sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

sorry for what my country has done? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics4 months ago

how much do you identify with your country? do you feel bad about things it (or rather its government) has done in the past? in my case, much as i enjoy not identifying with the uk i do occasionally feel some secondhand guilt for past (and indeed not that past) misdeeds. hiya india for starters. also do you think that politicians should ever apologise for things even though clearly neither they nor their government are in any way responsible? german ones have done this and i think it was the right thing to do even though germany now has one of the best systems in europe. (i think, if you live in germany and wish to correct me please do)

 
 
politics
sponsors
Obama Urges Homeowners to Refinance
See Rates - No Credit Check Needed. ($90,000 Refinance under $489/mo)
www.LowerMyBills.com

Obama Backs Auto Insurance Regulation
Drivers Pay $44/mo on Avg for Car Insurance. Are you paying too much?
Auto-Insurance-Experts.com

Online Degrees
Get Your AA, BA, Masters or PhD at a Top Online School. Start Now.
Education.Nextag.com/Online-Degrees

thea09 (4672) response was accepted on 11/9/2009.
denotes best response.
tags:  country, identify, sorry, politics, government
 
1. myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics   4 months ago

While you may have India on your list of guilts, Ireland should be first. Just saying. wink


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

hello person who does not live in ireland. you have a point.


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

True, but I am an O'Neill! That makes me clan Irish. So there. lol


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

irishididevildeeds. hey you have unwittingly just given me an opportunity to say just how funny the americans that come over here with claims of scottish ancestry are. you may well be called macleod but you are clearly an american. [goes into convoluted xenophobic rant]


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Yes, I am an American. My kids can claim to be 3rd generation Irish-American on their paternal side but so all intents and purposes we're just American.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

you can get to 3rd generation? goodness you don't have the background i do. we can get to 2nd and then it becomes 'we're not sure'


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

That's only if I'm going to be technical about it. Only one group is truly American and they probably came from somewhere themselves originally.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

just about everybody does. we all orginally came from africa i think. africa might be an exception. hey just realised that celts came from india - i think i can work that into a reason not to feel guilty [evil cackle] [goes on to pm indian friends with an apology take back] [second evil cackle]


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

I'm going to be in so much trouble for saying this, but now you're starting to sound American. lol


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

angryangryangry


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

I love it when I strike a nerve. I am so evil. lol


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

i have the skin of a rhinocerous notreallyirish. your evil attempts to try and hurt my feelings will never work.


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Can't be all that thick. Stiff upper lip. You aren't looking at it the right way. I just dissed my country. LOL


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

by accusing me of sounding like i came from your godforsaken land. an (admittedly feeble) attempt to hurt my feelings that was.


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

You said you had a reason not to feel guilty. America tends to come up with excuses why it shouldn't feel guilty. We often stick our noses in where we aren't wanted and claim it's because we're bringing democracy. So if you don't like me saying it then squeeze out some guilt.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

are the excuses ever as pathetic as mine was?


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Yes they are, quite often. Probably more so. The fact the US has its own issues it should straighten out before telling other countries how to run is proof of that. Here they are refusing to recognize Honduras simply for following it's own constitution.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

you'd better not be trying to confuse me evil. really wouldn't have expected to get these kind of views off you.


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Is my liberal showing? Honestly, I have quite a liberal side but I believe liberalism has been corrupted. At least in the states as far as I'm concerned. I always look at the rights of all while some (not all) liberals here look at the rights of those they agree with. While I may not like what an opposing view is, I respect the right to have one.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

if you feel like that all i can say is what on earth do you think you are doing in the mylot politics section? hold on a sec. what the hell do i think i'm doing being here? [rabbit bounces off in a confused daze]


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

It's the debate and frankly, I like to argue. lol


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

if someone has something intelligent to say, even if i think it is wrong, then i like to hear it. i have even been known to change my mind (not very often because obviously a mind like mine is rarely mistakenhappy) and also know that there can be different ways of seeing something that all have something valid in them (the dreaded 'a' word is an example of this]. [rabbit realises that she is posting in entirely the wrong section and buggers off}


myLot reputation of 79/100. spalladino (9043)   ranked 174 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

You crack me up when you refer to the U.S. as "god forsaken". lol I see God's hand here every day.

