I think my son needs a brother

@dorannmwin (36392)
United States
February 6, 2013 11:27pm CST
In all actuality, I'm not going to be having another child. However over the weekend we had my friend's son come and spend the night with us because sissy was spending the weekend with her grandparents and Paul was bored. While we had D with us, Paul had a great time and it was a lot of fun to really get to see him interact with another little boy. You see, the issue for us is that he has his older sister and he also has three female cousins that are all younger than him. He doesn't have any males in the family that are close to the same age as him and I really think that this is something that is leading to a hole in his life (so to speak). Have you ever had a family member that was the only one of their generation of a gender? If you have seen this, do you think that there really is something that is missing in their lives? I certainly do and that is the reason that I will invite my friend's son to come spend the night with us regularly or I will allow Paul to have friends over for playdates more often than Kathryn does (in addition to her cousins, there are also a half dozen girls on our street that are the same age as she is, but no boys for Paul).
3 people like this
21 responses
@WakeUpKitty (8694)
• Netherlands
8 Feb 13
Isn't that happening in all families? My father only had a lot of brothers plus 1 sister. I grew up with sisters and 1 way younger brother. My son (9 years old) only has sisters (elder and younger). My uncle has sons and only 1 sister. My friend only has sons, she is the only female. I doubt my brother, my son, or the rest of the children I know did miss the brother/sister at all. Might be that a boy been raised by only females (incl. sisters) is more gentle, attentive, but I even doubt that. My son is still interested in male-activities, drawing, making robots, etc etc. He also loves cooking. I don't think he ever missed a brother (this besides of the fact you have to wait and see if the two brothers will come along as well which is not for sure either). There are plenty of boys/men in this world (plus plenty of girls) they can play with and do their "male" or "girly" activities with. There are also plenty of activities both genders can do, plus there is nothing wrong for girls to do things which are more of the interests of boys. BTW I am sure we do way more "male" activities over here (incl. technic) as female activities. BTW my son loves shopping which we all (except for my eldest daughter) hate.
1 person likes this
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
It is something that is happening in many families. I do think that is one of the reasons that it is good for our children to have friends that are not a part of our families so that they do have friends that they are able to play with.
@ShyBear88 (59306)
• Sterling, Virginia
7 Feb 13
I don't have and something missing in me. I never had any sister and didn't really have any girl cousin that I saw. I never missed it, I had friends that where girls that I felt as I was getting bigger where like sisters to me. Now I don't talk to them because we aren't on the same page and they never seem to want to talk to me any more so I have mostly just mom friends. My daughter is pretty much surround by boys as well and she doesn't seem to miss not having a girl around all of the time because I guess she has enough older females in her life.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
I do think that when there are older people of the same gender that play an important part in the child's life that it does help to fill that void. However even that is something that is somewhat missing in Paul's life as he only has one uncle on my side and his father that he gets to spend time with regularly.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
14 Feb 13
You know, I believe to a certain extent that I wouldn't have missed much if I didn't have my aunts and uncles. However, I don't think that I would have grown up to be the person that I am today if it wasn't for the fact that I did have both a younger brother and a younger sister.
@ShyBear88 (59306)
• Sterling, Virginia
14 Feb 13
Having the same gender weather older or younger you don't need a lot to fill something. You won't know but what you see. Your going to have to ask him if he feels lonely or if he is missing out of something because he has no brothers. I don't think having brother or a sister would really change someone that much or that they are really missing something. Many people that don't have aunts or uncles and they don't miss that. It just depends on that person and what that person needs. I was a tom boy so I never missed not having girls around I preferred being around boys then girls and I still do.
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
10 Feb 13
My youngest is six. And his older brother is 12. Althought there are lots of games or things to do that they could share, sometimes there are just some things that the younger one could not relate to. Or vice versa. That's why my six year old always asks for his cousing to stay over, or sleep over. Sometimes he goes over there too. Their cousin is 10. And although there is still a 4 year gap, they seem to like the same games. Which the older brother seem to think too childish.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
Even with a four year difference in age, there are times that the things that the older child enjoys are things that the younger child are not able to relate with. This is something I see in our family as my daughter is almost four years older than her little brother.
