That's not right!!

United States
October 7, 2009 6:42am CST
Monday morning I woke up and saw I had a $450 child support payment, which was direct deposited into my bank account! That's pretty exciting considering I only get $50 a month, and he hardly ever pays that. The $450 I got on Monday was back pay, it caught him up. So, I decided to go on the website and look at the account, and I see that the payment he made was actually $500. The child support office kept about $50! What's up with that? So I sent them an e-mail and the next day get a reply. Because he only owed the $450 that's all they can give me. They'll hold the other $50 until his next scheduled payment. But if from now on he pays on time (ha ha, yeah right) then I'll never see that $50. Now I'm thinking that's not right!! He chose to pay $500, so why can't my child have that money? What if he wanted to pay extra at the holidays, I wouldn't get the money unless he were already behind! I don't think that's fair! If he over pays his child support I should be entitled to every dime!! Yet another flawed system! Do you have any child support stories you'd like to share?
4 people like this
12 responses
• United States
7 Oct 09
I dont see what the problem is they are holding onto the money to ensure that your child will get something the next scheduled due date its not like they are stealing your money you will see that $50 at some point my husband and I have the opposite problem he pays his support on time every month he pays $600 every month thats $600 that OUR 5 kids dont get to utilize we pay over $9000 a year to a child we never get to see we pay out the butt for a child we cant even claim on our taxes meanwhile the child's mother gets foodstamps because she is too lazy to work MY kids cant even get reduced lunches at school because he makes too much money before they take out taxes and they dont factor in the money spend in child support everytime we have a question about what we pay the child support office treats him like crap because he is the man you want to talk about a flawed system? lets talk about how the system treats people who actually PAY their support lets talk about how other kids suffer because their dad choosesa to pay his support on a sibling that they will never get to know because her mother has fed her all kinds of lies and turned her against her father even though his faithful support payments have put food on her table and clothes on her back for over 10 years
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
7 Oct 09
This really gets to me. I think that the original poster will eventually see that $50 and probably soon because someone who is always late on child support or who tries to go underground, get laid off, or fired to avoid paying once will do it again. It's too bad they don't extract an additional $200 from him to hold just in case he decides not to pay her for 4 months! I believe if you're paying support that you should be able to see the child - now if you DON'T pay support or if it has been determined that you can only have supervised visitation, I'm sure that would be different. When kids are young, they are supposed to be able to see both parents, and regularly - if there is no concern that one parent is unfit. When they get older, only then do they really get to say 'hey, I don't really want to visit' blah blah blah. I know about the reduced lunch thing because although something like 80% of the kids in this district qualify, we don't. My son is constantly complaining that I forget to put lunch money on his account, well, the fees went up once again and I keep telling him to make a sandwich lol. Children are not free to raise, and while I believe the whole parenting and caring for and all that physical and emotional stuff is a lot TOUGHER than the financial aspect, there IS a financial aspect and it is so weird that so many people think you can raise a kid on $50 a month lol. Impossible.
• United States
7 Oct 09
My son's father doesn't want to see my son. He doesn't call, or send cards, nothing. He tried to convince me to give him up for adoption when I was pregnant, then when I finally did go after him for support, which didn't happen until my son was 5, he tried to lay the guilt trip on me, as if it's my fault I got pregnant in the first place and how hard it is for him now... blah blah blah. He was pleading his poverty case to the judge for like half an hour... over $50 a month... that doesn't even feed my son for a week!! He's a growing 12 year old boy... and I've got 4 younger kids besides him. My husband kills himself to support our family, and most years I only see 1 or 2 child support payments all year!
• United States
7 Oct 09
95% of the kids in this district qualify for free lunches but we dont even though after we pay his child support and our utility bills and mortgage we only have about $150 to raise 5 kids its not fair to my kids they deserve better! they deserve to be able to enjoy a hot meal with their friends at school they deserve to have the clothes they want and the chance to do the activities that they want It makes me feel horrible when I have to tell my child they cant go on the feild trip because we dont have the $5-$10 to pay but yet a sister they have never met gets $600 every month his ex-wife moved their daughter out of state making it virtually impossible for him to have his visitation with his daughter he hasnt seen his daughter in over 10 years when we finally located them a couple of years ago his daughter didnt want to be in his life because she was told that he abondandoned her and a whole bunch of other lies the child wont even give her father a chance to tell her what really happened
• United States
8 Oct 09
Oh no no no no no no no!!!! That defeniatly is not right! As far as I'm concerned that's theivery!!! You need to let your ex know what they did, he can demand HIS money back and then he can hand you the 50 bucks himself and no one can take it from you. I can't imagine them able to keep the money if he demands it back. It's his anyways (actually it's more yours) but since it never got to you because of teh interference it's still his.... Will he get involved if you tell him what they've done?
• United States
8 Oct 09
Oh boy! That's quite the situation! I'm sorry! :/ But still...there has to be something you can do! Who are they to say what he can or can not give in child support!? What if one month he just decided to give you 1,000 bucks!? Do they think they can take 950 bucks of it away?!?! No good thieves!!!!
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Oct 09
I have no idea if he'd get involved or not, but I have no way of contacting him. I've never had a way of contacting him... even child support doesn't have his real address or phone number. He gave them a friend's address. See, he was married at the time my son was concieved, so he's still trying to keep all of this a secret from his wife. He used to have my number and address and would call every so often and stuff, but then I moved and couldn't let him know, so we have no way of contacting each other.
1 person likes this
@lilybug (21107)
• United States
7 Oct 09
I have never had them keep money because either of my kids fathers were ahead in child support. I have had them hold a whopping $86 for an additional 6 MONTHS from my son's fathers federal tax return just to make sure his wife was not entitled to the money before they gave it to my son.
