A better place? Do you say this?
By Marie Coyle
@MarieCoyle (43639)
October 2, 2023 4:12pm CST
Imagine this scenario~
Your child dies by his/her own hand.
Someone you love dies in a horrific accident
Someone you love dies from a long, drawn out, very painful death
Someone you love dies. They just die, and you have to convince yourself to go on.
This happens every single day, to many of us, all over the world.
Then, when you want to retreat, reflect, think, and mourn, you are usually faced with a funeral, a lot of people you don't really know, and the people who are grieving for your loved one just as much as you are.
So, why does this saying bother me so much?
''He's in a better place.''
When you are in fresh, deep grief, whether or not you are a Christian or whatever your beliefs are, this isn't something that offers any comfort whatsoever. You feel the ''better place'' is with YOU. YOU want them back. You are grieving, and you don't want to hear that at ALL.
Whether it's your child, a family member, a friend...you don't want to hear that.
I recently attended a memorial service for a young man who died by suicide. He came home on an unannounced leave from army service to surprise his young wife. He found his wife with another man...he left and that was it. He left parents, and siblings, friends, endless relatives...I had observed a lady talking to his mother before the service. She evidently just had to say that tired saying, ''he's in a better place'' and the mother just ran out the door. The memorial service was delayed for an hour, and that particular lady retreated.
Is that one of your sayings, or someone you know says that when someone dies? I know one lady that does this. I avoid her whenever possible....I understand the person is referring to heaven as the destination. Not everyone believes in heaven, or isn't sure--the entire world is different on this.
It honestly sounds like the person is promoting death when this is said under certain circumstances--a suicide, a death due to horrific violence, shooting, harsh disease, abuse...
To me, there is no better place for my loved one(s) to be than close by me. If we all were so eager to get to the better place, why do we fight to stay alive, or even defend our country? We do those things because we think life is worth it. We want to be here, with our people.
I won't ever hate someone who says it or hold it against them for it. I just think it could be said in a different way. If it's a child or a young person, don't say ''be thankful that you have other children'' or ''you can have another child''...one person cannot take the place of another. Not ever, it's just not possible. Say you're sorry. Say something nice about the person, to the grieving people.
I have discovered that most people truly do not like ''better place'' condolences.
16 people like this
11 responses
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
2 Oct 23
I am very sorry you had to hear that phrase. It does not soothe the soul, or help the pain.
1 person likes this
@sallypup (64196)
• Centralia, Washington
3 Oct 23
Just make sure the person knows you are there to listen, even silently. Say you're sorry and give the person space. I also am not delighted with folks who don't understand my grieving over the loss of a fur person. Sorrow is a shocker and deeply personal.
2 people like this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
3 Oct 23
Our pets are family. We grieve for them, it's normal, and people who don't understand that, I don't understand them. They are part of our daily lives, and bring us much love and joy.
1 person likes this

@LadyDuck (473929)
• Switzerland
3 Oct 23
@MarieCoyle You are so right, all what we want is to have them back. It is insulting to hear "he/she is in a better place". It is not true, the better place was within the family, with all those who loved him/her.
1 person likes this
@LadyDuck (473929)
• Switzerland
4 Oct 23
@MarieCoyle - I wonder if they ever lost a loved one, how can they be so insensible?
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
3 Oct 23
I would never use it, either. None of us truly knows just what the person mourning believes, or the deceased, either. It's' not our business. That better place comment is insulting--we all want them back, as you said, Anna. We think to be with us IS the better place.
1 person likes this


@JudyEv (352852)
• Rockingham, Australia
4 Oct 23
@MarieCoyle I think so too and just being there quietly is sometimes enough.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
3 Oct 23
Sometimes a person needs to keep quiet,be supportive, and say very little. A simple ''I'm sorry'' goes a long way in my book.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
4 Oct 23
@JudyEv
It truly is. Often that is what is needed the most.
1 person likes this
@Deepizzaguy (109452)
• Lake Charles, Louisiana
2 Oct 23
The loss of a loved one is very painful for me to deal with. I like to say "I will see you again in the afterlife.'
1 person likes this

@Deepizzaguy (109452)
• Lake Charles, Louisiana
3 Oct 23
@MarieCoyle I am in agreement with you that sorry for your loss is enough.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
3 Oct 23
I don’t even say that much, because I sometimes do not know the person’s beliefs. I just say I am very sorry.
1 person likes this


@porwest (99664)
• United States
14 Oct 23
@MarieCoyle I agree. It's like what I do when I read a post about a bad situation calling for prayer. Rather than assert I am an atheist and offer nothing, I simply say, "I will keep you in my thoughts." It says enough without saying too much and keeps things less insensitive. IMO.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
14 Oct 23
@porwest
Most definitely it is better to say a bit less and not hurt any feelings with the thoughtless trite and insensitive “better place “ saying.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
13 Oct 23
Different people believe and worship differently, and I feel it rather rude to just assume that the ones who are deep in grief can be helped by such a statement. It may be the person saying it meant well. but it does nothing to ease the pain of loss of a loved one. Better to just say, I'm sorry, and move on from there.
1 person likes this

@much2say (57521)
• Los Angeles, California
3 Oct 23
It is rather insensitive, no matter how well intended that phrase is. That is one that I don't care to use. I guess I've always taken "a better place" to mean that the person was no longer in pain nor suffering . . . but it could be a religious reference too - you're right - not all believe in that.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
4 Oct 23
Yes, I can definitely see the double meaning there. I always took it as a reference as the deceased was now in heaven--and we don't always know the deceased ones beliefs on that. It's just best not said, out of respect for the family, I think.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
3 Oct 23
That's the best way, the person knows you care, and that's the most important thing.
1 person likes this
@DaddyEvil (147589)
• United States
2 Oct 23
No, I don't say that and would resent anyone telling me that. A simple "I'm sorry." is much better to my way of thinking.
1 person likes this

@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
2 Oct 23
I agree. It's not what anyone wants to hear at that time, and maybe never.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
2 Oct 23
I am glad I am not the only one. Every time I hear it, I want to get mouthy or tell the person to go away.
1 person likes this
@wolfgirl569 (115719)
• Marion, Ohio
3 Oct 23
@MarieCoyle I think some people don't want to say they are sorry. It can feel like an empty platitude also
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
3 Oct 23
@wolfgirl569
Maybe so. I know there are people who have trouble with ''I'm sorry'' but in this case, it would have been way more appropriate.
1 person likes this
@1creekgirl (43498)
• United States
2 Oct 23
Thank you for such a caring and insightful post, Marie. People mean well usually, but they don't truly understand.
1 person likes this
@MarieCoyle (43639)
•
2 Oct 23
I've never liked it when someone said that, but this last time, that was it for me. Like you said, maybe they mean well, but not putting much thought into their words and the hurt they cause. Thank you, Vicki.
1 person likes this