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
7 Feb 13
I have four sons. My SIL has fraternal twins- a boy and a girl. So this little girl literally has no playmate. Most often, she would be just bullying the boys! But other times, she would just ask my youngest son who is of the same age as her to play with her. They are practically best friends. But I can see that she has grown up to be not so girly as what we expect our daughters to be. Plus the fact that her mother is not conscious in making her daughter act like a girl. She likes wearing rubber shoes without any socks, which I hate seeing in girls. She doesn't comb her hair that much, plus the finesse is lacking. So, I think that, you should find a playmate for your son so that he'd know how to be with boys like him. Trust me. It would be better for your kid to be around kids like him.
@sishy7 (27169)
• Australia
7 Feb 13
Another thing we have in common, I also have four sons... My mom said some years ago if she'd ever have a grand daughter. Well, it does not seem likely now as my sister also has only sons. Hers and mine are close in ages and although they live overseas, they are always the closest of cousins whenever they see each other. They don't really think about having a sister; in fact, they'd feel sorry if there is a sister because she'd not have anyone to be closed with.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
I do consider Paul to be quite lucky that he does have D as a friend and also that he has his friend Sammy that lives around the corner that he gets to play with on a pretty regular basis. However, when it comes to family gatherings he is definitely outnumbered with first and third cousins. We have to go all the way to fourth cousins before there is a boy similar in age to him.
• Dhaka, Bangladesh
9 Feb 13
Thank you Doran for sharing your ideas. Yes, your son really needs a brother. You can plan accordingly. Have a very nice weekend.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
Adoption is something that I've considered for our family, but that is something that will have to wait for a little bit because we are not in a financial situation right now to make that possible.
1 person likes this
• Dhaka, Bangladesh
26 Feb 13
Have a very wonderful day.
@averygirl72 (37854)
• Philippines
8 Feb 13
I had a young boy cousin who is the only child and he treats us like her siblings. Her mother has a friend who is almost his age I guess and they play basketball during weekends. Good thing is there are plenty of young boys in the neighborhood enough to make his own basketball team that meets with him on weekends. That is good that you think of his welfare, make plans and make effort and sees what really is lacking in his life.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
My life really does revolve around my children and I believe that is the main reason that I can see those things that seem to be lacking in their lives.
@dawnald (85135)
• Shingle Springs, California
7 Feb 13
Cary does have male cousin who's the same age, but when he comes over, he plays more with Cary's sisters...
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
That's funny that his male cousin spends more time playing with the girls than he spends playing with his male cousin.
@silverfox09 (4708)
• United States
8 Feb 13
My little brother was always asking for a brother , my mother was even thinking about adopting a brother for him, he never got one though . I also wanted a sister to grow up with and play with never got that either . When your son get older he will get over it. I now appreciate the fact my mother never had a daughter lol , I have a loving little brother even though he annoy me . My brother have male friends at school , he is now ok and he stop asking for a brother . My mother also invite his male friends over are allow him to visit them .
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
You sound a lot like my daughter in this one in saying that you love having a brother even though he does annoy her. I really do know that Paul is going to be okay, but I also think that getting older is definitely something that is helping him.
• United States
7 Feb 13
It's good that your son is surrounded by females. Hopefully, this translates into him growing up knowing how to treat females well. If you ever really want to add another child to your family, there are a lot of children out there who need good homes.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
You know, fostering or adopting is something that I've considered doing. After I had my friend's children this past summer, I really did realize that I have a lot of love in my heart that isn't already given.
