sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Socialism Explained  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8074)   ranked 53 out of 3,986 in politics 3 years ago

An economics professor at Texas Tech said he had never failed a single student before but had, once, failed an entire class. That class had insisted that socialism worked and that no one would be poor and no one would be rich, a great equalizer.

The professor then said OK, we will have an experiment in this class on socialism. All grades would be averaged and everyone would receive the same grade, so no one would fail and no one would receive an A.

After the first test the grades were averaged and everyone got a B. The students who studied hard were upset and the students who studied little were happy.

But, as the second test rolled around, the students who studied little had studied even less, and the ones who studied hard decided they wanted a free ride too; so they studied little. The second test average was a D! No one was happy.

When the 3rd test rolled around the average was an F. The scores never increased as bickering, blame, name calling all resulted in hard feelings and no one would study for the benefit of anyone else. All failed, to their great surprise, and the professor told them that socialism would also ultimately fail, because when the reward is great, the effort to succeed is great; but when government takes all the reward away; no one will try or want to succeed (or produce).

It couldn't be any simpler than that...

What about you? Do you think this description fits?

 

politics
sponsors
eBay ® - Official Site
Get great deals on eBay. Buy It Now or Win It!
www.eBay.com

Is Socialism Liberalism?
Learn how Socialism Destroys Democracy
AmericasCulturalStudies.com

Voltairine de Cleyre
The American Anarchist and Feminist - information, essays and quotes
OnlinePhilosophyClub.com

matersfish (2667) response was accepted on 4/25/2009.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  socialism, big brother, big government, communism, email forward
 
1. myLot reputation of 92/100. anotherxidentity (1054)   ranked 285 out of 3,986 in politics   3 years ago

The thing with Socialism is that the idea of it works but because of human nature Socialism is not going to work and never will be. There is some part in a human's mind that is greedy - and some people just tend to have that quality more in them than others. So therefore its those people who are going to be the ones, like above aren't studying which is just going to start a spirlling effect downward.

So if the world was perfect - socialism would be what would be nice, but in reality I think competition is also healthy. If there isn't competition in this world nobody would want to work harder, be the best, etc. so I don't think we should have socialism.

eBay ® - Official Site Get great deals on eBay. Buy It Now or Win It!  www.eBay.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 83/100. lilwonders456 (3526)   ranked 34 out of 3,986 in politics   3 years ago

This is a wonderful example on why socialism does not work.

Is Socialism Liberalism? Learn how Socialism Destroys Democracy  AmericasCulturalStudies.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 80/100. missybal (3820)   ranked 473 out of 3,986 in politics   3 years ago

Boy that's one way to prove a point. I hope that it was every student in the class who actually insisted that Socialism worked because if I was in that class as one who seriously disagreed, and I worked my butt off to get a good grade a still failed I would be ticked off. I hope they learned the lesson. And I hope the teacher still took their grades and graded them as individuals for what I hope would be at least two or three who really did try. Thanks for sharing this.

Voltairine de Cleyre The American Anarchist and Feminist - information, essays and quotes  OnlinePhilosophyClub.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 97/100. Pose123 (8272)   ranked 110 out of 3,986 in politics   3 years ago

Hi flowerchilde, All socialists don't think alike but I agree true socialism alone can't work, especially as we think in today's society. I also believe that we must have some Socialism because Capitalism in it's purest form can't work either. Blessings.


myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8074)   ranked 53 out of 3,986 in politics  3 years ago

I don't think anything gone extreme can ever work, and capitalism has gone extreme.. whereas Free Enterprise and little government was pure and a great thing.. and is what made the U.S. great.. The Book of Revelation (Apocalypse) says socialism (extreme) will (finally) devour capitalism (which too went extreme and is called a harlot or described with a greek word porneo, and the verses also say it is God's will that she crash for she corrupted the world with her enchantments.. yet perhaps the calamity can be delayed..?)
cool

Free History Magazine Get the world's biggest events. Get a free History Channel® Magazine.  Thehistorychannelclub.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 99/100. ElicBxn (24693)   3 years ago

fits to a "t"

fact is, that if every one did a job they loved - so that shoe makers loved to make shoes and made them for the love of making them, and garbage men picked up garbage for the love of it, etc, then socialism would work, but how many garbage men are doing it for the love of their job, or sewage workers, or street sweepers...

heck, how many health care people are wiping old people's butts, or day care workers wiping babies butts are there?

gifts for brother Affordable Personalized Gifts. Premiuim Quality. Ships In 24 Hrs.  www.zazzle.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 62/100. gewcew23 (5064)   ranked 414 out of 3,986 in politics   3 years ago

AWESOME, that explain socialism in a nutshell. Socialism rewards failure punishes success, so under socialism why would anyone want to be better than anyone else.


myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8074)   ranked 53 out of 3,986 in politics  3 years ago

Amen! People don't realize that production grinds to a halt.. like happened in the USSR for example..