No matter, what I wanted to comment on in this thread has more to do with Irish's comment regarding her heritage. Yes, most of us are originally from someone else. My family tree grows in many directions internationally. My father's father was Irish...his wife was English. Her family tree goes back to the House of Tudor, to King Edward VI. My mother's father was German. I was born in Baltimore, Maryland and brought a little bit of Baltimore down here to Florida where I will forever be considered a Yankee no matter how long I live here. We are all products of what came before us...so you can call me Princess. rasp


myLot reputation of 70/100. II2aTee (797)   ranked 115 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

irishididevildeeds. hey you have unwittingly just given me an opportunity to say just how funny the americans that come over here with claims of scottish ancestry are. you may well be called macleod but you are clearly an american. [goes into convoluted xenophobic rant]


LOL JB I totalyu sympathize witrh you on this.

I am half Native American. Iroquois, Turtle clan. My Grandmother was the Clan Mother.

When people find this out they all of a sudden feel some kind of kinship with me. I kid you not every time someone finds out I'm Native American, their reply is this: "I am too!! My great great grandmother was Cheroke Indian!!"

Over the years I've learned to roll my eyes and laugh. EVERYONE in America has a Cheroke ancestor. And if they would just read a history book, they would find out why.

Of course, if they did that.. they might not be so quick to boast their ancestory.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

i found the same thing in certain south american countries (everybody was mixed but the racicism was horrendous, possibly like the wee ua now?


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Tee,

Everyone asks me if I'm Native American. They tell me I look it. I choose not to identify with it simply because I don't know. I can only go by stories and without concrete proof I'm certainly not going to go around calling myself tribal. The O'Neill I know from having met my biological grandmother.
I think people say Cherokee because it is one of the better known tribes. I have a friend who comes from one of the lesser known tribes. Can't recall it though something Seneca. I'd be more likely to believe someone was in a lesser known one than one you hear about all the time. But you're right about the Cherokee claims. I know a lot of them. LOL


myLot reputation of 70/100. II2aTee (797)   ranked 115 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

I'm just the opposit Irish. Most people dont believe me when I tell them I am Native American because I have red hair and my skin is on the lighter side. A gift from my mothers Irish heritage (LOL I had to throw that in there to tweek Bunny a bit:p

But when I stand next to my father, its more than apparent. He is full blooded Native American, and my face, build and bone structure are an exact duplicate of his. If my skin was just a few shades darker and my hair was black I could get away with being full blooded.

But Irish I'm willing to bet anything you have some Native American heritage in you. Like I said... everyone is a Cheroke LOL!


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

evil - count yourself luckyy girly. i also look like someone who is not from the country i actually orginate from - and it is fantastic. particulularly in countries like greece - look greek, burble away in greek and you will never have the problems often encountered by irritating british tourists


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Funny about appearances. My daughters are dark and one might see them as being Native American. My son is blond with blue eyes. He looks nothing like his sisters. My oldest daughter is a half sister to her two siblings and if one were to see them all together they would think my son didn't belong in the family although he and my middle child are fully related on both sides. I tell you I got a lot of comments when he was born. I kept telling them it couldn't be the mailman. lol


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

small and dark provides a great travelling oppotunity - tell her that nobody to begin with will guess that she is from your awful country. if she can speak anything other than american they'll probably never guess anyway


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

What? Small? Not my daughters. One's 6'2". Now my son is a wee one who stretches himself to be that tad bit taller than mom. lol


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Do you think that someone who appears ethnic is given more allowances than someone who doesn't? No one gives a thought to a black person dressing in African garb even though they've never been in Africa or Indians born and raised in the states wearing a sari. Even Native Americans to a certain degree. It seems to me that whites tend to be looked at strangely if they embrace their culture. As if we are being expected to assimilate while others don't have to. What are the thoughts?


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

small and dark describes me. incidently i'm the oldest and also the shortest of my siblings - i have very small bones and am not fat which makes me look even smaller. [goes off to stuff face in a vain attempt to remedy this].


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

ok i can actually understand someone feeling proud of their roots (americans in kilts still make me snigger behind their backs though. sorry) although it may not always come across as particularly sensible.


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

I'd much rather see Americans in Kilts than in the current teenage male fashion of one's behind hanging out of their pants that are tightly belted to their knees. Although it's funny as heck watching them try to run.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

they are still doing that? do you know that when i'm busy stereotyping your horrible country i tend to refer to it as whatever ''''insert name of south american country here' did in the seventies?


myLot reputation of 57/100. Maggiepie (1604)   ranked 1,795 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

Spalladino (I hope that's spelled correctly!) said: "You crack me up when you refer to the U.S. as "god forsaken". lol I see God's hand here every day."

Ditto.

Sp. continued: "No matter, what I wanted to comment on in this thread has more to do with Irish's comment regarding her heritage. Yes, most of us are originally from someone else."

