Marrying Again

@GreenMoo (11834)
May 23, 2012 10:38am CST
A friend of mine has just become engaged to be married. When he and his girlfriend go ahead he will become her FIFTH husband. What do you think of this serial marrying? It's not a case that her previous partners have died or anything. They are all divorces. I'm torn between thinking that she must be an eternal optimist and romantic, and thinking that after marrying once, even twice, she'd be a little more careful after. Do you know anyone who has married more than a couple of times?
7 people like this
33 responses
@nikki3 (172)
• United States
23 May 12
in my opinion to each his own. I know someone who has married 5 times. She thought that she was being carful and all 4 of those men were really mean to her. not going into detail of what happen but you get the picture. Now the 5th marriage it is the best for her. This guy treats this woman like she is made of gold. I am very happy for her and her husband. Now,What about those people that never marry and have tons and tons of boyfriends?
1 person likes this
@GreenMoo (11834)
23 May 12
Four husbands who are really mean sounds like a pattern. Glad for her sake that she's finally found happiness with number five.
1 person likes this
@GardenGerty (157551)
• United States
23 May 12
I have known of people who believe they make the same mistakes each time, so they quit rather than get married again. I guess it is smart to realize when you are making the same mistakes. It is also possible to make a different mistake each time because of being a perpetual optimist.
@Masihi (4413)
• Canada
23 May 12
Wow, that is too much, I mean usually it's celebrities that go around marrying and divorcing and remarrying and just treating marriage like a piece of paper or something. Seems like she is too idealistic and wanting the perfect husband and the perfect marriage but guess what...there's no such thing as a perfect husband or a perfect marriage. My own marriage was on the rocks at least 2 times but we're still married and very dedicated to keeping the marriage alive. Here's an American lady who's married 23 times and married the world's most married man - 29 times married, and she's on the lookout for Husband #24 - http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/howaboutthat/4796811/Grandmother-is-most-married-woman-after-tying-the-knot-23-times.html - heh - she even made it into the Guiness Book of World Records!! :-p
1 person likes this
@GreenMoo (11834)
23 May 12
That's just ridiculous. It thumbs it's nose at all that's special about marriage.
1 person likes this
@sharra1 (6340)
• Australia
27 May 12
It sounds like she is a serial monogamist. There again she could just be trying to find the right man and keeps falling for the wrong kind of man. I see nothing wrong with what she is doing. There are things you just have to learn from experience. You can only really know if a person is right for you by living with them and if she does not like that then she would marry them and when it did not work out divorce them. I have two nephews, one had a girlfriend who would not live with him outside of marriage and the other lived with his girlfriend for a few years. The first one dated his girl for about 5 years or more and then they married in a big wedding, they were divorced 2 years later. It seems that she found him too hard to live with or maybe she thought she would change him after marriage and found out she couldn't, I am not really sure as I have not spoken to either since it happened. The second one married his long time partner and they are very happily married. The thing is that no matter how well you think you know someone you don't. Living with someone is so different from just dating them. But I was once told that you never know a man until you live with him and that is true and it is also true of women. So if she is unable to just live with men she marries them and then finds out if they are ok or not. It is also possible that she rushes in too soon or that the men she is attracted to do not show their true colours until after they are married. Personally I think she is better off trying to live with them first and see if they are right for her. As to your question, yes, my partner has been married a few times and because of those experiences swore he would never marry again. We are not married but we have been together for longer than any of his marriages lasted and we are very happy.
@sharra1 (6340)
• Australia
28 May 12
I wonder that as well and yet we are brought up to believe that marriage is a goal we should achieve and living together is still regarded as a sin by many people. I know when my first nephew married his wife was treated differently to my other nephew's partner even though they were a happy couply. She told me how she felt that she was treated by the rest of the family as sort of a second class person because she had not married her partner. When she finally did marry him she was accepted as ok but she resented the attitude that not being married made her different and not quite right. That attitude is still in society and my family is not religious. I was quite shocked that they treated her like that. I know it was not a reaction from my brothers and she never told me if there was someone specific but it is a shame that such an attitude still exists. So it is possible that this woman is chasing the illusion of the happy married woman. I used to dream of getting married but it is just an illusion, just a piece of paper that does not change the relationship.