@much2say (54010)
• Los Angeles, California
7 Feb 13
When I read your header . . . I was thinking oh wow, she's thinking about #3!! Paul's "situation" reminds me of my daughter's friend, J. J is 8 years old and he is an only child (and the only "young" grandchild). His parents tell us all that they definitely do not want another child no matter what anyone says. Besides mom, J also has his grandma living with him. J also has 2 teenage half sisters - and though they do not live in the same house, they are always at their house afterschool. And then there is a school friend who lives a block away from them . . . and she is taken to J's house in the morning and afternoon as her parents work. So there are a lot of "stable" female figures around in his daily life. Aunties and the other grandma often visit from the Philippines. Though the parents don't run a daycare by any means, one would swear their house was one. The mom told me she and hubby grew up with tons of cousins and friends in their house in the Philippines, so it was important for them to have "that" for their son. But there are no cousins around . . . and his half sisters are of course older. So they make sure he has plenty of playdates with kids from school (both boys and girls) - and they welcome anyone who wants to come play. The father has expressed concerns because he was the only "boy" (we had this conversation actually not too long ago). I remember a long while ago he kept saying he thinks his son is sort of a wuss because he had all these females around him, especially with grandma's influence most of the day. (I don't think the term "wuss" is nice to say about your own son, but that is what he said). But somewhat recently the conversation was about he believes his son has overcome having all these women/girls around him. Jokingly, he says if his son starts doing gross things, or gets too wild - he gives him a thumbs up on it! . In our own personal case, we have plenty of friends around for both my daughter and son. But, they do not have any cousins their age on either side of the family (hubby's side the kids are all adult/late teen and we never see them - and on my side there are no other kids). So family get togethers and such means there are no social peers for my kids. I grew up with tons of cousins and I feel like my kids are missing out on "cousin" relationships.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
I would definitely never say that my son was a wuss because of the fact that he does really like to play sports and things like that. He is already anxiously awaiting the baseball season to start and I know that baseball is always really good for him. When it does come down to it, I definitely have to say that Paul is really quite an athlete.
• Valdosta, Georgia
7 Feb 13
My son is the only boy but at least with him he has his cousin who is a year younger than him to play with. But soon they will be moving 3 hours away and so my son will be all alone and the only boy. =( That is another reason I like doing my Childcare business because it gives my son some boys to play with! =-) Like each weekend I have been watching these 2 boys who are 4 & 5 years old and my son is 5 so it works out really good! I am going to feel bad once his cousin moves but at least he will have some friends to play with every weekend when I watch the boys!
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
You are right about the childcare. In fact, I think that the playmates that children get when their parents are providing childcare is really one of the main reasons that parents choose to be childcare providers. My mother was always babysitting a lot of the kids from our neighborhood when we were growing up.
@maurya83 (923)
• India
7 Feb 13
Hello Dorannmwin, My elder brother is the only son of my parents with 4 sisters but we never felt it like a big issue for him even he did not said anything regarding this.. In fact i never thought like this before reading your post. I dont feel this made any kind of hole in his life, he is very responsible, always happy and has a very big friend circle..may be you feel like this because your son is very young, this will not a big problem for him as he will grow further, he will develop his own personality and make more and more friends of same gender..you know in my childhood i also didn't had more friends of same gender, all the kids of my age group in my neighborhood were boys with whom i used to play but i didn't ever felt that it affected my life in any means as when i grew up i made lot of good friends of same gender..
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
I do think that it has to do with the fact that he is a younger child. However as he is starting to show his more masculine characteristics, I am seeing that it isn't as easy for him to interact with his sister and his cousins.
@911Ricki (13588)
• Canada
7 Feb 13
I think he does need that interqaction, my younger brother was like this, and we see how he turned out. He was always around older girls, he is so prim and proper on his look, more OCD has 6 - 8 showers a day. Very poor attitude, and not capable of handling life situations. He was never around kids his own age, or boys for that matter. So now at 18, he isn't at the same level at kids his own age, he doesn't have any friends, and simple shows in his personality. Have you thought about activities? I know they may cost a lot, but there are some offered by the school, or other programs, I remember going to them. I think it would help him play with other kids his own age, including boys. But it also will help him later in life, it will show him responsibility, being mature, and handle stress, and time management. I always use Scouts as a key example, it's all boys, and gives them different situations, such as mettings, achievements, playtime even camping.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
Right now we are getting ready to start baseball again and Paul is definitely ready for that. Then he is also looking forward to next year when he is in first grade and he will be able to join Boy Scouts. I do like extracurricular activities for my children, but I also try to limit those because of the fact that there are a limited number of hours in the day.
