He would've been a real pain to live with, though, as Maya, his beloved wife, would have agreed! happy

I never wondered what was in his mind when I saw his creations, though; I was always more interested in how they opened up my mind with their surrealism, making me see new worlds, or old ones in an entirely new way.

Maggiepie
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"

DC Storage Trailers Find Washington DC storage trailers & containers -- all sizes, rates. Storage.YellowPages.com/DC
 
5. myLot reputation of 97/100. sarahruthbeth22 (10370)   ranked 318 out of 3,956 in thinker   3 months ago

No. It never does.Either the piece flows over me and I am moved or I don't get it and it wasn't made for me to get. I never try to analyze art. It is too precious.


myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

I actually do question some artist's works and what they were thinking...for instance what was Pollack thinking of when he did his paintings that look like splatters of paint that a child might have done?


myLot reputation of 59/100. Maggiepie (1466)   ranked 51 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Pye: "Hmmm...I wonder how many I can fool with this crap, & I wonder how much I can get for them?" wink

Maggiepie (ducking)lol
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"


myLot reputation of 59/100. Maggiepie (1466)   ranked 51 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Ditto that thought for Rotheke.

Me again
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"


myLot reputation of 97/100. sarahruthbeth22 (10370)   ranked 318 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

I saw the movie and in it his style came from an accident. He was about to paint and it dripped from his brush and bam, it hit him this was the way to express his art. I am too busy either liking it or avoiding art to sit and think " How did he do that? And why?"

washington dc roofing Looking for Remodelers? View the top Washingtondc experts. contractors.locallytrusted.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 99/100. ElicBxn (15134)   ranked 317 out of 3,956 in thinker   3 months ago

having seen one of the casts (and several of the early tries) of the statue in a display of the artist, it doesn't QUITE work, tho I've certainly seen cartoons of it doing so

did you know he has a bronze of it on his grave?


myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

LOL--really? He has a bronze of it on his grave?blink


myLot reputation of 99/100. ElicBxn (15134)   ranked 317 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

that's what the show said - here's a quote from Wikipedia...

"A cast of The Thinker was placed next to his tomb in Meudon; it was Rodin's wish that the figure serve as his headstone and epitaph."

Mini Storage WA Free Truck Rental with move in & boxes only $.99. Reserve risk free. www.MiniuStorage.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 96/100. BarBaraPrz (3351)   ranked 450 out of 3,956 in thinker   3 months ago

No, you're not the only one to come to that conclusion about The Thinker. Just give him a newspaper or crossword puzzle book and the scenario would be complete. lol
Brain's not fully in gear, so can't remember the name of painting (the title had something to do with Fire) nor artist, but the National Gallery bought a huge painting of a red stripe on a white background, for like a gazillion dollars... I know what was on the "artist's" mind -- easy money -- but what about the buyers? Did they have a collective brain fart?


myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

I managed to find it...it's called the Voice of Fire...yes, I've seen similar type of paintings and wondered, like huh?confused

 
Travel to Washington DC Browse the Best Travel Deals to Washington DC. Use Travelzoo. www.Travelzoo.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 94/100. Lakota12 (16871)   ranked 327 out of 3,956 in thinker   3 months ago

Always womdered what happened to Venus's arms were they chopped off for some reason!


myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Well that statue is rather old,...they just might have fallen off with time???


myLot reputation of 94/100. Lakota12 (16871)   ranked 327 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

we will never really know for asure no one around now to tell us!

Great Variety of Washington DC Souvenirs Great selection of Washington DC Souvenirs. We have shot glasses, caps, coins, mugs, bells, magnets, keychains, golfballs, photo frames, playing cards, mouse pads, sweatshirts and more. www.pdsouvenir.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 78/100. whiteheather39 (13290)   ranked 301 out of 3,956 in thinker   3 months ago

I first saw "The Thinker" statue many, many years ago and that he was sitting on the loo was my first thought as well. I have also seen my exes in the same pose in the same location!lol


myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

I'm glad I'm not the only one to think that statue is sitting on the royal thronelol

D.C. Chrysler Dealer Find New Vehicle Deals at Your Local Washington Chrysler Dealer www.ChryslerDealer.com
 