@sharra1 (6340)
• Australia
29 May 12
Well I know what my mother thought about me for just thinking of spending the night with a man I was not married to so those attitudes are not that far distant. It is simply not considered respectable to not be married, but it does not bother me and I see no difference. So it is not surprising that she prefers marriage to show that she is respectable. Legally it makes very little difference because if you live with someone for long enough they have a claim the same as a married person does. Still I think there are some things where it is easier for you if you are married. I am not at all concerned about people's attitudes and I would not associate with anyone who had a problem with it as they would not be my sort of people.
@GreenMoo (11834)
27 May 12
I suppose my own question is why she bothers with the marriage certificate after she's proven first hand how worthless it is.
1 person likes this
@dragon54u (31636)
• United States
23 May 12
I had a great grandmother that married 6 times but I never knew her. Most of my friends and acquaintances are one their second marriage and doing quite well. Or, like me, they elect to stay single. I think the key to a successful second marriage is taking time to find out why the first one failed. People all too often keep choosing the same type of person to marry and make no changes in themselves, discover nothing new about what motivates them and so they make the same mistakes again and again. They are doomed to fail because they haven't solved the underlying problem, choosing the wrong personality to "fall in love" with. It's actually a kind of dependency, I think. I hope your friend somehow changes his bride's losing streak and puts her in touch with whatever it is that makes her pick men who are wrong for her. I wish them happiness although the odds aren't on their side.
1 person likes this
@GreenMoo (11834)
23 May 12
I think you've summed up the way I feel about it. It seems rather like a pattern, and not a good one. They certainly seem happy at the moment though, so I do hope that continues for them.
1 person likes this
@NoWayRo (1061)
• Romania
23 May 12
If this is less traumatic for her than to be single, or stay in a relationship without being married, I'd say she's doing the right thing. I know a man who's been married 6 times - AND had a child with each of the wives. You'd think it's a messed up family - but it's not. The children are a very tight group (the oldest one is in a marriage that's already longer than any of his father's), the wives maintain a very decent social relationship, none seems to be scarred for life, at least from what I can tell from a distance. If the ex mothers in law get together, though, it's an absolute blast I also know people who have never recovered after one divorce, so it depends. But look on the bright side - you get to eat wedding cake 5 times
1 person likes this
@GreenMoo (11834)
23 May 12
Wedding cake has to be my absolute favourite thing, so perhaps I should update my views on tying the knot!
1 person likes this
@shansavy (171)
• Jamaica
23 May 12
that sounds a bit odd on her part i must say. i think honestly if you friend goes through with this then he will be divorce #5. more than likely it will not be his fault and he will just be hear broken over the whole thing
1 person likes this
@GreenMoo (11834)
23 May 12
I tend to think the same thing actually, but daren't say so.
@katsmeow1213 (28717)
• United States
23 May 12
I don't personally know anyone like this.. but seems to me with so many failed relationships, she is most likely the problem, not them. When my husband and I were first dating, his sister had just gotten married. She's all about trying to prove how she's so much better than anyone else. So that Christmas there was a big to-do about who was going to host Christmas dinner. She wanted it at her house so she could show off. Hubby's parents wanted it at their house for tradition. Unfortunately SIL was going to invite her husband's entire family, which I'd never met. At the time my oldest son was about 4 (no other kids yet) and he was very hyper. I didn't feel comfortable bringing him around people I didn't know. What if they didn't like that he was hyper and unmanageable? I felt more comfortable going to the in-laws because they were used to my son. So that started this big war between hubby and his sister because he told her we would not go to her house (because of me and my son as well as the fact that his parents didn't like the idea either). But he told her my reasons for not wanting to go.. and to that she said "We are married and you aren't, so that makes my husband more family to you than her and her son!". That was about 11 years ago. She's now on her second marriage and me and hubby are still together. Hmmm..
@GreenMoo (11834)
23 May 12
I wonder whether this lady has unrealistic expectations of marriage. Some people opt out when a bumpy patch comes along whilst others dig in and see what they can do about making things work. But they seem quite happy at the moment so fingers crossed marriage doesn´t change that for them.