7 Feb 13
I guess it must be a wonderful feeling to have a sibling, u can fight with them, play, share ur thoughts n secrets. I never had that joy and I still miss it. My parents only wanted one child. I always felt that void that nobody can fill, not even my cousins. Having a sibling makes u look at things in a different light, it makes u more caring, responsible and protective. Its provides u with a "whole" feeling of being safe and loved for that nothing can compensate. I really supoort ur thought. Ur son should definitely have a brother. :D :)
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
I cannot begin to imagine what it would be like to go through life without having a sibling at all. I was the oldest of three children and I was an only child for the first two and a half years of my life. However when my little brother was born, I felt a lot happier because I wasn't alone to go through life.
@katsmeow1213 (28717)
• United States
7 Feb 13
Yeah my daughter has that problem. They don't have any cousins at all.. but she has 4 brothers. She also doesn't seem to have as many friends as the boys do. My boys go out with their friends all the time. She has only just recently been interested in having sleepovers.. and up until now she hasn't been able to participate in many because of my working on weekends. She is quite obvious with her dismay of having all brothers.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
I can easily see how unhappy that your daughter is with having all brothers. It is good, however, that she is finally getting to the point that she wants to have sleepovers and more time to play with female friends.
@bunnybon7 (50973)
• Holiday, Florida
7 Feb 13
good idea. i was an only child and loved spending a few days when out of school with my girl cousins that lived quite a few miles away. i always hated to leave. so i know how lonely he must feel with just girls all the time.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
I can definitely tell that he gets quite lonely from time to time. It also doesn't help too much that his sister is very bossy and will force him to always play girly games with her.
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
7 Feb 13
I kind of understand what you sare saying. I was one of three girls and our cousins were girls except one and we liked to play with him. He was gay but none us knew that at the time. We just liked the fact that enjoyed playing dolls with us. Am I being politically incorrect? I do not mean to say that all gays like to play dollies. But he just wasn't into whay was considered biy thingies. I may be losing the plot here as ourt problem was that we did not know how to interact with boys and this caused great problems later in life as we went to all girls' schools. Your son is obviously happy playing with another boy so yes - invite him often so that Paul is not always surrounded by girls. Nothing but good can come of it.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
Well, Paul will play Barbies or Littlest Pet Shop with his sister or his cousins, but those really aren't the games that he prefers. I do try to let him play with the neighbor boy as often as possible and I also try to make sure that he gets to play with my friend's son at least once a month. You see, we would do that more often, but D lives with his mother and gets to visit with his father every other weekend.
• Philippines
7 Feb 13
My son has a lot of cousins near his age so I guess there's no problem with him. He can socialize with them. Though we've never let him sleep over yet with his cousins or vice versa. I hope your son will have more playmates in the future.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
Paul is in kindergarten now and that does seem to be something that is making a difference for him. However, at this age I really don't know any of the parents of his classmates so he really hasn't had the opportunity to play with those friends outside of school.
@iluvusabado (2560)
• Philippines
7 Feb 13
i have two male cousins who grew with me. i remember we were of the same batch in school. my nephew has three male cousins of almost the same age so he has some playmates. i don't really see anything missing with their lives. anyway, he can still play with other kids. though it would be better if he have some male figure in the family whether the same age as him or different.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
I do think that it is always important for our children to have some kind of playmates in their lives. For Paul, he has always been around girls and now that he is getting a little bit older, it just seems to me that he needs to have more boys in his life.
• Philippines
7 Feb 13
Why not try to have one but I don't but I think a very slim chance for it to prosper for it is not a matter of choice. I knew families who want a male on the family but never have ONE as a result they got ten female. I don't heard any scientific study for a husband and wife to select what to raise a boy or a girl it all depends on come what may.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
13 Feb 13
Oh, I'm done with having children. I consider myself to be very lucky that I was able to have the son and the daughter that I have. However, I've also been through two miscarriages and I don't really believe that would be something that I would be able to tolerate going through again in my life.