Everyone, including "Native Americans" came from "somewhere else!" lol Except, as someone pointed out, Africans (those who still live on that continent, anyway, excluding the European stock, of course--no, wait, their ancestors came from Africa, too! So...I guess that makes everyone in the USA African-American...right?).

More Sp.: "My family tree grows in many directions internationally. My father's father was Irish...his wife was English. Her family tree goes back to the House of Tudor, to King Edward VI. My mother's father was German. I was born in Baltimore, Maryland and brought a little bit of Baltimore down here to Florida where I will forever be considered a Yankee no matter how long I live here."

Cousin! Your family lineage is almost the same as mine--including the Tudors! I have two branches of Amerind (Iroquios & Oklahoman Cherokee) from my Dad's side, but my Mom's side added a plethora of other things, such as French & Russian Jew.


And Sp. ended with: "We are all products of what came before us...so you can callme Princess. rasp"

Ain't that the truth! It's an old planet, & we've got ancestors from all points on it, if we only knew. The human genome proves this. It also proves there's no such critter as a "pure" race, either.

I'm just sayin.... whistle

Maggiepie
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"


myLot reputation of 79/100. spalladino (9043)   ranked 174 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

I agree Maggiepie, there can be no pure race...not anymore. Nice to have a cousin on the board. thumbup


myLot reputation of 57/100. Maggiepie (1604)   ranked 1,795 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

Spalladino: lol So glad to meet you, paisan! wink (Is that spelled correctly? Wait, if you're male--would it be paisano?)

Maggiepie
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"

Obama Urges Homeowners to Refinance See Rates - No Credit Check Needed. ($90,000 Refinance under $489/mo) www.LowerMyBills.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 97/100. celticeagle (4853)   ranked 1,534 out of 6,391 in politics   4 months ago

I do identify with my country. I am patriotic and i agree with what they are doing as far as helping people in other countries. I don't like the crap going on overseas but I agree with the reason behind it. Not everything can be taken care of in a day either. I think my country could do alot worse.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

had to quickly check what your country was there - states right? well your country has indeed done quite a few bad things but i'll agree that it could have done worse.


myLot reputation of 97/100. celticeagle (4853)   ranked 1,534 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Yes, indeed and it has a history of trying to help.

Obama Backs Auto Insurance Regulation Drivers Pay $44/mo on Avg for Car Insurance. Are you paying too much? Auto-Insurance-Experts.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 96/100. thea09 (4672)   ranked 321 out of 6,391 in politics   4 months ago

Morning jb, you're up early. I shall just address your last point here as you seem to have lumped a couple of discussions into one.

Whilst it is patenty ridiculous to carry the can for centuries old misdaeeds it is also ridiculous in a modern world to not admit responsibility and make good the misdeeds of one generation, and this is where you're example of German is wrong in my mind. I'll cite a couple of examples and I'm sure if I'm in error then Tony will be along to correct me with a more up todate version of events.

There are still active German companies who have not taken full responisibility for their use of slave labour during the last war and have not offered suitable recompense for stealing other peoples lives in this way. I'm sure at some point the German gov. could have forced them to do something and certainly if they act as other govs. then plenty of its members will have some kind of personal association with these companies but would rather bank their profits than address this matter. This may appear to be for some something in the past but it's been ignored for over half a century by most.

And don't tell me that the German gov. could not have put some influence on the Swiss banks which hold onto the stolen wealth of jews and probably have active accounts to past nazi member memebers families. Stolen assets remain stolen and if anyone had been serious about returning them than the german gov had opportunities a plenty to raise the issue publicly and loudly to put pressure from themeselves and other governments to demand the return to stolen assets sitting in these secret bank accounts. No serious pressures were ever put to bear on this matter and if there had been unity in outrage then something could have been done but the german goverment instead, by doing nothing, condoned theft on a massive scale and no doubt enjoyed some of the rewards of this huge reserve of funds, not collectively as a government but on an individual basis.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

i'm usually up early. however i have something rather dull that i should be doing - which is why i am faffing about here. you know (for once) what you are burbling on about so i'll let you win. ps do you know where you are? w00t


myLot reputation of 96/100. thea09 (4672)   ranked 321 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

I had no idea where I was as you failed to inform me in advance as per our agreement. You really should pop in and see dear Peter. I could be safe here as it's outside the range a bit, I think, so thus outside the firing range.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

i think you'd be safe anyway. i'm not - they know who i am. i drop points everytime i post here. granted i am annoying but even so. btw any wolves looking at this - i know who you are and while i don't minus people i'd like to point out that the main effect of negative rating people is to make your own star drop.