@GreenMoo (11834)
24 May 12
Being comfortable is a different type of happiness. My partner has seen me at my worst, and my best, and vice versa. So we can relax and be ourselves. Right now, that 'rut' works better for me than the constant emotional rollercoaster of the early days.
• United States
23 May 12
I think comfortability changes the happiness. You get settled into a routine, which some may look at as a rut. I feel that way too in my own marriage. I don't feel swept off my feet anymore and sometimes I miss that. It's about seeing that the grass isn't greener on the other side of the fence. Everyone comes with flaws, problems, and baggage.
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
28 May 12
I think she is not contented to those men and or she has a nature that men doesn't like at all
@sharra1 (6340)
• Australia
29 May 12
Or she married them too quickly before she found out if she could live with them. I have known people make mistakes like that and they rarely stay married long.
@GreenMoo (11834)
28 May 12
Certainly something was not right.
1 person likes this
@much2say (53958)
• Los Angeles, California
24 May 12
I know quite a few women who are with their 3rd husbands. I guess they are happy now . . . and they say their current marriage has been the longest one. Maybe for some people it takes several tries to find Mr. Right? I personally can't relate . . . I've been with my hubby for many, many years (since before he was my hubby) - he is my first husband and I can't imagine divorcing him or ever marrying anyone else! That's just me.
@GreenMoo (11834)
25 May 12
Each to their own, and if it doesn't work out then I don't think there's anything wrong with trying again. But once someone is trying for the fifth time it makes me wonder what she's doing wrong ....
@GreenMoo (11834)
27 May 12
All grown up now, but I agree that it must have been tough in the past.
@much2say (53958)
• Los Angeles, California
25 May 12
Yah, 5 is a lot - 4 ex-hubbies!! Are there any kids involved? That makes it tough too!!
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
8 Jun 12
We've all seen these in movies or TV, but I've never known anybody who's married more than a couple of times. Although it says that he or she does not take marriage seriously (because he or she opts for divorce when it doesn't work), it does sound nice to think that he or she may be na eternal optimist. Someone who thinks that the right soul mate is still out there.
@GreenMoo (11834)
9 Jun 12
I've been swinging between these two thoughts ever since I found out! I hope it works for them, but the odds seemed stacked against it.
@ryanong (9665)
• Vietnam
24 May 12
There are many guys who has married more than 2 times, they was sad after getting divorced but they would be happy back so fast and continue dating again and then do married. Somehow it is good also because they can't stand living alone for a while, they need a marriage life even though they did fail with it many times before.
@GreenMoo (11834)
24 May 12
Learning from the mistakes of the past?
@ryanong (9665)
• Vietnam
25 May 12
In fact, we all do it also. You don't think so?
@luisaR (452)
• Philippines
24 May 12
I guess that's the privilege of having divorce legal in a country. when things aren't working anymore, just a piece of paper to sign on and it's done. Unlike here in my country, getting an annulment is harder and it takes awhile. 5th marriage? as long as there is a pre nuptial and she is accepted for what she has gone with, it's alright. The only difference is she's not a celebrity like we are used to read on news changing man over again.
@GreenMoo (11834)
24 May 12
Unrealistic expectations perhaps?
• Philippines
24 May 12
I don't believe that if a man or a woman has got married for several times, to mention,f ive (5) times has nothing to do with personality disorder... Because I believe that having problems during married life has no solution at all, and that the only remedy is have divorce and to marry another. I don't really believe this. But yeah in reality this really happened, in fact, divorce are now legalized for some other countries. But its so sad to think about the situation.. That's why before jumping into the decision of getting married, there should be proper getting to know each other which in reality is always the reason of having a divorce, due to misunderstanding and personal adjustments with each others.
@yiart65 (146)
• Singapore
26 May 12
Maybe she still haven met the guy whom she felt that she can spend a lifetime with? I mean, all these do not matter if the both of them are fine with it. As long as they are happy, I guess there isn't a problem at all.
@GreenMoo (11834)
27 May 12
A good point. If they're happy, it's not really anyone else's business. I don't envy the people who are about to buy her her fifth set of wedding presents though. Do you think she has a kitchen full of toasters?