10. mandiSDlady (14)   ranked 1,098 out of 3,956 in thinker   3 months ago

I live in Rapid City, SD and we have an alley downtown that is dedicated to local artist to express themselves. The alley is basically a large canvas for the Artist. It is actually becoming a large tourist attraction. While walking down Art Alley, you can see everything from classic cartoon characters, to self portraits, to plastic heads with "face paint", anything you can think of. Some people call it graffiti, some people call it art. I admit to walk down it parts can be "scary" because just about everyone sees art differently. Just as to a young child, banging two pans together is music; as to maybe an adult it's just noise. A Surgeon sees a internal body part as amazing, others may see it as disgusting. It's really all in the eye of the beholder.


myLot reputation of 98/100. pyewacket (11580)   ranked 44 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Some "graffiti" is actually quite beautiful but makes me wonder, why are they painting on walls or streets instead of canvases?


mandiSDlady (14)   ranked 1,098 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

I agree, but sometimes it's that open area that inspires. Being in that moment, that "freedom" of having a whole building to express yourself. And to alot of the artist that I know who have regular stuff in Art Alley think of it as being a sell out if they were to go canvas. But I know acouple that do both, canvas and Art Alley. Just to pay bills and that kinda stuff. I was really amazed to see how many artist there are in such a small town like Rapid City, SD. You'll never know what you'll find, till it finds you.


myLot reputation of 59/100. Maggiepie (1466)   ranked 51 out of 3,956 in thinker  3 months ago

Pye: It's "the people's gallery." In other words, it's free advertisement. Galleries are exclusive, & don't want to display unknowns for free, in my experience.

Maggiepie
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"

WA Appraiser License Start Your Appraiser Career Today. 110% Money Back. PDA Included. www.RealEstateLicense.com
 
sponsors
DC Storage Trailers
Find Washington DC storage trailers& containers -- all sizes, rates.
Storage.YellowPages.com/DC

washington dc roofing
Looking for Remodelers? View the top Washingtondc experts.
contractors.locallytrusted.com

Mini Storage WA
Free Truck Rental with move in& boxes only $.99. Reserve risk free.
www.MiniuStorage.com

similar discussions
What is your favourite art movement?
I love contemporary art and have become quite interested in abstract work. What about you?
Art related to flower!
Recently I developed a new interest, that is ikebana. Ikebana is a Japanese art of arranging...
Arts and Life: A Debate
There are debate on arts and life is always going on:Arts' for art sake or arts' for life's...
Landscape architecture
I am a freshly graduated landscape architect and I would love to meet people who know anything...
do you ever get caught up in the technicalities?
the best example of what i'm talking about it in art because i love drawing. when you look at a...
IS SEX AN ART?
seriously think and respond.
Thomas Kinkade...The Painter of Light...
I was researching Thomas Kinkade this morning and I ended up putting one of his pics as my desktop...
watermark my photos??
Hai everyone...I am Amit Gandhi from India...I heard about mylot just recently...Since I am new...
Car from Nike...!!
hey guys...do you wanna have a look at a car from Nike....if you wanna have a look at it, then just...
What is the most artistic natural thing in your city?
What is the most artistic natural thing in your city? By that, I mean, what is the most beautiful...
sponsors
DC Storage Trailers
Find Washington DC storage trailers & containers -- all sizes, rates.
Storage.YellowPages.com/DC
washington dc roofing
Looking for Remodelers? View the top Washingtondc experts.
contractors.locallytrusted.com
Mini Storage WA
Free Truck Rental with move in & boxes only $.99. Reserve risk free.
www.MiniuStorage.com
Travel to Washington DC
Browse the Best Travel Deals to Washington DC. Use Travelzoo.
www.Travelzoo.com
Great Variety of Washington DC Souvenirs
Great selection of Washington DC Souvenirs. We have shot glasses, caps, coins, mugs, bells, magnets, keychains, golfballs, photo frames, playing cards, mouse pads, sweatshirts and more.
www.pdsouvenir.com
D.C. Chrysler Dealer
Find New Vehicle Deals at Your Local Washington Chrysler Dealer
www.ChryslerDealer.com
WA Appraiser License
Start Your Appraiser Career Today. 110% Money Back. PDA Included.
www.RealEstateLicense.com
Washington Jeep Dealer
Find New Vehicle Deals at Your Local Washington Jeep Dealer
www.JeepDealer.com
Washington Background Check - $14.95
Washington Background Check. Statewide felony and misdemeanor records since 1997. 3-state search $29.95 or our 39-state search for $34.95. Quick results. Easy online ordering.
www.backgroundferret.com
Washington D.C.'S Premier Entertainers
D.C.'s Top Comedy Magician Team. Exciting Dove And Stage Illusions.
www.speedthro.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.