myLot reputation of 95/100. jwfarrimond (2404)   ranked 431 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Naming names.. one of the "active German companies" who used slave labour during the war is Volkswagen..


myLot reputation of 96/100. thea09 (4672)   ranked 321 out of 6,391 in politics  2 months ago

A BR in politics no less jb. thumbup

Online Degrees Get Your AA, BA, Masters or PhD at a Top Online School. Start Now. Education.Nextag.com/Online-Degrees
 
4. myLot reputation of 77/100. spicysweetie21 (1400)   ranked 372 out of 6,391 in politics   4 months ago

I have talked about this in the past, but even though he is now my ex and this happened a long time ago, I do feel very bad about how the U.S (my country) put japanese people, including his parents, into the internment camps, and also how we dropped the A bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Both of those things definitely made me feel bad to be a white american, even so many years after the fact.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

it's strange how you can feel bad about things that are absolutely nothing to do with you isn't it? completely off-topic really good thing he's your ex btw- he didn't sound like a great guy at all spicysweetie


myLot reputation of 78/100. xfahctor (5555)   ranked 63 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Spicy, before you feel TOO bad about Nagasaki and Hiroshima, you should be aware our west coast came very close to suffering the same fate. We just got lucky enough to be faster at building our bomb. The target date for the joint japanese/german nuclear strike on our west coast and pacific fleet was going to be days after we dropped ours. In short, we just got there first. Had we not ended the war in such quick fashion, had we not developed and used a nuclear weapon, WE would have been the first nation in history to have one dropped on us rather than Japan.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

x - hey do you seriously think your wee soddisng country and its belated invlovement ended ww II finsnished it? if so go ahead - braincells are being faxed over


myLot reputation of 78/100. xfahctor (5555)   ranked 63 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Jb, I was speaking to the pacific front and the conflict between Japan and the U.S. with this particular post. The end of the European part of the war was a group effort.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

get on with it x. btw next discussion going up is~why don't americans say please' you and your soddingly awful country are going to get negs whenever i see you


myLot reputation of 20/100. itsmychoice (165)   ranked 2,332 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

Talking about soddenly awful, if it wasn't for your English evil bloodlines with all the money, starting all this One World Order, this discussion would not be here. Mainly the Bush family being tied to your evil empire. And your Scottish rites of Masons and Illuminati.


myLot reputation of 57/100. Maggiepie (1604)   ranked 1,795 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

jb78000

get on with it x. btw next discussion going up is~why don't americans say please' you and your soddingly awful country are going to get negs whenever i see you

This went too far. Not only are you using ugly language, but promising to break the rules by negatively rating someone just because you don't like their country?

I've reported you. I hope they through youR sorry posterior off, bigot! angry

Maggiepie
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

it was a joke maggie. and i think xfahctor may have got it. i enjoy winding up americans and if they don't get sarcasm then i have every intention of employing it wherever possible.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

also x is on my friends list - and i annoy him by plussing him every time i encounter him. as i do with the rest. i don't neg.


myLot reputation of 79/100. spalladino (9043)   ranked 174 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

Maggiepie, you really shouldn't jump to conclusions and especially when you've got an entire discussion full of jb's comments to help you determine whether she was joking or not. I assure you that she was. jb and I are friends and she's actually very nice, even with that silly habit of referring to my country as "god forsaken". happy


myLot reputation of 64/100. anniepa (9274)   ranked 380 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

I'm another American who knows how to take a joke and who is proud to have jb as a friend! Maggiepie, you need to lighten up a bit! Who with half a brain cell would actually TELL someone they're going to break the TOS by negating them because of where they're from?

Annie


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

rabbit pops in to plus nice american friends. spicy, x, annie and spall. you may well come from an awful country but i like you nonetheless.


myLot reputation of 57/100. Maggiepie (1604)   ranked 1,795 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

All right, JB. Sorry. It's hard to tell, sometimes, when someone is "joking." You sounded serious. I withdraw my complaint, with apologies. But since I'm too dumb to get sarcasm, next time, use an emoticon to let me know. "Nudge, nudge, wink, wink...say n'more!" thumbup

Oh, & someone asked who here would actually threaten to break a TOSable rule? I have seen it happen.