@freqspaz (220)
• United States
25 May 12
Wow. Really five? Wow. I mean, I don't know what to really say to that. I am divorced myself because my ex was cheating on me and after a few years that we were married we didn't get along anymore, so we went our separate ways, but it wasn't a messy divorce. I have been with my current hubby for six years now, and we both joke that we're going to be the happy old couple that is in a home, I will know him as the nice man, and he will know me as the pretty lady. My aunt went through husbands for a while, like most people go through socks and she looks back on those times and says it was because she was hopelessly romantic and once the 'hunnymoon' was over then she honestly felt that she found any reason to get out because it wasn't as 'fun' as it was in the beginning, so she'd make up a reason or cause a fight or something to get out of it and start again. She is older now and has been married to her husband for 10 years, but her bit of advice to me was to, and I quote "Never do what I did, learn from me and if you feel happy and safe, work at it, don't be lazy." And I have. But really husbands aren't like shoes are cars or even dinnerware- they are not hobbies either and if she has had 5 of them in the past, I would be worried about her AND him. Be supportive though, if he is happy then be happy with him. If she drops him like day old news then really be there for him, just don't tell him "I told you so".
@GreenMoo (11834)
25 May 12
Your story of your aunt is a brilliant one. I love it. I'm a little worried about my friend. I'm sure he knows what he's getting into, and I wish them both happy times.
• United States
24 May 12
Some people have commitment issues. Your friend's intended bride sounds like she is one. I agree that it sounds like your friend is destined to be ex-husband #5. However, it sounds like he's pretty well blinded to her faults, and he will just have to learn things the hard way.
@GreenMoo (11834)
24 May 12
Discussing this has made me think about several other explanations, and one of those is that culturally she may feel she´s ´incomplete´ without a husband in tow. Interesting though. Anyway, their problem rather than mine. I just hope it works out for them both. I wouldn´t put money on it, but we´ll see!
@Lore2009 (7378)
• United States
24 May 12
Wow, fifth!? I am still recovering my 1st divorce.. I don't think I will be able to survive another! I've never really met anyone who's married more than twice actually but I see a lot on TV. Seriously, talk about optimism!
@GreenMoo (11834)
27 May 12
I guess if they parted amicably it would be easier to go ahead and do it again ... and again ... and again .... Seems a bit overdone though doesn't it? You'd think she's have worked out what she wanted by now.
@mjmarcha (11)
• Philippines
25 May 12
I know someone in our place and I think it we must be sure enough that our relationship with someone will last for lifetime. Keeping a relationship stronger is very hard but ending up in a failure is only a choice we have made.
@GreenMoo (11834)
25 May 12
Keeping together is the hardest part, but I think it's worth it if it's possible.
1 person likes this
@peferble (149)
• Bangladesh
24 May 12
My opinion is , its their own decision.
@GreenMoo (11834)
24 May 12
Of course it is, and I wouldn't dream of interfering. I'm interested in learning what motivates someone to marry and divorce so many times though.
• United States
24 May 12
i have been married before, but i do want to marry again. but i think if it doesnt work the second time, then either its me or i jus dont know what i am looking for. so i havent even thought of marrying again because the last time was during a time that i know i wasnt ready..and i only did it because she asked me..so the next time i decide to waste someones life..i want to make sure i am ready to do that. but when i give marriage one more time..it will be my last..so on my end..im going all in!
@GreenMoo (11834)
25 May 12
All in, or nothing. That's what marriage SHOULD be, as I see it.
1 person likes this
• United States
24 May 12
To me marriage is something that should only be done once if it works great if not then it wasnt ment to be, maybe a second time if u meet that right woman/man, but 3-5 times is a lil extreme... i have two cousind that have both been married three times, one is in his 3rd marriage and the other is divorced from his 3rd wife...i ask them y do they keep getting married to women u barely even know thinking that this marriage is gonna wrk...getting to know somone take time nothing that can be rushed...and jumping into a marriage just to say ur married is a lil crazy if u ask me but for someone to be nmarried 5time and divorced all five makes me beklieve she is trying to get something out of the situation or she is just the worse wife ever.. if ima waist all those yerars out of my like getting married and getting a divorce there has to be somethig in it for me because that doesnt look good on your resume when u are trying to find real love..
@GreenMoo (11834)
25 May 12
It doesn't seem a little like she's repeating a pattern over and over, doesn't it?