The Future of TV Watch 3500+ channels today. Digital TV on PC. Click Here to Learn More!  www.StopPayingCableBills.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 97/100. dragon54u (15689)   ranked 28 out of 3,986 in politics   3 years ago

I think that that story should be published in every newspaper and magazine in the world. Here in the United States nobody seems to realize or care that we are falling into socialism and, inevitably, into fascism. When the next three years have passed we will find ourselves as slaves unless we do something quickly.


myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8074)   ranked 53 out of 3,986 in politics  3 years ago

My only hope is the primaries in 2010.. I don't even put much stock in calling or writing to our senators or congressmen anymore.. I think we get what we vote for, period.. and if we don't know what we're voting for, if public sentiment and media (one and the same?) are what we're going on, yikes, disaster. And I'm afraid that's right where we are. If we (the nation collectively, that is) can shake ourselves awake enough to see the pending disaster(s) and at least get more of a balance in the houses of congress, perhaps rationalization will have yet one last hurrah..

gifts brother Find gifts brother Online. Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!  Target.com/FreeShipping
 
8. myLot reputation of 96/100. tigerdragon (3165)   3 years ago

it was very well portrayed and explained. i like the way he showed what and how socialism works. he made them realized it on their own what it is. It is so ironic that for the longest time we have fought against communism and socialism but haven't we learned from that? i do not have anything against the idealism but what bothers me about socialism is the reality of it all, taking into consideration the human element. it would work if we are all mechanised, but we are not. during the late sixties and the early seventies, the world is fighting against communism and socialism and yet we see "hippies" congregate in communes.today, we are fighting against terrorism and poverty and yet the ones in power are the ones financially terrorizing the world and, under the rug, slowly inducing economic socialism. I saw this coming when the super powers were gearing towards a universal global system in which all nation is directly connected economically. now, look what happened! if one is one trouble, everyone is affected.

5 Foods to Never Eat Cut down a bit of stomach fat every day by never eating these 5 foods.  The6packAbsSecret.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 99/100. hotsummer (3660)   ranked 746 out of 3,986 in politics   3 years ago

that is quite a good example of what socialism is. i don't believe ni socialism as an answer to the world's poverty or any problem facing a country. i believe that we could not take away what one worked hard for and give it to others who has less in life by forced. cause that would be unfair and that will be injustice. and i believe it may create some kind of complacency in people cause they will not give their right due in the hard work that they do cause they will remain the state of life no matter how hard they work in life. that will never work to make a nation succeed in life. no one will want to work hard for other's benefits. it is like giving free lunch to others from our own pocket. every person should strive to make their life better and not expect others to bring them to a better state of life. cause socialism will create passive attitude among the people.


myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8074)   ranked 53 out of 3,986 in politics  3 years ago

You know, I think that's very true.. that socialism creates a passive attitude among the people.. Instead of seriously thinking over issues, it seems to me like the attitude would be more of what can I get from the government.. but even then, all in all, the getting can be very short lived... and has been in all past experiments with it.

Gifts Brother See All Gifts Brother Great Deals On Great Brands.  www.Gifts.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 96/100. Lakota12 (23205)   ranked 121 out of 3,986 in politics   3 years ago

It sure does!

The Elite Idolaters A book about the Michigan FOIA and the Child Protection Law.  www.davidebloch.com
 
sponsors
Free History Magazine
Get the world's biggest events. Get a free History Channel® Magazine.
Thehistorychannelclub.com

gifts for brother
Affordable Personalized Gifts. Premiuim Quality. Ships In 24 Hrs.
www.zazzle.com

The Future of TV
Watch 3500+ channels today. Digital TV on PC. Click Here to Learn More!
www.StopPayingCableBills.com

similar discussions
The results of Obama's new amnesty for illegal immigrants.
Could he have chosen a better "poster child" for his new amnesty policy that shows his utter...
Do you have the benefit of MUTUAL companies in your country?
Here in UK there are a number of Mutual companies, these are companies which instead of paying...
Where is the British Justice?
In my prior post on British losing their spines, becoming injust Jellyfish, I was appalled by how...
Things that make you go hhmmmmm......
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=14C-H3W03VI&feature=related I thought this was cute... tell me...
Socialism vs Capitalism
Business exist to make money. Socialism is a way for lazy people to get something for nothing....
Politics and socialism
I'm a socialist, and i know that there are lots of people in america who dislikes socialism, but i...
Why Solcialism doesn't work?
I feel with all this talk of Socialism and Capitalism I think an expert of sorts should be used...
Anyone here from a socialist country?
What is it like? What is your constituion like? Your employment? Your entertainment? Your...
The Other Parties.
I decided to place this information here just for some fun and what I think will be a pretty cool...
Socialism the way to go??
I've often thought....wouldn't socialism be better than the current capitalist way of doing...
sponsors
Free History Magazine
Get the world's biggest events. Get a free History Channel® Magazine.
Thehistorychannelclub.com
gifts for brother
Affordable Personalized Gifts. Premiuim Quality. Ships In 24 Hrs.
www.zazzle.com
The Future of TV
Watch 3500+ channels today. Digital TV on PC. Click Here to Learn More!
www.StopPayingCableBills.com
gifts brother
Find gifts brother Online. Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!
Target.com/FreeShipping
5 Foods to Never Eat
Cut down a bit of stomach fat every day by never eating these 5 foods.
The6packAbsSecret.com
Gifts Brother
See All Gifts Brother Great Deals On Great Brands.
www.Gifts.com
The Elite Idolaters
A book about the Michigan FOIA and the Child Protection Law.
www.davidebloch.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.