Maggiepie
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

alright/ when i encounter you i shall use inverted commas and capitals whenever i say something not that serious. they will be my written verson of that special voice members of your terrbile country use when they are being sarcastic...or actually may better for people to check carefully to gauge when i actually mean something to be taken seriously= have to admit one of my comments was a bit overthetop up there. you can always ask people who do this if they are being serious. oh well.


myLot reputation of 77/100. spicysweetie21 (1400)   ranked 372 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

Thanks for the thumb up JB happy I must admit that I had a fun time sitting back and watching the things that unfolded, and I wasn't the one arguing lol, I was going to respond at one point, but the back and forth all over the place made me realize I was best just being a spectator.

Top Online School Degrees Earn Your Degree from a Top School Online! Study at Home or Anywhere. CollegeDegreeNetwork.com/Schools
 
5. myLot reputation of 60/100. ParaTed2k (4591)   ranked 400 out of 6,391 in politics   4 months ago

The past is important to remember for only one reason... so we don't make the same mistakes. Trying to reconcile the misdeeds of the past require us to do two things.. and neither of them are good.

1) Just the people of the past by the standards of today.

This is a howling injustice to the people of the present. We look back in horror at the things done, but we don't look at them in the context of the day. If you were raised in a culture where slavery was ok, chances are you would become an adult that thinks it's ok. We all hope we'd be those enlightened few who was above all that, but the reality is, we probably wouldn't be.

2) Punishing people for the "sins of the fathers".

Sorry, but no one deserves that. My great great great great great great great great grandpa may have been a pretty scummy excuse for a human being, but that doesn't make me one. Your ancestors may have been scoundrels and rascals, but that doesn't make you one.

Now, that doesn't mean that apologies aren't in order at times. I think that if we come to our senses as a society, it is important for us as a society to apologize and make amends to the people our policies harmed. however, just to them, not to those who come long after the injustice is perpetrated.

The germans of today owe nothing to the Jews for the Holocaust. The Missourrians of today owe nothing to the Mormons for the "Mormon Extermination Act". Today's US Railroad workers need not feel guilt for the treatment of Chinese people while the original tracks were being laid.

I am a direct decendent of King Richard the Lionhearted. Which means a few things as far as lineage, but nothing as far as what he may or may not have done and what is owed to me, or what I owe to others. NOTHING.

We're born to the parents we're born to, in the geographical area we're born in. That means that we have physical psychological and behavioral characteristics that place us in various demographic groups. There is no inherent "original sin" that comes with those demographics. To believe their is is to prejudge entire groups unjustly.


myLot reputation of 60/100. ParaTed2k (4591)   ranked 400 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

It's all just a "something for nothing" scheme.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

richard the lionheart junior eh? hello ricky. what you've said is true, and well put actually. but i think a lot of people identify quite strongly with their country and as well as feeling secondhand proud of certain things (past and present) also sometimes feel bad about others.


myLot reputation of 60/100. ParaTed2k (4591)   ranked 400 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Yes, we do, and I think there is nothing wrong with a little pride or shameful feelings at the past. It's when we try to make the people of the present pay that crosses the line.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

[arrogant and ignorant brit returns] you need to explain yourself a bit more rickety.


myLot reputation of 60/100. ParaTed2k (4591)   ranked 400 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Sorry, I didn't know you were such a pompous pissant.

:::: Goes out and shoots a rabbit in effigy::::~D


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

more death threats? how feeble. thumbdown like pissant, new one for my collection. thumbup


myLot reputation of 60/100. ParaTed2k (4591)   ranked 400 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

But rabbit is my favorite game to hunt.;~D


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Rabbit-the only meat you can eat and floss your teeth at the same time. rasp


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

[at seeing two conservative anti-rabbit campaigners get very abusive and threatening, rabbit bounces in, complete with half a dozen kalashnikovs] which one of these two should i shoot first?


myLot reputation of 72/100. irishidid (3062)   ranked 1,315 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

That would be libertarian, thank you very much. At least for me. Not sure about Ted.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

aren't a lot of your awful country's people who i would normally tell to get back in their liberal/convervative wee boxes libby wotsits?


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

and if you got that congratulations. wouldn't mind an explanation of what librarians believe in though. (had some already but no harm in another).


myLot reputation of 60/100. ParaTed2k (4591)   ranked 400 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

There was a time I considered myself libertarian. In fact the Libertarian Party is the only one I've ever gone as far as filling out a form to join. But over time I realized that what I am is a Conservative with a handfull of liberal opinions.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

you are sodding useless paragraph. go and find yourself a wee box and then squeeze inside it - i have no intention of conversing with anybody that can think for themselves. or indeed think.


myLot reputation of 46/100. iriscot (743)   ranked 572 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

Hi Ted, I'm a moderate with some conservative leanings and some liberal leanings. So try and figure out what I truly am.