1 person likes this
@Bluepatch (2476)
• Trinidad And Tobago
7 Oct 09
Sometimes the government is like a business. They find reasons to take things from you. We, the plebs, are helpless against them and our votes hardly ever make the difference we need. That's life !
@dawnald (85137)
• Shingle Springs, California
7 Oct 09
Not yet, not yet... Well not my stories anyway. My brother-in-law had an agreement with his first wife for child support, $600. They changed it to $400 when she got a job, but he never got it in writing (stupid). So then she started drinking and bringing men home and he sued for custody. That, of course, is when she went after him for back child support, the difference between the $600 and the $400. But it ended up that enough people had heard her say she had agreed to lower it. Neither one of them won anything from that battle (except he got her to be more careful about her behavior around their daughter). The lawyers won (as usual)...
@dawnald (85137)
• Shingle Springs, California
7 Oct 09
PS No, it's not right...
@dawnald (85137)
• Shingle Springs, California
7 Oct 09
Heck no, I'd be the last person on the planet to blame you... I'm kind of surprised that his wife wouldn't know though. If there's a court order, it would be hard for her not to know. Sometimes it is easier for the father not to be involved. Oh the stories I could tell...
• United States
7 Oct 09
I'm so glad my biggest problem with my son's father is the child support! He wants nothing to do with us, and I'm happy to keep it that way. He was married when I met him (long story, and I was young so don't blame me) and I assume that to this day his wife still doesn't know about my son, and he wants to keep it that way. Like I said, fine by me. My hubby is "daddy" to my son, and hubby acts like a father to him too. If it weren't for the skin color and the last name you'd never know they weren't father and son. I like it that way.
1 person likes this
• United States
7 Oct 09
I don't see what the big problem is...if he never seems to pay then I would just be happy to have gotten any money at all especially that much at one time. It seems like the system is looking out for you...by keeping that extra $50 they are insuring that if he falls behind ago you will still get your $50 payment for at least that one month.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163772)
• Garden Grove, California
8 Oct 09
the big problem from my viewpoint is she needs a heck of a lot more than a measly fifty dollars, now how far is that' going to go with today's prices?
@cutepenguin (6430)
• Canada
7 Oct 09
I think that your child should be entitled to the money. It's sad that paperwork and rules can intrude on almost anything.
• Canada
9 Oct 09
There is definitely something off about that. If the guy wants to overpay, that's just great. However, the office may be trying to keep things neutral. Maybe the guy's trying to overpay, so as to throw them off, and if they (think) they are paying you more than they should, this might confuse all involved. I think that unless someone does what they are supposed to do, unless all people do as they are supposed to do, the situations is nothing but one bit Catch 22.
@sacmom (14192)
• United States
7 Oct 09
That doesn't seem right at all. Why does it even have to go through this place to begin with? I know that when my mom was receiving child support years ago for my sister and I my dad sent the check straight to her. There was no middle man, so to speak. So, you only get $50 a month for child support? Is that right, or did I miss something? And this is for how many children? Sorry, if I am being nosey. My mom was getting $250 a month per child ($500 total) for my sister and I. And here that was back then. By what I understand my dad should have been paying a lot more with the money he was making. But he apparently had a very good lawyer and that is what the court ordered him to pay. When my mom tried to demand alimony my dad threatened to take us kids away. And here he's the one that cheated on her. Talk about twisted. Gotta love the system. Good luck in getting that extra $50. Happy mylotting!
• United States
7 Oct 09
Yes it's $50 and it's for 1 child. It's how much he and another woman agreed he paid for her child, so I said that was fine with me too. This was back like 6 years ago when my only concern was finding him so he could sign his parental rights over to my husband... but we never got around to doing that.
1 person likes this
@sid556 (30953)
• United States
8 Oct 09
Ya, they have kept my child support back in the day when I occassionally got it. I would argue with them till I was blue and it did no good. Back then he only paid 25.00 per month because their records showed him as not working. He was really working under the table and doing quite fine financially. If he got behind (and he always did) they tacked on an extra 5.00 per week. If he messed up and paid more than that....they kept it claiming that he owed the state money!! What in the world does that have to do with my child support? I was raising 3 kids on my own at the time. What they should do is credit his account and send the money where it was intended. I went thru so much with the child support people over the years that I could write a book. Currently I have a 15 yr old still at home and I don't get any support at all. I could fight it but I've given up the battle.
@Hatley (163772)
• Garden Grove, California
8 Oct 09
katsmeow hi hatley here 50 a month that is lousy, but I am glad you got the 450 now but why didnt they just send you five hundred.well I think maybe you need to find a legal aid free lawyer to get what is really coming to you for your childs 'welfare as this just does not seem right to me. I have not had this experience myself but have hAd friends who had' to enlist legal help to get all that was due them for child support. he helped make the child so he has to support it, like' it or not.
@SomeCowgirl (32189)
• United States
7 Oct 09
That definitely doesn't sound fair for them to take the money. Although you don't believe he'll pay on time so you will see that money... the way they are doing it is almost like he gets a "free month" where he doesn't have to pay... I don't know. I think that I'd be putting out a complaint. Is he aware they did this? The full $500.00 should be going to your child...
@SomeCowgirl (32189)
• United States
7 Oct 09
Exactly, none of that money should be on "hold"... Do they not realize that it could be put to good use?
• United States
7 Oct 09
I'm not sure if he's aware or not, I have no way of contacting him and he never calls me. The child support payments are our only link to each other, so I'm clueless. I think my son should have all the money though, who cares if he overpaid...
1 person likes this