I'm just about to stay away from this board, I find there are too many negative thinkers on it. They seem to jump without reason or purpose.

Anti-Virus Download Free Virus, Adware, Spyware, Trojan and RootKit scan. Rated 5 Stars. www.pctools.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 64/100. anniepa (9274)   ranked 380 out of 6,391 in politics   4 months ago

Since I've never been OUT of my country I guess I identify pretty strongly with it. I love my country, I consider myself patriotic and a "good American" but I don't think loving one's country and being patriotic has to mean believing it's never done any wrong. During last year's Presidential campaign there were attacks at those who considered the U.S. to be "imperfect"; sorry, but I certainly think we're imperfect! Nobody and nothing is perfect and when you love someone or something that includes admitting the imperfections and wanting the best for the person or thing you love!

Absolutely, I feel "sorry" for some things my country has done in the past or for things that were allowed to happen to people in the past. I may not have done it, I don't know anyone who did it, nobody is still alive who did it but that doesn't mean we can't say the words "I'm (or we're) sorry"!

Annie


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

i agree with all that annie - except the bit about nobody being perfect. please change that to 'nobody is perfect except the blue rabbit' ta.


myLot reputation of 64/100. anniepa (9274)   ranked 380 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

THAT goes without saying...OF COURSE the blue rabbit is perfect...lol!
Annie


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

if it wasn't for that lol you would now be offically my favourite mylotter annie


myLot reputation of 78/100. xfahctor (5555)   ranked 63 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

All hail the all wise, all knowing all perfect cotton ball blue butt!


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

if it wasn't for fearing that you are not being that serious x you would have become number two in whereever here is/ you are number 4 in p.e. btw.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

do you know x that i am only [does quick check] about 2 lifetimes aways from giving this one up as a joke?


myLot reputation of 97/100. fruitcakeliz (885)   ranked 991 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

jb...do i need to be getting jealous about the fact that x is checking out your cottenball accentuated butt? LoL


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

no, but maybe you should get concerned about the fact that someone who claims to be a human male is so interested in rabbits and squirrels


myLot reputation of 46/100. iriscot (743)   ranked 572 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

My question jb is "where did you get those automatic guns" at a gun show or did you steal them from a collector? Hmmmm......

 
7. myLot reputation of 48/100. DiamondDogs (375)   ranked 1,355 out of 6,391 in politics   4 months ago

It was a very topical issue for a long time that our (Australian) government should make a formal apology to the aboriginal people for the way that they were treated in the past.
People were divided over whether the Austalian people should need to apologise for something that had nothing to do with them, and our former PM also refused catagorically to make an apology.
Seeing that we still celebrate national days from a bygone eras, and Australians had a sense that we should formally recognise the wrongs that were done in the past, the new government made that apology not long after being sworn into office.
It's pretty boring, but if anyone wants to see it, it can be seen on youtube by typing "Kevin Rudd says sorry".


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

it's a nice gesture. obviously everybody knows that the people alive today are not responsible for the events of the past but a symbolic apology is a decent thing for a government to do. incidently i've heard that the orginal australians are still getting a tough time - is this true?


LittleMrsSunshine (86)   ranked 1,354 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

I have also heard that there are still problems for the Aboriginal people, with schooling being a major issue, leaving Aboriginals without an education and therefore an inability to join in the modern society, if they so wish. The same was done in South Africa, with many whites blaming the blacks saying they were stupid etc when really it was the education system letting them down. It is good to say sorry for past mistakes, but only if we are not continuing those same mistakes into the future. History is there to teach us.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

but unfortunately has a nasty habit of repeating itself. btw was this your first ever comment here? nice one thumbup


myLot reputation of 85/100. grandpa_lash (1699)   ranked 182 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Good point, Diamond. If we still take credit for the exploits of Australian troops in now six wars, then we should also take the demerits for the bad things that previous Australians did, like the treatment of indigenous peoples.

Lash

 
8. myLot reputation of 96/100. vandana7 (1720)   ranked 75 out of 6,391 in politics   4 months ago

Hi jb78000 - u r a great one to admit that. I am from India, and I do feel we should not have participated in some foreign problems. That too when we had our own problems to handle at the time! Politicians play on wrong sentiments of people. Everytime there are elections round the corner, and the situation at home is not very encouraging, they start wars! I am inclined to be a very mind ur own business kind of person, so I definitely would not have endorsed the war with Pakistan for Independence of East Pakistan, now Bangladesh, or the help that Indian government offered to the Sri Lankan troups to defeat LTTE. I would never allow the issue to come up, and always mention that even if they are of Tamil origin, they belong to that country now, and v have nothing to do with them! After all, colored people in the United States must have come from Africa, but they dont know from which part of that continent! Is the acceptance of the country only when the country is flourishing? Ever since we participated in that war, Pakistani pride is hurting, and seeking some revenge to set the scores right. We've lost many, and so have they. I wish this would stop. I think they are as human as we are. In some ways I do identify with them. After all, they do talk the same language as we do. But for religious differences, we are not even a different race! Then why must we spend out time hating each other, when we should be addressing more serious issues within our countries. I wish past could remain in its place. What happened during partition is not first hand experience for our family, so why should we mistrust everybody! And it is not as if nothing similar happened here! Why must we carry the grudges of people who are no longer around, and waste our present with them? I do feel that way jb78000 but I will never be able to convince a single soul out here.:(


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

i agree with what you say about pakistan. hey - you said that there are religious differences but while the official religions are different aren't there indians from lots of different religions? including muslims

 
9. myLot reputation of 98/100. astonysh (1894)   ranked 523 out of 6,391 in politics   4 months ago

shockedI find myself in the extraordinary situation (a first-time ever - well maybe both of us despise Hitler) of agreeing with ParaTed2k on this.

The question is now do I put on my UK hat (I still have a British passport) and excuse those in the South-East of England whose great-great grandparents got rich on the slave trade. Coming from the working-class North of England probably not (why in Hades should Iangry apologise for those greedy money-grubbing snobs down South?) .... though on second thoughts I probably ought to as they were not responsible for those actions.

Similarly if I put on my German hat (with residence permit dutifully attached) or lederhosen (hang on, it is Oktoberfest fortnight, but Frankfurt is not in Bavaria!), do I look round and check out some extremely old guys .... Actually last year when I was in hospital, I shared a room with a guy who had served on the Eastern Front. He had nothing but contempt for Hitler, but refusing to fight meant certain incarceration, so he went.

As for the companies that owed money to the victims of the war - a lot of effort has been made to repay that. Admittedly the sums were probably insufficient, but how do you repay that sort of brutal exploitation? The current generation of Germans meanwhile are maybe the only people in Europe who will not vote in any numbers for the extremist Neo-Nazi parties, as they know where it leads. Attempts have been made to reconcile with the past, mainly successfully. thumbup


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

strange as it may seem i too agree with the ted sometimes. btw his name now is richard, rich tea biscuit if you are in a particularly heated discussion. great points anyway astonyish.


myLot reputation of 57/100. Maggiepie (1604)   ranked 1,795 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

Hmm. I'm English, Irish, Danish, Dutch, German, French, N. African, Russian Jew, 2 branches of Amerind, Welsh, Scottish...& American.

If I apologized to virtually any country but Australia & the ones in the far east, I'd be apologizing to myself.

Seems sort of a waste of time, to me...not to mention a tad silly.... doh

Maggiepie
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

goodness, how many grandparents do you have maggie? or are you able to go back a couple more generations than that?...

 
10. myLot reputation of 85/100. grandpa_lash (1699)   ranked 182 out of 6,391 in politics   4 months ago

The current Australian government apologised to our indigenous remnants for the damage done them by both colonial imperialism and for the later paternalistic attempts to deal with them, including the shameful episode known now as the lost generation, where indigenous children were forcibly removed from their parents and brought up in white homes to assimilate them. I agree with this apology, although I think the British should have been made to join in on the apology for imperialism. Even though the current generations had no part in the horrors imposed, it was our forebears who did it. More than an aoplogy, however, we should be looking at redressing what are still obvious inequalities and disadvantages.

Lash


myLot reputation of 48/100. DiamondDogs (375)   ranked 1,355 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Yes I think that in those days, we were still close to being a British colony.

...Where did you get that avatar? lol


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

yep. that was awful. also have heard of pretty nasty inequalities still there in the land down under however much people think it is a nice country. btw british imperialism is the main thing it has never apologised for but certainly should. so as i am a stand in for whatever twerp is the current prime minister here goes: 'sorry'


myLot reputation of 85/100. grandpa_lash (1699)   ranked 182 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Diamond, I don't rightly remember where it came from, except that it was from one of my BDSM submissives along the way. I've had on the hard drive for several years, this is the first time I've actually used it. Isn't it a pearler?

Lash


myLot reputation of 48/100. DiamondDogs (375)   ranked 1,355 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Good for you JB.
Foreign media reports of inequality in this country are ridiculous IMO.
Look, aboriginals are slightly genetically different to us and many aboriginals cannot adapt to modern western life. Let's face it, either can a lot of anglos.
Aboriginals are on average far more adept at some tasks that anglos could not handle. Unfortunately we live in a fast paced world that doesn't require their innate skills - atm anyway. But the worst thing would be to brush that knowledge under the carpet and risk losing it.
To exaggerate things a little bit, many people in Australia may get peeved that aboriginals are given access to free housing and then they smash down the dooors for firewood, or they might turn their backs on a free education which is not afforded to other citizens.
There are differences that need to be accepted, and strengths that need to be embraced. A poignant phrase from "Crocodile Dundee" was that their opinion about fighting over land is like two fleas fighting over who owns the dog that they live on.
And so, aboriginals might not find it important to pursue an education in order to live in a world that they innately don't believe in. I say good for them, but others may not.


myLot reputation of 48/100. DiamondDogs (375)   ranked 1,355 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Oh Lash, you've been a naughty boy lol

I don't quite know what to make of your avatar, but it conjures evil thoughts. It's a pearler alright lol, you gotta love it.

DD.


myLot reputation of 85/100. grandpa_lash (1699)   ranked 182 out of 6,391 in politics  4 months ago

Diamond, your last response re the aboriginals is a very anthropological approach. Most of white Australia, politicians particularly, simply don't seem to grasp that there is such an extreme difference in values and attitudes between the races and try to make it a one size fits all culture. It isn't.

Lash


myLot reputation of 48/100. DiamondDogs (375)   ranked 1,355 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

Yes Lash, I agree that it's not quite as simple as expecting that if a person is raised in a certain manner, then the result will be predictable.
IMO, the racism, sexism, etc. comes from those who won't accept people's differences.


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

[annoying rabbit. again] two points here really - silly wee erm s e x games - go for it. anything that is actually an excuse for the hard of thinking to pounce - get a sodding grip. how many times does it happeh here?


myLot reputation of 46/100. iriscot (743)   ranked 572 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

I'm amazed that no one has mentioned the fact that we in the USA started a war in Iraq for no other reason than for GB to get revenge for the death threats on his father.

I expect Ted and all of his right wing buddies to come out now with their guns blazing!


myLot reputation of 57/100. Maggiepie (1604)   ranked 1,795 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

Oh, Iris...put the Koolaid down. Thaaaat's better...now back awaaaay from the nasaty old drink--

And join the real world.

Yeesh.

Maggiepie
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"


myLot reputation of 83/100. jb78000 (1807)   ranked 193 out of 6,391 in politics  3 months ago

iris - we joined in. in spite of the fact that just about everybody in my country was against it. but thought it was about oil though?

 
sponsors
Top Online School Degrees
Earn Your Degree from a Top School Online! Study at Home or Anywhere.
CollegeDegreeNetwork.com/Schools

Anti-Virus Download
Free Virus, Adware, Spyware, Trojan and RootKit scan. Rated 5 Stars.
www.pctools.com

similar discussions
on what country you came from?
i have made a discussion intend for Filipino members asking what province in the Philippines they...
Big snow on Christmas Day
When I get up this morning I find all white outside. It is a big snow on Christmas Day. The...
what is special and unique about your country/island?????????????????
I am from Jamaica. Jamaica is special and unique because it is highlighted for tourism and...
You Couldn't PAY Me To Go To A Country Music Concert!!!
Well, I take that back...I guess you could...because I'm being paid $50 to go to one tomorrow......
Talles Building
I have been here several times. Nice place and beautiful scenery and harmony. Did anyone been here...
Country life
Sarah Davis lives in Dalton,Australia,there her parents have a sheep farm,Dalton is a small...
Country or City? Would You Want to Try Something Different??
If you live in the country, would you like to try living in the city for a while? On the other...
Which country do you wish to see
I love to travel, and by gods grace i got to travel to three countries last year, i really enjoyed...
Which country would you choose to work in?
If you could go to any country in the world on a two year work visa. You would get a high salary...
I Beleive That Garth Brooks Is The Best Solo Artist In Country Music Today!
Garth in one of those guys who changed country music. He is the main reason why I love country...
sponsors
Top Online School Degrees
Earn Your Degree from a Top School Online! Study at Home or Anywhere.
CollegeDegreeNetwork.com/Schools
Anti-Virus Download
Free Virus, Adware, Spyware, Trojan and RootKit scan. Rated 5 Stars.
www.pctools.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.